HR Consulting

blogheader

Leave and Accommodations for Small Employers

I am not an attorney. These articles are general information based on my experience as an HR professional, and they are not legal advice. For legal advice about your situation, consult a qualified attorney.

FMLA for Small Employers: Does It Even Apply to You?

The short version

  • FMLA applies at 50 or more employees within 75 miles. Under 50, it does not apply to you at all.
  • California’s CFRA applies at five employees, and New York’s paid family leave reaches nearly every private employer.
  • Since January 2025 you cannot require an employee to use accrued PTO while they are drawing state paid-leave benefits.

If this article raised a question about your own business, that is what our subscription is for. Plans start at $139 a month. Call (562) 444-8076, email service@accomplicenter.com, or come by our store at 3217 Carson St in Lakewood to sign up.

The Family and Medical Leave Act applies to employers with 50 or more employees within a 75-mile radius. If you have fewer than 50 employees, the federal FMLA doesn’t apply to you. That’s the answer most small-employer operators don’t get told clearly enough.

The distinction matters because operators with 35 employees get advice that assumes FMLA, and the advice is wrong.

The 50/75 threshold

FMLA applies to “covered employers.” A covered employer is one that employed 50 or more employees in 20 or more workweeks in the current or preceding calendar year. The 50-employee count includes part-time, full-time, and temporary employees on the payroll.

Even at a covered employer, an individual employee is “FMLA-eligible” only if they meet three additional criteria:

They have worked for the employer for at least 12 months (not necessarily consecutive). They have worked at least 1,250 hours in the 12 months immediately preceding the leave. They work at a location where the employer has 50 or more employees within a 75-mile radius.

This last one is the part that catches some employers. A regional office with 30 employees, where the parent company has 5,000 employees concentrated 200 miles away, isn’t a covered FMLA worksite for the regional employees. They work for a covered employer but they aren’t FMLA-eligible because their specific worksite doesn’t have 50 within 75 miles.

For a small-employer reader, the practical version of this is simpler. If you have one location with all your employees, the question is whether that location has 50 or more. If yes, you’re covered, and individual eligibility depends on tenure and hours. If no, FMLA doesn’t apply.

What FMLA provides when it applies

FMLA gives an eligible employee up to 12 weeks of unpaid, job-protected leave in a 12-month period for any of these qualifying reasons:

The birth of a child and bonding within one year of birth. Placement of a child for adoption or foster care and bonding within one year. A serious health condition that makes the employee unable to perform essential functions of their job. Caring for an immediate family member (spouse, parent, child) with a serious health condition. Qualifying exigencies arising from a family member’s military service.

A separate “military caregiver leave” provision provides up to 26 weeks for an eligible employee caring for a covered servicemember with a serious injury or illness.

“Job-protected” means that when the employee returns from leave within the 12-week (or 26-week) window, they’re entitled to be restored to the same or an equivalent position. Equivalent means same pay, benefits, schedule, and responsibilities. It doesn’t mean identical, but it does mean materially the same.

“Unpaid” means FMLA itself doesn’t require the employer to pay during the leave. The employee can use accrued PTO, sick leave, or short-term disability if applicable, and the employer can normally require the employee to use accrued time concurrently with FMLA. One exception matters and it is new. Where the employee is drawing benefits from a state paid family or medical leave program, the Department of Labor concluded in January 2025 that the leave isn’t unpaid, so the substitution rule doesn’t apply. Neither you nor the employee can force the use of accrued PTO, and topping up to full pay takes mutual agreement. Check the state program too; some override this.

State family leave laws under the federal threshold

When you’re below 50 employees and FMLA doesn’t apply, state law often does. The state laws vary substantially.

California has the California Family Rights Act (CFRA) which applies at 5+ employees. Most operators in California have CFRA, even if they don’t have FMLA. CFRA provides up to 12 weeks of leave for similar qualifying reasons as FMLA, and California’s Paid Family Leave (PFL) program provides partial wage replacement during the leave.

New York Paid Family Leave applies to nearly all private employers regardless of size. It provides paid leave for bonding with a new child, caring for a family member with a serious health condition, and certain military exigencies. New York also added 20 hours of paid prenatal leave effective January 1, 2025, for every private employer with no size threshold, on top of and separate from New York sick leave. It is the first law of its kind and it is routinely missed.

