HR Consulting

blogheader

Discipline and Termination for Small Employers

I am not an attorney. These articles are general information based on my experience as an HR professional, and they are not legal advice. For legal advice about your situation, consult a qualified attorney.

The Termination Checklist: 12 Steps Before You Let Someone Go

The short version

  • Before the meeting: verify the reason in writing, check the last 90 days for protected activity, check consistency across employees, confirm leave status, and calculate final pay.
  • If you are in a day-of-discharge state, the check has to be in your hand when you walk in.
  • Document the meeting within 24 hours, and investigate anything the employee raised during it.

If this article raised a question about your own business, that is what our subscription is for. Plans start at $139 a month. Call (562) 444-8076, email service@accomplicenter.com, or come by our store at 3217 Carson St in Lakewood to sign up.

You’ve decided to terminate someone. The decision feels right. You’ve thought about it. You’ve talked to people. You’re ready.

Stop. Before the meeting, work through this list. Each step has a reason behind it, and skipping any one of them is the kind of thing that turns a clean termination into a wrongful-termination claim.

The pre-termination questions (steps 1 through 5)

Step 1. Verify the reason holds up in writing

If you had to explain in court why this employee is being terminated, what would you say. Write it down. Read it. Does it match the documentation in the file. Is it specific. Is it tied to behavior or performance, not personality. Does it apply consistently to similarly situated employees, or are you about to fire this person for something other employees do without consequence.

If the answer to any of these is shaky, fix it before the meeting. Get the documentation in order. If the file doesn’t support the termination, the meeting isn’t ready yet.

Step 2. Check the recent timeline

Look at the last 90 days of the employee’s history. Did they recently file a complaint, request an accommodation, take protected leave, refuse to do something they thought was unlawful, or report a workplace safety concern. If yes, the timing is going to look retaliatory regardless of your actual reasons. You can still terminate, but the file needs to be much stronger to overcome the timing inference, and you should walk through this with your lawyer before the meeting.

Step 3. Check protected-class implications

Is the employee in a protected class. Are similarly situated employees outside that class being treated the same way for the same conduct. If you’ve terminated three employees this year and all three are in the same protected class while non-class employees with similar conduct have not been terminated, you have a disparate-treatment problem. Run this check before the meeting, not after.

Step 4. Confirm the leave status

Is the employee currently on FMLA, state family leave, pregnancy leave, ADA leave-as-accommodation, or workers’ compensation leave. Termination during protected leave isn’t categorically prohibited, but it requires documentation that the termination decision was made independent of the leave and would have happened regardless. Verify before the meeting.

Step 5. Calculate the final pay

What does the employee receive on the day of termination. Regular wages through the termination date. Overtime if applicable. Accrued and unused PTO if your state or your handbook requires payout. Earned commissions or bonuses. Reimbursable expenses. Add it all up. Have payroll prepare a paper check (or a same-day direct deposit if your state allows it). The check needs to be in your hand at the meeting.

If you’re in California, Colorado, Massachusetts, Missouri or Nevada, payment is due on the day of discharge. Montana requires it immediately on a for-cause discharge or layoff unless a written personnel policy extends the deadline. Utah gives you 24 hours. Hawaii allows the next working day where the circumstances genuinely prevent immediate payment. Minnesota requires payment within 24 hours of the employee’s demand. The check has to be ready before you walk into the meeting.

The meeting (steps 6 through 9)

Step 6. Set the meeting deliberately

Pick a quiet time. Pick a private place. Plan to have a second person present (typically an HR designee or another manager) as a witness. The meeting should be short, factual, and respectful. It is not a debate. The decision has been made.

The script is straightforward. State the decision. State the effective date (today, in most cases). State the reason briefly without belaboring it. Hand over the final paycheck. Hand over any separation paperwork. Answer logistical questions about benefits and unemployment. Don’t get drawn into a discussion of the merits of the decision.

Step 7. Provide separation paperwork

State law and federal law require certain paperwork at termination. The list varies by state, but typically includes:

The final paycheck itself. A COBRA notice if you have group health coverage and 20 or more employees, or a state mini-COBRA notice if you have fewer (about forty states have one; California’s is Cal-COBRA, covering employers with 2 to 19 employees). The state unemployment notice (required in many states). A termination letter or notice of separation if your state or your handbook requires one. A return-of-property checklist (laptop, keys, badge, uniforms, vehicle, etc.). Any state-specific forms (California has the Notice to Employee as to Change in Relationship; New York has separation notices; others vary).

Have all of this assembled in a folder before the meeting. Hand it over at the meeting.

Step 8. Recover company property

Keys, badges, laptops, phones, vehicles, uniforms, samples, customer lists, anything else that belongs to the company. Recover it at the meeting if possible. If not possible (a remote employee, equipment at the employee’s home), set a clear plan for return with a written deadline and follow up.

Step 9. Address access immediately

Email access, computer system access, building access, customer-facing accounts. All of it should be terminated by the end of the meeting (preferably before the meeting starts, so the employee can’t access systems after they know they’re being terminated). Coordinate with IT in advance. Same for physical access (badges, keys).

