ADA Accommodations: A 5-Step Process for Small Employers
By John Hamilton, MS, PHRca, PHR · Reviewed for legal currency August 2026
I am not an attorney. This article is general information based on my experience as an HR professional, and it is not legal advice. For legal advice about your situation, consult a qualified attorney.
The short version
- A DMV placard is not an accommodation request, and an accommodation request does not have to use the word “accommodation.”
- Five steps: recognize the request, engage the interactive process, evaluate against essential functions, decide and document, follow through.
- The ADA applies at 15 employees. California’s FEHA applies at 5, and failing to engage in the interactive process is its own claim there.
A single wage claim or agency charge can cost more than several years of an HR subscription. Plans start at $139 a month. Call (562) 444-8076, email service@accomplicenter.com, or come by our store at 3217 Carson St in Lakewood to sign up.
An employee comes into your office. They lay a state-issued handicap placard on your desk and ask whether they can start parking in the closest spaces to the building. Maybe they say “I have a condition.” Maybe they don’t say anything more than that.
What do you do?
Most operators handle this one of two ways. They say yes: sure, no problem, take any spot you want. Or they say no: the closest spots are reserved for customers, sorry. Both are wrong. The right answer is a third one that takes a little longer and costs you almost nothing.
A handicap placard isn’t an ADA accommodation request
- A handicap placard from the DMV is one thing. An accommodation duty under the Americans with Disabilities Act is another. They can show up in the same conversation. They don’t mean the same thing.
- The DMV is asking a narrow question. Does this person have a condition that interferes with their ability to drive, or to get from their car to where they need to go? Limited mobility from a back injury, lung disease, cardiovascular disease, low vision. The DMV’s analysis ends there. A placard is a parking privilege based on a driving-related impairment.
- The ADA is asking a different question. It looks at whether the employee has a physical or mental impairment that substantially limits a major life activity, and then it looks at the employee’s job. What are the essential duties of the position? What accommodation, if any, would let the employee perform those essential duties? Would providing it cause undue hardship to the business?
- These two questions reach different conclusions. An employee can have a DMV placard and no ADA accommodation right at work, because the placard says nothing about whether their condition affects the essential duties of their job. An employee can also have a real ADA accommodation right at work and no placard, because their disability has nothing to do with mobility or driving.
An employee with a placard for low vision who works a desk job may have no ADA accommodation right at all. Their condition doesn’t affect any essential function of the work. An employee with severe anxiety who has never been near a DMV may have a strong ADA accommodation right at work.
Same person can have both. Same person can have one and not the other. The way you figure out which is by having a conversation. A real one, in writing, with a doctor’s input. That conversation is the interactive process.
Why slowing down matters
Most accommodation problems I’ve seen at small businesses don’t come from bad faith. They come from quick reactions. The owner wants to be a good boss, hears the request, says yes on the spot. Then the second request comes in, and the third, and now there’s no consistency, no documentation, and no defensible reason for why one employee got something the next one didn’t.
Or the opposite. The owner gets nervous, says no immediately, and now there’s an EEOC charge or a state-agency complaint on the desk because nobody asked the doctor what the employee actually needed.
The interactive process prevents both. It is deliberate and it is slow, and the same conversation that protects you legally is the one that tells your employee you take their situation seriously.
Step 1. Recognize the request
The request doesn’t have to use the word “accommodation.” It doesn’t have to mention the ADA. An employee saying “I’m having trouble standing for my whole shift” is making a request. So is “the fluorescent lights are giving me migraines.” So is laying a placard on your desk and asking about parking.
Train your managers to spot it. Formal or informal, written or verbal, the moment the request comes in your obligation starts and your timeline starts with it.
Step 2. Engage the interactive process
Hand the employee a set of accommodation request forms. Not because the paperwork is the point, but because the forms create a written record and tell the doctor what to address. The forms ask three things. What does the employee need. What limitations create the need. What does the doctor recommend.
Give the employee a deadline to return the forms. Fifteen business days is reasonable. Tell them in writing they can keep their current arrangement (parking, schedule, whatever it is) while the forms are being completed. That’s both a courtesy and a hedge. It protects you in case the doctor confirms the need.
I recently advised a manufacturing client in California whose HR specialist handled this almost perfectly. An employee came in and asked about parking closer to the building. She gave him the forms, told him his doctor needed to fill them out, and gave him fifteen days. She also told him plainly that the request had nothing to do with the DMV placard he showed her. She was treating it as a separate accommodation question, which is exactly right.