Fourteen states and the District of Columbia now run paid family and medical leave programs. New Jersey, Connecticut, Massachusetts, Washington, Rhode Island and D.C. apply broadly. Oregon Paid Leave covers every employer with even one Oregon employee; the 25-employee line only decides whether you owe the employer share of the contribution. Colorado FAMLI applies broadly and added up to 12 additional weeks of neonatal intensive care leave effective January 1, 2026. Delaware and Minnesota began paying benefits on January 1, 2026 and Maine on May 1, 2026. Maryland has been delayed again: contributions start January 1, 2027 and benefits January 3, 2028. Virginia’s program is scheduled for 2028.

Other states have narrower programs (some apply only at higher employer thresholds, some cover only certain reasons, some are more limited in duration).

If you have employees in any state with a paid family leave or family medical leave program, you have an obligation independent of FMLA. The obligation often applies at lower employer thresholds. Check your specific state.

What you owe when neither FMLA nor a state program applies

Even if you have fewer than 5 employees in California (so CFRA doesn’t apply), or you’re in a state without a state program, you still owe certain leave obligations.

  • ADA accommodations. A serious health condition might also qualify as a disability under the ADA, which can require leave as a reasonable accommodation. ADA applies at 15+ employees federally; state equivalents apply lower.
  • Pregnancy disability. State pregnancy-disability laws (PDL in California at 5+, similar laws elsewhere) provide leave related to pregnancy independent of FMLA.
  • Workers’ compensation. A work-related injury triggers workers’ comp benefits and protections regardless of employer size.
  • Military leave. USERRA applies to all employers regardless of size.

Jury duty, voting, and similar civic obligations. State laws vary.

Domestic violence leave, crime victim leave, and bereavement leave in states that have them apply at varying thresholds.

The point is that even an under-50 employer in a state without a state family leave program still has leave obligations. They’re just narrower and triggered by different circumstances.

The administrative work FMLA requires when it applies

If you’re at or above 50 employees and FMLA applies, the administrative work is real and worth doing right.

  • Notice requirements. You have to provide a general FMLA notice to employees (the FMLA poster, distributed at hire, accessible in the workplace). When you become aware that an employee may need FMLA leave, you have to provide an Eligibility Notice within five business days, followed by a Rights and Responsibilities Notice and a Designation Notice.
  • Certification. You can require medical certification from a healthcare provider for serious health conditions. The certification has to be requested within five business days and the employee has 15 calendar days to return it.
  • Tracking the 12-week balance. You have to track FMLA usage in a designated 12-month period (calendar year, fixed year, “rolling forward” from first use, or “rolling backward” from current date). Your handbook should specify which method you use.
  • Maintaining benefits. Group health insurance has to be maintained during FMLA leave on the same terms as if the employee were not on leave.
  • Restoration. When the employee returns within the 12-week window, you have to restore them to the same or equivalent position.

The penalty for not handling FMLA correctly is real. Wrongful denial of FMLA, interference with FMLA rights, and retaliation for taking FMLA are all separate claims, each with separate damages exposure including back pay, front pay, liquidated damages, and attorney fees.

What this looks like in your manual

Your handbook should have an FMLA policy if you’re at or above 50 employees, or a state-specific equivalent if your state’s law applies at lower thresholds.

The policy should include:

Eligibility criteria. Qualifying reasons for leave. The notice and certification process. Whether you require concurrent use of accrued paid leave. The 12-month measurement method. Benefit continuation during leave. Restoration rights. The intersection with state programs (where applicable) and ADA.

We tailor handbook leave policies to the specific state and the specific employer size in the custom employee manual that comes with every AccompliCenter HR subscription. If you’re a 35-employee California business, your handbook needs CFRA but not FMLA, plus PDL, plus the ADA-accommodation-leave overlay. If you’re a 60-employee multi-state employer, you need FMLA plus the relevant state programs in each state. The right policy depends on your specific picture, and the wrong policy is worse than no policy because it commits you to obligations you might not actually have.

This article is general information, not legal advice. For legal advice about your situation, consult a qualified attorney.

Back to the list of articles

The short version

  • Seventeen states and the District of Columbia require paid sick leave. Three more require paid leave an employee can use for any reason.
  • Missouri’s law was repealed on August 28, 2025. Nebraska exempts employers with 10 or fewer employees. Connecticut reaches 11 employees in 2026 and one in 2027.
  • Where a city ordinance and a state law both apply, the more generous of the two governs.

Fixing an HR mistake after the fact costs more than preventing it. Subscriptions start at $139 a month, and every plan includes a custom employee manual. Call (562) 444-8076, email service@accomplicenter.com, or come by our store at 3217 Carson St in Lakewood to sign up.

There is no federal paid sick leave law for private-sector employees. The federal government’s only paid-sick-leave entitlement applies to federal contractors. Everything else is state and local.