The post-termination follow-up (steps 10 through 12)

Step 10. Document the meeting

Within 24 hours, write a contemporaneous note about what was said in the meeting. Who attended. What you said. What the employee said. Any objections or claims raised. Any commitments made (return of property by a specific date, etc.). This goes in the file.

If the employee said something that should be investigated (a discrimination complaint, a safety concern, a wage claim), the meeting note triggers that investigation. Don’t ignore complaints raised during termination meetings. They’re sometimes genuine, and ignoring them creates additional liability separate from the termination itself.

Step 11. Handle the unemployment claim

The employee will likely file for unemployment. Your decision on whether to contest depends on the facts. If the termination was for misconduct meeting the state’s standard, you can contest and may prevail. If the termination was for performance issues that don’t rise to misconduct, contesting is usually a waste of time. (We wrote a separate post on the contest decision.)

Either way, when the unemployment notice arrives, respond on time. Late responses can default in favor of the employee and sometimes create additional issues.

Step 12. Communicate to the team appropriately

Tell the team the employee is no longer with the company. Don’t elaborate on why. “Effective today, [name] is no longer with the company. We thank them for their service. [New person or coverage plan].” That’s it.

If team members ask why, the answer is “I’m not going to discuss the specifics.” Repeat as needed.

This is also where you address any operational gaps the termination creates. Who covers the work. Who responds to the customers. What happens to in-progress projects. The departure shouldn’t disrupt the business if the planning was done in advance.

What to do if the meeting goes sideways

Most termination meetings go cleanly. Some don’t. The employee gets emotional. The employee starts to argue. The employee threatens to sue. The employee refuses to leave the building.

Stay calm. Don’t argue back. Don’t escalate. Repeat what was said: “The decision has been made. We’re going to need you to gather your things and exit the building.” If the employee won’t leave, you can call building security or, in extreme cases, local police for a peaceful escort. Have a plan in advance.

Don’t change the decision under emotional pressure. Don’t promise anything you don’t intend to deliver. Don’t get drawn into a debate. The decision was made before the meeting started, and the meeting is for communicating it, not deciding it.

If the employee threatens to sue, acknowledge it briefly (“I understand. We’ve made this decision in good faith.”) and continue. Don’t apologize, don’t admit anything, don’t make new statements about the merits. Move forward with the steps.

What this looks like in your manual

Your handbook should include a termination procedure that lays out the company’s approach. The procedure doesn’t have to be a script, but it should reference:

The final-pay timing and content. The separation paperwork required by your state. The return-of-property expectation. The access-termination protocol. The protocol for communicating to the team.

We include a state-tailored termination procedure in the custom employee manual that comes with every AccompliCenter HR subscription. The procedure is what your managers reach for when they need to do this and don’t do it often. Plans start at $139 a month.

Termination is one of the parts of the job that nobody enjoys. Done with the checklist, it’s clean. Done without, it’s the most expensive mistake a small employer can make.

This article is general information, not legal advice. For legal advice about your situation, consult a qualified attorney.

Back to the list of articles

How to Document a Performance Problem So It Holds Up Later

The short version

  • The test is whether a jury reading your documentation would see what you saw.
  • Good documentation is specific, contemporaneous, behavioral, tied to a written standard, and includes the employee’s response.
  • A file full of praise followed by a sudden termination is the single most common documentation failure.

Fixing an HR mistake after the fact costs more than preventing it. Subscriptions start at $139 a month, and every plan includes a custom employee manual. Call (562) 444-8076, email service@accomplicenter.com, or come by our store at 3217 Carson St in Lakewood to sign up.

The most expensive employment decisions a small employer makes are termination decisions, and the most common reason termination decisions go wrong is bad documentation. The performance issue is usually real. The conversations with the employee usually happened. The expectations usually were communicated. None of it ends up in writing in a form that holds up later.

The “would this email convince a jury” test

Pretend the documentation you just wrote is going to be projected on a screen in front of a jury. The jury has never met you, doesn’t know your business, has no priors about the employee. They can read what you wrote, and that’s all the information they have about the situation.

Would they see what you saw. Would they understand the behavior was a problem. Would they conclude the employee knew what was expected and fell short. Would they see the company as having handled the situation in good faith.

If yes, the documentation is doing its job. If no, the documentation isn’t going to survive the moment when it gets used.

It’s the same test an arbitrator, a hearing officer, an EEOC investigator, or a state agency will apply. Could a reasonable third party read this and conclude what you concluded.

What good documentation includes

  • Specifics, not generalities. “John was unprofessional with a customer” is general. “On October 15 at approximately 2 PM, John raised his voice to a customer who asked for a refund. The customer (Jane Smith, order 4721) reported that John told her the policy was clearly posted and she should have read it. John used a dismissive tone for several minutes. The customer left without resolution and posted a negative review the same evening” is specific.
  • Contemporaneous, not after-the-fact. Documentation written within 24 to 48 hours of the event is contemporaneous. Documentation written six months later because someone is now considering termination is not contemporaneous. The contemporaneous version carries weight. The after-the-fact version looks like manufactured evidence.
  • Behavioral, not personal. “John was rude” is a personality conclusion. “John raised his voice and used dismissive language with a customer” is a behavior. Behavior is documentable. Personality isn’t.
  • Tied to the job description or written standards. The behavior or performance issue should connect to a specific expectation. “John’s customer service didn’t meet the standard in the job description, which states that customer-facing staff will treat all customers with professionalism and resolve issues constructively.” The standard is the anchor.
  • Includes the employee’s response. What the employee said when the issue was raised. Did they acknowledge it. Did they dispute it. Did they offer context. Did they propose a solution. The employee’s response is part of the file.
  • Includes any commitments or follow-up. What was decided in the conversation. What the employee committed to do differently. What the company committed to (training, support, etc.). What the next check-in or review will look like.