Step 3. Evaluate
When the doctor’s response comes back, you have something to work with. Compare the recommendation against the essential functions of the job and figure out whether the recommended accommodation, or a reasonable alternative, lets the employee perform those essential functions without undue hardship to the business.
Three terms in that sentence carry weight.
Essential functions are what you put in the job description. If your job descriptions don’t say what’s essential, fix that.
Reasonable alternative means you don’t have to grant the exact accommodation requested if a different one works. The employee is entitled to an effective accommodation, not a specific one.
Undue hardship is a high bar. It isn’t “this is inconvenient.” It’s “this fundamentally disrupts how the business operates.” Cost matters, but a reasonable accommodation that costs a few hundred dollars at a 12-employee shop will rarely qualify as undue hardship on its own.
Step 4. Decide and document
Decide. Write the decision down. Send it to the employee in writing.
If you’re granting the accommodation, spell out the terms. What’s being granted, when it starts, how long it lasts, what the employee’s responsibilities are. If you’re denying it, spell out the reason. If you’re offering an alternative, spell that out too.
The documentation is the entire point. It’s how you show, six months from now or six years from now, that you engaged in good faith. Without it, you’re standing in front of a hearing officer telling a story. With it, you’re handing them a file.
Step 5. Follow through and revisit
If you granted an accommodation, monitor it. If circumstances change, revisit. The employee’s condition might have shifted. The job’s requirements might have changed. You might have grown. Accommodations aren’t lifetime contracts. They’re a snapshot of what works right now.
What if the employee doesn’t hold up their end
Back to the manufacturing client. The employee took the forms in November. He didn’t return them. The HR specialist followed up in December. He said he was busy with school and would get to the doctor’s appointment soon. She said please keep us updated. He still didn’t return the forms.
By March, four months after the original meeting, he was still parking in handicap spaces without an authorized accommodation. He got a written warning for the unauthorized parking. He refused to sign. He said other employees parked there too. He said singling him out wasn’t fair.
The advice I gave the company was that the warning was perfectly valid. His refusal to sign didn’t change anything. The November interactive-process meeting had superseded any informal parking arrangement he claimed had existed. And the company’s documented good-faith engagement was the reason the discipline would hold up if it ever got challenged. Handing him forms, giving him a deadline, following up in December, waiting four months. All of it was the file.
I also told them to verify that the same standard was being applied to anyone else parking in handicap spaces without authorization. His “others do it too” argument was legally weak, but inconsistent enforcement would have undermined the company in front of an investigator. Equal application of the rule was the missing piece.
This is what the interactive process actually does. It protects you from the small number of employees who try to use accommodation requests as cover. It also preserves your relationship with the much larger number of employees who do hold up their end, because the standard is consistent, the process is fair, and the documentation says so.
Following the law here isn’t just defensive. It’s how you treat your good people the way they deserve to be treated.
State-by-state quick notes
Federal ADA: applies at 15 or more employees. Definition of disability under the 2008 amendments is broad and covers a wide range of physical and mental impairments. Interactive process is required by EEOC regulation.
California (FEHA): applies at 5 or more employees. The state’s definition of disability is broader than federal. There’s no “substantial limitation” requirement. The interactive process is explicit in California regulation, and the failure to engage in it is itself an independent claim an employee can bring.
New York and New Jersey: state disability law reaches every employer, down to one employee. Washington: eight or more. All three define disability more broadly than the ADA does.
Other states: many go lower than 15. Minnesota, Michigan, Colorado, Alaska and Hawaii cover all employers. Connecticut starts at three. New Mexico, Ohio, Pennsylvania and Rhode Island at four. Oregon at six for disability. Check your state before you assume the federal 15 applies.
What this looks like in your manual
Five steps. Recognize the request. Engage the interactive process. Evaluate. Decide and document. Follow through.
Your manual should have a written accommodation policy that lays this process out for your managers in language they’ll actually use when a request comes in. The custom employee manual that comes with every AccompliCenter HR subscription includes exactly that: a state-tailored accommodation policy plus the forms your managers need to start the conversation. Plans start at $139 a month, and the manual is built for someone who runs a business, not for someone who reads regulations for fun.
To subscribe, call us at (562) 444-8076, stop by our store at 3217 Carson St in Lakewood, or email service@accomplicenter.com.
See AccompliCenter HR plans →