Seventeen states and the District of Columbia require paid sick leave. Three more (Illinois, Maine and Nevada) require paid leave an employee can use for any reason, including illness, which brings the working total to twenty states plus D.C. Dozens of cities and counties have their own ordinances on top. The picture changes every legislative session, and it moves in both directions: Missouri enacted a law by ballot measure in 2024 and repealed it sixteen months later.

This map is current as of publication and will go stale. Verify your specific state and any cities you operate in.

The state-by-state picture

  • The states, alphabetically. Illinois, Maine and Nevada mandate paid leave usable for any reason rather than paid sick leave specifically. Missouri repealed its law in 2025 and Virginia’s isn’t in force yet; both are here so you don’t go looking.
  • Alaska. Effective July 1, 2025 by ballot measure. 1 hour per 30 hours worked. Annual use cap of 40 hours for employers with fewer than 15 employees, 56 hours at 15 or more.
  • Arizona. 1 hour per 30 hours worked. Cap depends on employer size.
  • California. 1 hour per 30 hours worked. Annual use cap of 40 hours or 5 days, accrual cap of 80 hours or 10 days. Employees can use after 90 days. Amounts and caps were expanded by SB 616 effective January 1, 2024. Permitted uses expanded again in 2025 to cover jury duty and court appearances, agricultural workers avoiding smoke, heat or flooding during a declared emergency, and qualifying acts of violence, and again on October 1, 2025.
  • Colorado. 1 hour per 30 hours worked. Annual use cap of 48 hours. Plus separate “Public Health Emergency” leave provisions.
  • Connecticut. Coverage dropped to employers with 11 or more employees on January 1, 2026, and reaches every employer with one or more on January 1, 2027. 1 hour per 30 hours worked, usable after 120 days.
  • Illinois. Paid Leave for All Workers Act effective January 1, 2024. 1 hour per 40 hours worked. Up to 40 hours per year. Use for any reason.
  • Maine. Earned Paid Leave Act covers most employers with 11+ employees. 1 hour per 40 hours worked. Up to 40 hours per year. Use for any reason.
  • Maryland. Healthy Working Families Act. Employers with 15+ employees provide paid sick leave; smaller employers provide unpaid.
  • Massachusetts. 1 hour per 30 hours worked. Up to 40 hours per year.
  • Michigan. The Earned Sick Time Act was amended February 21, 2025. 1 hour per 30 hours worked. Annual use cap of 72 hours at 11 or more employees, 40 hours at 10 or fewer. The 120-day waiting period replaced the old 90-day period, and the extra unpaid hours for small-employer employees were eliminated.
  • Minnesota. Earned Sick and Safe Time. 1 hour per 30 hours worked. Up to 48 hours per year. Effective 2024.
  • Missouri. Enacted by ballot measure effective May 1, 2025 and repealed by the legislature effective August 28, 2025. Missouri employers have no paid sick leave obligation.
  • Nebraska. Effective October 1, 2025. 1 hour per 30 hours worked, after an 80-hour employment period. Employers with 10 or fewer employees are exempt entirely. Annual use cap of 40 hours at 11 to 19 employees, 56 hours at 20 or more.
  • Nevada. Employers with 50+ employees. 0.01923 hours per hour worked.
  • New Jersey. 1 hour per 30 hours worked. Up to 40 hours per year.
  • New Mexico. Healthy Workplaces Act. 1 hour per 30 hours worked. Up to 64 hours per year.
  • New York. State law plus separate New York City and Westchester County laws. Hours and accrual vary by employer size.
  • Oregon. 1 hour per 30 hours worked. Up to 40 hours per year. Employers with 10+ employees provide paid; smaller provide unpaid.
  • Rhode Island. 1 hour per 35 hours worked. Up to 40 hours per year. Employers with 18+ employees provide paid.
  • Vermont. 1 hour per 52 hours worked. Annual cap depends on employer size and tenure.
  • Virginia. Enacted May 20, 2026 but not yet in force. Employers with 50 or more employees comply beginning July 1, 2027, 25 or more on January 1, 2028, and all employers on January 1, 2029.
  • Washington. 1 hour per 40 hours worked. No annual cap on accrual; carryover up to 40 hours.
  • District of Columbia. Accrued Sick and Safe Leave Act. Hours vary by employer size.

States without paid sick leave laws (most still have unpaid sick leave protections in some form): Texas, Florida, Georgia, Alabama, North Carolina, South Carolina, Tennessee, Indiana, Ohio (despite local ordinances in some cities), Pennsylvania (despite local ordinances), Kentucky, Wisconsin, Iowa, Kansas, Missouri (repealed in 2025), Oklahoma, and others.