What bad documentation looks like

“Talked to John about his attitude.” No specifics, no behavior, no standard, no follow-up.

“John needs to improve.” Conclusion without evidence.

“Several customers have complained about John.” Aggregated claim without specifics.

“John has been a problem for a while.” Vague timeline, no events.

Documentation written six months after the events occurred, drafted to support a termination decision that’s already been made. The reverse-engineered file. Easy to spot. Doesn’t survive scrutiny.

Documentation that’s inconsistent with other contemporaneous records (positive performance reviews, no prior write-ups, manager praise in emails). The kind of inconsistency that destroys credibility.

The structure of a good written record

A performance documentation note should include, in some order:

Date and time of the event or conversation.

  • Who was involved. The employee. The manager. Any witnesses. Any customers or other parties.
  • What happened. Specific behavior, specific words if possible, specific outcomes.
  • Why it’s a problem. Connection to the job description, to a written policy, to a customer or operational impact.
  • What was discussed. The conversation between the manager and the employee, including the employee’s response.
  • What’s expected going forward. Specific behavior, specific outcomes, specific timeframes.
  • Any commitments. What the employee said they would do. What the company will provide.
  • Follow-up date. When the next check-in will happen.

A documentation note in this structure runs maybe 200 to 400 words. It’s not a thesis. It’s a record.

The conversation matters as much as the document

Documentation captures a conversation. The conversation has to actually happen, and it has to be the kind of conversation that the documentation reflects.

This means: when an issue arises, talk to the employee. Don’t wait. Don’t accumulate issues silently and spring them in a termination meeting. Address each issue close to when it happens. Have the conversation. Document the conversation. Move on.

This pattern, repeated, is what builds the file that supports a termination decision when one becomes necessary. It’s also what often prevents the termination, because employees who get clear, contemporaneous feedback often correct the issue.

The praise problem

Operators who later have to fire someone often have a track record of praising that same employee in writing. Positive performance reviews. “Great job!” emails. Holiday bonuses. Promotion considerations. Then, six months after the last positive communication, a termination.

This pattern is the single biggest documentation problem I see. The praise undermines the eventual termination. A jury reading the file sees positive feedback up to a few months before the firing, with no negative documentation in between, and concludes that something other than performance must have caused the change. That something often gets identified as a protected reason.

The fix is to give honest performance feedback throughout the relationship. If performance has been mixed, the reviews should reflect that. If issues arise, they get documented when they arise, not retroactively. The file should match reality.

This doesn’t mean withholding praise. Praise good work. Document accurately. Reviews should reflect the actual performance, including the parts that need improvement. A balanced review that’s honest about strengths and weaknesses survives scrutiny in a way that all-positive-then-suddenly-fired doesn’t.

The performance improvement plan

A formal performance improvement plan (PIP) is a documentation tool that structures the response to a sustained performance issue. The PIP includes:

The specific performance gaps, with examples and standards.

The expectations going forward, with measurable goals.

The timeframe, typically 30 to 90 days.

The support the company will provide, like training, coaching, additional resources.

The check-in cadence, typically weekly or biweekly.

The consequences of not meeting the standard, typically termination.

The employee’s signature acknowledging receipt (not agreement, just receipt).

A PIP done well is a tool for either improvement (sometimes the employee turns it around) or for clean termination (the file is unambiguous). A PIP done poorly is a fig leaf the company puts on a termination decision that was already made, and juries see through this.

The test for a good PIP is whether the company actually wants the employee to succeed. If yes, the PIP is structured to help them succeed and the company invests in the support. If no (the company has decided to terminate and is going through the motions), the PIP is theater and shouldn’t be used.

What this looks like in your manual

Your handbook should have a performance management section that:

References the standards (job descriptions, policies) against which performance is measured. Describes the company’s approach to performance feedback (regular check-ins, periodic reviews). Describes the discipline structure (with “may” rather than “will” language). References the PIP as a tool for sustained issues. Confirms that documentation will be created throughout the relationship.

We include this in the custom employee manual that comes with every AccompliCenter HR subscription. The section ties to the job descriptions, the discipline policy, and the termination procedure. Plans start at $139 a month.

The skills of documenting performance well are practiced. Most managers are uncomfortable writing critical things about employees, even when the criticism is warranted. The discomfort is part of the job. The cost of not documenting is the lawsuit that the documentation would have prevented or shortened.

This article is general information, not legal advice. For legal advice about your situation, consult a qualified attorney.