The local-ordinance layer

Even in states without state-level paid sick leave, several cities and counties have their own ordinances. Notable ones:

Pittsburgh, Philadelphia, Allegheny County (PA). Paid sick leave ordinances covering most employers within those jurisdictions.

Bloomfield, Newark, Jersey City, New Brunswick, Trenton, Paterson, Plainfield, Passaic, Montclair, East Orange, Morristown (NJ). Pre-state-law local ordinances now largely subsumed under state law but with some preserved provisions.

New York City, Westchester County, Suffolk County (NY). Local laws on top of state law with additional provisions in some cases.

Cook County (IL), Chicago. Local ordinances on top of state law.

Los Angeles, San Francisco, Oakland, Berkeley, Emeryville, San Diego, Santa Monica, San Jose (CA). Local ordinances providing more than the state minimum.

Seattle, Tacoma (WA). Local ordinances.

Minneapolis, Saint Paul, Duluth, Bloomington (MN). Local ordinances.

Denver (CO). Local ordinance covering more workers than state law.

Bernalillo County (NM), Albuquerque.

Austin, San Antonio and Dallas (TX). Each enacted a local paid sick leave ordinance. Each was struck down by the courts, and Texas separately preempted local employment-leave ordinances by statute in September 2023. None is enforceable. Texas employers have no local paid sick leave obligation anywhere in the state.

Portland (ME).

If you operate in any of these cities or counties, the local ordinance applies on top of state law, and the more generous of the two governs.

The structural elements that matter

Within any state’s law, several structural elements determine the actual employer obligation.

  • Accrual rate. How many hours of sick leave the employee earns per hour worked. Most laws use 1 hour per 30 to 1 hour per 52, with 1 per 30 being the most common.
  • Annual cap on use. The maximum hours an employee can use in a year. Common caps are 40 or 48 hours.
  • Cap on accrual. The maximum hours an employee can carry on the books at any time. Some laws cap accrual; others don’t.
  • Carryover rules. Whether unused hours carry over from year to year. Most laws permit carryover up to a cap.
  • Reasons for use. Most laws permit use for the employee’s own illness, family member’s illness, preventive care, domestic violence situations, and certain other categories.
  • Front-loading option. Some laws permit employers to front-load the annual entitlement at the start of the year instead of accruing hour by hour. Front-loading is administratively simpler but the employer commits to providing the full entitlement upfront.
  • Notice requirements. Some laws require employees to provide notice when foreseeable; some don’t.
  • Documentation requirements. Whether and when the employer can require documentation for sick leave use. Most laws permit documentation only for absences exceeding a certain length (typically 3 consecutive days).
  • Pay rate. Most laws require the employee’s regular rate of pay. A few require an hourly rate based on the employee’s wage history.

The unpaid floor

Even in states without paid sick leave, employers often have unpaid leave obligations:

FMLA at 50+ employees provides up to 12 weeks of unpaid leave for serious health conditions and family member care.

ADA accommodations may include leave as a reasonable accommodation.

State-specific unpaid sick or family leave laws exist in some states without paid leave.

Workers’ compensation provides protected leave for work-related injuries.

The floor is rarely zero, even where there’s no paid leave entitlement. The handbook needs to address whatever leave obligations actually apply.

What this looks like in your manual

Your handbook should have a paid sick leave policy specific to your state and any cities or counties you operate in. The policy should include:

The accrual rate. The annual use cap. The carryover rules. The qualifying reasons for use. The notice requirements. The documentation requirements. How sick leave interacts with PTO if you have a separate PTO policy.

We tailor paid sick leave policies to the specific state and cities you operate in, in the custom employee manual that comes with every AccompliCenter HR subscription. A multi-state employer gets multiple policies for the multiple jurisdictions. A single-location California employer gets a California policy plus the relevant city policy if applicable. Plans start at $139 a month.

If you’ve been operating without a written paid sick leave policy in a state that requires one, this is a high-priority compliance gap. The fix is a policy plus a payroll/HR system that tracks accrual correctly. The cost of leaving it alone is back pay for unprovided leave plus penalties under the state’s specific enforcement scheme.

This article is general information, not legal advice. For legal advice about your situation, consult a qualified attorney.