Back to the list of articles

Unemployment Claims: When to Contest and When to Let It Go

The short version

  • Contest a claim only when the facts meet your state’s misconduct standard and you have the documentation. Both, or neither.
  • Most performance terminations do not rise to misconduct, so contesting them wastes time and can produce findings used against you later.
  • California employers also lost 1.2 percent of the FUTA credit for tax year 2025, an extra $84 per employee.

Employment law is complicated, and one mistake can cost far more than a year of help. An AccompliCenter HR subscription starts at $139 a month. Call (562) 444-8076, email service@accomplicenter.com, or come by our store at 3217 Carson St in Lakewood to sign up.

You just terminated an employee. A few weeks later, you receive a notice from the state unemployment agency. The employee has filed for benefits. You have a deadline (typically 10 to 14 days) to respond. The form asks whether you want to contest the claim.

What you do here matters. Contest the wrong claims and you waste time, lose anyway, and possibly invite scrutiny of your termination practices. Concede the wrong claims and your unemployment insurance rate goes up over time, which compounds into real money.

How unemployment works for employers

Unemployment insurance is a state-by-state program funded by employer payroll taxes. The federal floor is set by FUTA (Federal Unemployment Tax Act); states administer their own programs with their own rules.

Your unemployment insurance rate is “experience-rated.” This means your rate is set partly based on the unemployment claims paid out to your former employees. More claims, higher rate. Fewer claims, lower rate. The exact rate calculation varies by state, but the principle is universal: claims affect your rate.

Within the rate calculation, the state distinguishes between charges that are “non-charged” (the state pays the benefit but doesn’t charge it against your account) and “charged” (the benefit is charged to your account). The distinction depends on why the employee separated and whether you contested the claim successfully.

In general:

A successful contest of misconduct or voluntary quit results in the claim being non-charged.

A claim that’s paid because the separation was a layoff, a termination without cause, or a quit with good cause is charged.

The math is real but moves slowly. A single claim might shift your rate by a fraction of a percent, which over time compounds. For a small employer with a small claim history, individual claims matter more than for a large employer where any single claim is a small fraction of total claim volume.

One number makes this concrete for California employers. California has owed the federal government money for unemployment benefits since 2020, and the penalty comes out of the FUTA credit. For tax year 2025, paid with the Form 940 due January 31, 2026, California employers lost 1.2 percent of the credit: a net federal rate of 1.8 percent instead of 0.6 percent, or an extra $84 per employee. The Department of Labor sets the 2026 figure in November 2026, and it rises if the loan is still outstanding. That sits on top of whatever your state experience rating does.

When to contest

Contest a claim when both of the following are true:

The facts support a successful contest. The standard varies by state, but the general categories that lead to successful contests are misconduct (a serious violation of company policy or rule), voluntary resignation without good cause attributable to the employer, or refusal of suitable work.

You have documentation supporting your position. Memory and verbal accounts don’t carry weight in unemployment hearings. Written warnings, signed acknowledgments, performance documentation, witness statements, time records. The contemporaneous file is what carries the day.

The intersection of these two is where contesting makes sense. If both are present, contest. If either is missing, let it go.

When to let it go

Let the claim go when any of the following is true:

The separation was a layoff or position elimination. Not the employee’s fault. The unemployment program exists for exactly this situation. Contesting is a waste of time.

The performance issues were real but not at the level of misconduct. Most performance terminations don’t rise to misconduct under unemployment standards. The employee was underperforming, you let them go, but they weren’t engaged in willful misconduct or gross neglect. The benefit will likely be paid regardless of whether you contest.

The documentation isn’t there. Even if the facts support a contest, you can’t win without documentation. Trying invites a hearing where you’ll lose, and the loss can produce findings that get used against you in any subsequent litigation by the same employee.

The employee resigned with what they’ll claim was good cause. Constructive discharge cases (where the employee resigns because conditions made staying intolerable) are usually losers from the employer’s perspective. The employee will argue the conditions were intolerable. The hearing officer will likely give them benefit of the doubt unless your documentation is unusually strong.

The amount at stake is small relative to the cost of contesting. A short-tenure employee with a low wage may produce a claim that’s small enough that contesting (with management time, document assembly, hearing preparation, possibly attorney involvement) costs more than the rate impact of conceding.

How to contest effectively when you do contest

Three steps.

Respond to the initial notice on time, with the relevant facts. The state agency sends an initial determination questionnaire. Answer it completely. Provide the dates, the specifics, the reasons. Attach the relevant documentation (final warning, signed acknowledgment of policy, etc.). The initial response often determines the outcome without a hearing.

Prepare for the hearing if one is scheduled. Many states schedule a hearing if either party requests one, or if the initial determination is appealed. Hearings are typically conducted by phone, last 30 to 60 minutes, and follow rules of evidence loosely. Prepare your witness list, organize your documents, brief the witnesses on what they’ll be asked.

Present the case clearly. Hearing officers handle dozens of these cases a week. They’re not going to dig through a chaotic file. Present a clean, organized account: here’s what the policy was, here’s the employee’s signed acknowledgment, here’s the documented violation, here’s the employee’s response, here’s the termination decision and why.

If you’re uncomfortable representing yourself at the hearing, an HR consultant or attorney can represent the company. The cost varies. For a small claim, it’s often not worth it. For a large claim or one with patterns that affect future cases, it can be.

The misconduct standard

The standard for misconduct varies by state but generally requires more than ordinary unsatisfactory performance. The employee has to have engaged in willful or wanton disregard of the employer’s interests, or gross negligence, or deliberate violation of a known policy or rule. California is representative and strict: the employer has to show a material duty owed to the employer, a substantial breach of that duty, willful or wanton disregard, and a breach that tends to injure the employer’s interests. All four. A discharge that was entirely justified is not automatically misconduct.

Examples that typically meet the standard:

Theft, fraud, or other criminal conduct related to the job. Insubordination (refusal of a direct lawful order). Repeated violations of safety rules. Repeated tardiness or absenteeism after multiple warnings, where the employee was clearly aware of the standard and the consequences. Workplace violence or threats. Significant policy violations (drug use, harassment, etc.) where the policy was known.

Examples that typically don’t meet the standard:

Poor performance over time without specific willful conduct. Single incidents of judgment errors, even when consequential. Personality conflicts with management. Inability to learn the job or keep up with the workload. Failure to meet sales targets or production goals due to factors not entirely within the employee’s control.

The line is fuzzy and varies by state. The general principle: misconduct requires fault on the employee’s part beyond ordinary failure to perform.

The voluntary-quit-with-good-cause issue

When an employee resigns, the question becomes whether they had good cause. Good cause attributable to the employer (intolerable working conditions, unsafe workplace, harassment that the employer didn’t address, material change in compensation or duties) typically results in benefits being paid. Good cause not attributable to the employer (personal reasons, transportation, family situation) typically doesn’t.

This is the area where employers most often get tripped up by what the employee said in their last conversation. If the employee said they were quitting because of “stress” or “I just can’t take it anymore” or “the way [manager] treats me,” the employee will likely frame this as good cause attributable to the employer. The employer’s documentation needs to show otherwise.

What this looks like in your manual

The handbook itself doesn’t directly contest unemployment claims, but several handbook elements support successful contests:

A clear discipline policy that establishes expectations. A documented complaint procedure (so resignation-citing-conditions claims can be checked against whether the employee actually used the procedure). A clear policy against the kinds of conduct that constitute misconduct. Acknowledgment forms that establish employees were aware of policies.

We include all of this in the custom employee manual that comes with every AccompliCenter HR subscription. The handbook gives you the foundation; the day-to-day documentation builds on it. Plans start at $139 a month.

If you’re getting unemployment claims and you’re not sure whether to contest each one, the framework above is the starting point. The math is sometimes counterintuitive: contesting fewer claims, but contesting them well, often produces a better long-term rate outcome than contesting everything reflexively.

This article is general information, not legal advice. For legal advice about your situation, consult a qualified attorney.

Back to the list of articles

How to Fire an Employee Without Getting Sued

The short version

  • Run the proximity test. Any complaint, accommodation request, protected leave or safety report in the last 90 days makes the timing look retaliatory.
  • Ames v. Ohio Department of Youth Services removed the extra hurdle for majority-group plaintiffs in 2025, so the consistency check now runs in every direction.
  • Pair any severance with a properly drafted release, and keep confidentiality and non-disparagement clauses narrow.

You do not have to work through these rules alone. Our HR subscribers email or call us whenever a question comes up, and plans start at $139 a month. Call (562) 444-8076, email service@accomplicenter.com, or come by our store at 3217 Carson St in Lakewood to sign up.

You can fire any employee, at any time, for any lawful reason, in 49 of 50 states. That’s the theory of at-will employment. In practice, whether the reason was lawful is exactly the question that ends up in front of a jury, an arbitrator, or an agency investigator after the firing.

The Termination Checklist (post #24) covers the procedural steps. The legal traps underneath them are what turn an otherwise ordinary termination into a wrongful-termination claim.

The categories of unlawful termination

Most wrongful-termination claims fall into one of these categories. Knowing them helps you spot when a planned termination might trigger one.

  • Discrimination based on protected class. You can’t fire someone because of their race, color, religion, sex (including pregnancy, sexual orientation, and gender identity), national origin, age (40+ federally; some states protect younger), disability, genetic information, or any other category your state protects. The discrimination doesn’t have to be intentional or stated. A firing that has a disparate impact on a protected class can be challenged even when the stated reason is neutral.
  • Retaliation for protected activity. You can’t fire someone because they filed a complaint, supported someone else’s complaint, requested an accommodation, took protected leave, refused to do something they reasonably believed was unlawful, raised a safety concern, or exercised any other statutorily protected right. Retaliation claims are the fastest-growing category of employment claims at the federal and state agencies, and they’re often easier to win for the employee than discrimination claims because the timing of the firing tells the story.
  • Public-policy violation. You can’t fire someone for a reason that violates public policy. The categories vary by state, but typically include filing a workers’ compensation claim, refusing to commit a crime, exercising civic duties (jury duty, voting, military service), and reporting illegal activity to authorities.
  • FMLA interference or retaliation. If FMLA applies to you and your employee was using it or was eligible to use it, you can’t fire them in connection with the leave.
  • ADA or state-disability-law issues. Termination of an employee with a disability, an employee who recently requested accommodation, or an employee on disability leave can implicate the ADA and state-disability-law analogs.
  • Implied contract. If your offer letter, your handbook, or your manager’s verbal promises created an implied contract (we covered the five phrases that do this in post #8 on at-will employment), termination outside the implied terms is breach of contract.
  • Wage and hour violations connected to termination. If the termination is preceded or followed by improper handling of final pay, accrued PTO, or commissions owed, the wage claim attaches to the termination as a separate cause of action.

The proximity test

The single most important pre-termination question is the proximity test. Look at the employee’s history in the past 90 days, with extra weight on the past 30 days. Did any of the following happen:

The employee filed a complaint (about anything: harassment, discrimination, safety, wages, working conditions, anything). The employee supported someone else’s complaint, was named as a witness, or participated in an investigation. The employee requested an accommodation under the ADA, the PWFA, or a religious accommodation. The employee took protected leave (FMLA, state family leave, pregnancy leave, military, jury, etc.). The employee filed a workers’ compensation claim. The employee raised a workplace safety concern. The employee refused to do something on grounds that they thought it was unlawful.

If any of these happened in the past 90 days, the timing of a termination is going to look retaliatory. You can still terminate, but the file needs to be much stronger. Specifically:

The reason for termination must be documented and clear. The reason must be tied to behavior or performance that pre-dates the protected activity, or to behavior that’s so serious it stands on its own (a clear policy violation, a safety incident, a customer complaint, etc.). The decision-maker should be able to show, in writing, that the decision was made independent of the protected activity. Other employees with similar issues should have been treated similarly.

If you can’t satisfy these on a proximity-test termination, talk to a lawyer before pulling the trigger. The cost of a 30-minute call with employment counsel is small. The cost of a retaliation claim is large.

The disparate-treatment check

Pull a list of every employee terminated in the past 18 to 24 months, along with the reason. Compare the protected-class status of the terminated employees to the protected-class status of the remaining workforce. If terminations are disproportionately concentrated in one or more protected classes, you have an exposure that exists independent of the specific termination you’re considering.

The same exercise can be done at the discipline level (formal warnings, performance improvement plans, suspensions). If discipline is being administered disproportionately to a protected class, the termination at the end of that discipline path inherits the same exposure.

The fix isn’t to never terminate employees in protected classes. The fix is to make sure the discipline and termination decisions are being made consistently across employees, regardless of class. That means the same conduct gets the same response, the same performance gets the same review, the same standards apply to everyone.

Two Supreme Court decisions changed the arithmetic here since 2024. In Ames v. Ohio Department of Youth Services, decided June 5, 2025, the Court held unanimously that a majority-group plaintiff no longer has to show “background circumstances” to get a discrimination claim past the starting line. Five circuits had required it. A white employee, a male employee, a non-disabled employee now clears the same bar as anyone else, which means the consistency check runs in every direction and not just the one you were watching. And in Muldrow v. City of St. Louis, decided in April 2024, the Court held that a discriminatory transfer needs only “some harm” to a term or condition of employment, not significant harm. Lateral moves, shift changes and performance improvement plans carry more exposure than they used to. Retaliation claims keep the older, higher standard.

The performance-issue trap

Performance-issue terminations are the largest single category of small-employer terminations and the most common source of wrongful-termination claims. The trap is that the operator usually has a real performance issue, but the documentation doesn’t support it, and the absence of documentation makes the termination look like pretext for something else.

The pattern I see most often is this. The employee has been a problem for months. The owner has talked to them about it informally. There’s no written record of the conversations. Eventually the owner decides enough is enough and terminates. The employee files a claim. The owner’s defense is “their performance was bad.” The employee’s response is “no it wasn’t, my reviews were fine, no one ever told me there was a problem.” The case goes to a jury, and the jury has to choose between the owner’s word and the employee’s word, with no contemporaneous documentation supporting either.

The owner often wins on the merits, but the cost of getting there can be tens of thousands of dollars. And sometimes the jury chooses the employee.

The fix is documentation, contemporaneous, in writing, throughout the employment. Performance reviews on a regular cadence, with specific examples and specific expectations going forward. Documented conversations when problems arise. A performance improvement plan with measurable goals when issues persist. A paper trail that supports the eventual termination if it comes to that.

We wrote a separate post on documenting performance problems (#25). The short version: write things down, in real time, with specifics, against the standards in the job description.

The “for cause” trap

Some operators want to fire employees “for cause” because they think it sounds stronger or it justifies denying severance or unemployment benefits.

Two problems. First, in an at-will state with at-will language, you don’t need cause. The cause framing is a holdover from contract employment that doesn’t serve the at-will posture. Second, claiming cause invites the employee to challenge whether the cause was met, which turns the case into a debate about the merits of your reason rather than a debate about whether you had a legal right to terminate.

Better approach: terminate at-will, document the reasons in the file, don’t make claims about “cause” you don’t need to make. The unemployment determination is separate (and is decided by the state agency based on whether the conduct meets the state’s misconduct standard, regardless of what you call it).

What about severance

Severance is a tool that’s underused by small employers. A few weeks of pay in exchange for a written release of claims is often the cheapest way to close out a termination cleanly. The math works whenever the cost of severance is less than the cost of defending a claim, even a meritless one.

A severance offer should always be paired with a written release. The release should cover all federal, state, and local employment claims (including ADA, ADEA, Title VII, FMLA, FLSA, state equivalents). Some special rules apply:

For employees age 40 and over, the federal Older Workers Benefit Protection Act requires specific language giving the employee 21 days to consider the release (45 days in a group termination) and 7 days to revoke after signing.

State-specific releases sometimes require additional language. California’s release should include a Civil Code section 1542 waiver. Other states have similar specifics.

A release without the right language doesn’t release. Get the document right.

One more drafting trap. Broad confidentiality and non-disparagement clauses in severance agreements can violate the National Labor Relations Act, and under the Board’s McLaren Macomb decision merely offering them is a violation. The rule reaches non-supervisory employees whether or not there is a union. The General Counsel memo explaining how to write narrow clauses was rescinded in February 2025, but the decision itself is still binding Board law. Keep the clauses narrow and carve out protected activity.

The severance amount is negotiable. Common range is one to two weeks of pay per year of service, with a minimum of two to four weeks. The amount that closes the matter depends on the facts of the specific case. For a clean termination of a recent hire, severance may not be necessary. For a termination of a long-tenured employee with potential exposure, severance is often the smart play.

What this looks like in your manual

Your handbook should include:

A clear at-will statement (front and acknowledgment). A discipline policy that uses “may” rather than “will” for any non-mandatory step. A reference to the termination checklist procedure. A complaint procedure that gives employees a path to raise concerns before they become claims.

The handbook is the document that makes a termination defensible when it happens. The complaint procedure is the document that sometimes prevents the termination from being necessary in the first place, by surfacing issues early.

We include all of this in the custom employee manual that comes with every AccompliCenter HR subscription. State-specific, integrated with the discipline framework, and aligned with the proximity-test and disparate-treatment checks above. Plans start at $139 a month.

Firing someone is the highest-stakes employment decision a small employer makes. Done well, it’s clean, defensible, and behind you in a week. Done poorly, it’s the lawsuit that takes two years to resolve and costs more than the employee ever cost you while they were on the payroll.

The decision is yours. The work to make it clean starts before the meeting and continues after.

This article is general information, not legal advice. For legal advice about your situation, consult a qualified attorney.

Back to the list of articles

Can I Fire an Employee for No Reason?

The short version

  • Technically yes in 49 states. Practically, no.
  • Firing for “no reason” lets the employee supply the reason, and most employees are in at least one protected class.
  • Document a behavioral, contemporaneous, consistently applied reason even when the law does not require one. A genuine layoff or position elimination is the exception.

A single wage claim or agency charge can cost more than several years of an HR subscription. Plans start at $139 a month. Call (562) 444-8076, email service@accomplicenter.com, or come by our store at 3217 Carson St in Lakewood to sign up.

This is one of the most-Googled questions in employment. The technical answer in 49 of 50 states is yes. The practical answer is no.

Let’s walk through both questions.

The technical answer

In every state except Montana, the default employment relationship is at-will. At-will means either party can end the relationship at any time, with or without cause, with or without notice, as long as the reason isn’t unlawful.

“Without cause” is the legal version of “for no reason.” If you don’t like the way the employee whistles, you can fire them. If you decide on a Tuesday that you don’t want them on the team anymore, you can fire them. If you have no specific reason at all, you can fire them.

What you can’t do, even at an at-will employer, is fire someone for an unlawful reason. The unlawful reasons:

  • Protected-class discrimination. Race, color, religion, sex (including pregnancy, sexual orientation, gender identity), national origin, age 40+, disability, genetic information, plus state-specific protected classes (which vary widely; California adds a half-dozen, New York adds caregiver status, others add other categories).
  • Retaliation for protected activity. Filing a complaint, supporting another employee’s complaint, requesting an accommodation, taking protected leave, raising a safety concern, refusing to violate the law.
  • Public-policy violations. Filing for workers’ comp, exercising a statutory right (jury duty, voting, military service), refusing to commit a crime.
  • Implied-contract violations. If your offer letter, your manual, or your manager’s verbal promises created an implied contract, terminating outside the implied terms is a breach.
  • Statutory protections. FMLA leave, ADA accommodation, PWFA accommodation, religious accommodation, and various others create specific protections.
  • Every other reason is fair game under at-will. Including no reason at all.

So technically, yes, you can fire someone for no reason in 49 of 50 states.

The practical answer

The technical answer doesn’t survive contact with an actual claim.

When you fire someone for “no reason,” the employee gets to fill in the reason. The conversation in the parking lot becomes their interpretation of what happened. The interpretation gets shaped by their lawyer, who’s looking for a viable theory. The viable theory becomes whatever fits the facts and lets them file a claim.

If the employee is in a protected class (and statistically, most employees are in at least one: race, sex, age 40+, religion, sometimes more), the easiest theory is that the “no reason” termination was actually a discriminatory reason. The employee files an EEOC charge or a state-agency complaint alleging discrimination. The employer now has to prove a negative: that the firing wasn’t for the alleged discriminatory reason.

Without a documented reason for the firing, the negative is hard to prove. The defense becomes “we don’t have a reason, but it wasn’t discrimination,” which sounds exactly like what a discriminatory employer would say.

This is what makes the rules-of-the-road problem real for terminations. Without a documented standard, the employee fills in the standard. The “real reason” becomes whatever the employee can plausibly argue. The defense is your word against theirs, with no neutral framework to anchor the truth.

What to do instead

For at-will employers in at-will states, the right approach is to always have a documented reason for termination, even when you don’t legally need one. Specifically:

A reason that’s behavioral or performance-based. Not “we just don’t think it’s working out.” Something like “the employee’s performance against the documented standard in their job description has not improved despite several conversations and a written warning.”

A reason that’s contemporaneous. Documented before or at the time of the termination, not after the fact when a claim has been filed. Contemporaneous documentation is much more credible than reconstructed-after-the-fact documentation.

A reason that’s consistent with how you’ve treated similarly situated employees. If you’ve fired this person for attendance issues but kept three other employees with worse attendance records, the disparate treatment is a problem. Consistent application of the same standard across employees is the structural defense.

A reason that doesn’t conflict with what the employee was told. If the manager told the employee in their last review that they were doing well, and the file shows positive feedback, and then the firing is for “performance,” the inconsistency is the problem. Honest contemporaneous feedback throughout the relationship is what supports the eventual termination if it comes.

The technical right to fire for no reason exists. The practical exercise of that right creates more risk than it avoids.

Why operators get this wrong

I see this pattern regularly with small-employer clients. The owner has been frustrated with an employee for months. The frustration accumulates. Eventually the owner decides to terminate. The decision feels right. The reasons are real but unstated, undocumented, never communicated to the employee.

The owner walks the employee out, tells them at-will means at-will, and assumes the matter is closed. A few weeks later the demand letter arrives. The lawyer’s theory is that the firing was discriminatory. The owner’s defense is the same frustration that had been building for months, none of which is in writing, none of which was communicated, none of which is consistent with the file.

The owner could have terminated this employee with a much stronger defensive posture if they had documented the issues as they arose, communicated the gap to the employee, given them a chance to improve, documented the lack of improvement, and tied the eventual termination to the documented record.

The same termination, with documentation, costs the company a fraction of what the same termination without documentation costs.

The exception: a clean layoff or position elimination

There’s one situation where “no reason” is genuinely fine: a layoff or position elimination that isn’t tied to the specific employee.

The position is eliminated for business reasons. Cost reduction. Restructuring. Closing a function. Selling part of the business. The decision is about the position, not the person. The person’s race, gender, age, etc., aren’t a factor because the decision wouldn’t have happened differently with a different person in the seat.

For a clean layoff, the documentation is the business reason for the position elimination. Financial pressure, strategic shift, operational change. The employee can still allege that they were specifically selected for protected reasons, but the structural defense is that the position was eliminated and a similarly situated employee in any class would have been treated the same way.

If you’re conducting a layoff of multiple positions, watch for disparate impact: are the eliminated positions disproportionately concentrated in any protected class. If yes, that’s the structural problem you have to address before the layoff, not after.

What this looks like in your manual

Your handbook should have:

A clear at-will employment statement (front and acknowledgment).

A discipline framework that uses “may” rather than “will” for any non-mandatory step, so you have flexibility but the framework exists.

A statement that performance is evaluated against the standards in the job description, which connects discipline to a documented criterion.

A complaint procedure so employees who feel mistreated have a path to raise concerns before filing claims.

A termination procedure that walks the manager through the steps to take when a termination is decided.

We include all of this in the custom employee manual that comes with every AccompliCenter HR subscription. The combination of at-will language, discipline framework, performance documentation reference, and termination procedure is what supports the operator who needs to terminate someone and wants the file to support the decision. Plans start at $139 a month.

The technical answer to “can I fire an employee for no reason” is yes. The practical answer is don’t, and document a reason even when you don’t legally need one. The cost of that small additional discipline is much less than the cost of a wrongful-termination claim built on the absence of documentation.

This article is general information, not legal advice. For legal advice about your situation, consult a qualified attorney.

Back to the list of articles

To subscribe, call us at (562) 444-8076, stop by our store at 3217 Carson St in Lakewood, or email service@accomplicenter.com.

See AccompliCenter HR plans →

Store Hours

Today
  • Mon
    Nov 16

    8:30AM
    —
    6:00PM
  • Tue
    Nov 17

    8:30AM
    —
    6:00PM
  • Wed
    Nov 18

    8:30AM
    —
    6:00PM
  • Thu
    Nov 19

    8:30AM
    —
    6:00PM
  • Fri
    Nov 20

    8:30AM
    —
    6:00PM
  • Sat
    Nov 21

    9:00AM
    —
    4:00PM
  • Sun
    Nov 22

    10:00AM
    —
    3:00PM