Back to the list of articles

Pregnancy Leave: How Federal Law and State Law Stack On Top of Each Other

The short version

  • Three federal laws apply to pregnancy: the PDA at 15 employees, the PWFA at 15, and FMLA at 50.
  • In California, pregnancy disability leave and CFRA bonding leave do not run concurrently, so an eligible employee can be out roughly seven months with job protection.
  • The abortion-accommodation portion of the EEOC’s PWFA rule was vacated nationwide in May 2025. The statute and the rest of the rule stand.

Employment law is complicated, and one mistake can cost far more than a year of help. An AccompliCenter HR subscription starts at $139 a month. Call (562) 444-8076, email service@accomplicenter.com, or come by our store at 3217 Carson St in Lakewood to sign up.

Pregnancy is the place in employment law where the most laws stack on top of each other. Three federal laws apply. State laws apply on top of that. In California specifically, an employee can be entitled to roughly seven months of protected leave when all the laws stack. Most operators don’t know how the laws fit together, which means they handle pregnancy leave wrong both ways: granting leave that wasn’t required, or denying leave that was required.

The federal floor

Three federal laws apply to pregnancy in employment. They do different things and they apply to different sized employers.

  • Pregnancy Discrimination Act (PDA). Amended Title VII in 1978. Prohibits employment discrimination based on pregnancy, childbirth, or related medical conditions. Requires that pregnant employees be treated the same as other employees with similar abilities or limitations. Doesn’t require leave specifically; it requires non-discrimination. Applies at 15+ employees.
  • Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA). Provides up to 12 weeks of unpaid, job-protected leave in a 12-month period for the birth of a child and bonding within one year. Eligibility requires 12 months of employment, 1,250 hours in the past 12 months, and a worksite with 50+ employees within 75 miles. Applies at employers with 50+ employees.
  • Pregnant Workers Fairness Act (PWFA). Effective June 27, 2023, with EEOC final regulations effective June 18, 2024. Requires reasonable accommodation for known limitations related to pregnancy, childbirth, or related medical conditions, unless the accommodation would cause undue hardship. PWFA isn’t a leave law primarily. It’s an accommodation law that operates similarly to the ADA but specifically for pregnancy. Applies at 15+ employees. A federal court vacated the abortion-accommodation portion of the regulations nationwide in May 2025; the statute and the rest of the rule stand.

(The Americans with Disabilities Act also applies if pregnancy-related complications rise to the level of a disability under the ADA, which has been the case in some pregnancies and not others. See our post #28 on the ADA process.)

What the federal floor actually does

A small employer with 15 to 49 employees gets PDA and PWFA but not FMLA. The picture for that employer:

The pregnant employee can’t be discriminated against because of pregnancy. They get treated like any other employee with a similar ability or limitation.

The pregnant employee can request reasonable accommodations under PWFA. Modified schedules, light duty, additional breaks, time off for medical appointments, temporary reassignment, sometimes a leave of absence as the accommodation itself. The employer engages in the interactive process and provides the accommodation unless undue hardship.

There’s no federal entitlement to a specific amount of leave for bonding or childbirth recovery. State law fills in or it doesn’t.

A larger employer (50+ employees) gets all three federal laws plus FMLA. The picture adds:

Up to 12 weeks of unpaid, job-protected leave for the birth of a child and bonding (and other FMLA-qualifying reasons). Job restoration to the same or equivalent position when the employee returns within the 12-week window. Continuation of group health insurance during leave.

The state add-ons

State laws add to the federal floor in three categories: state pregnancy disability laws, state family leave laws, and state paid leave programs.

  • State pregnancy disability laws. Several states have specific laws providing leave for pregnancy-related disability beyond what the PDA requires. California’s Pregnancy Disability Leave (PDL) provides up to 4 months of leave for pregnancy-related disability, applies at 5+ employees, and runs separately from CFRA bonding leave. Similar laws exist in some form in most major states.
  • State family leave laws. State equivalents of FMLA that often apply at lower employer thresholds and provide leave for bonding with a new child. California’s CFRA at 5+. New Jersey, Connecticut, Oregon, Washington, Massachusetts, Colorado, Maryland, Minnesota, and others have programs at varying thresholds.
  • State paid leave programs. Insurance programs that provide partial wage replacement during family leave or pregnancy disability leave. Funded by payroll deductions. Provide a percentage of wages (varies by state) for a specified duration. California’s PFL, New York’s PFL, New Jersey’s FLI, Connecticut’s Paid Leave, Massachusetts’ PFML, Oregon Paid Leave, Washington PFML, Colorado FAMLI, and others.

How the laws stack: California example

California is the state where the math gets longest, because California has the most overlapping laws. The typical stack for a California employee at a 50+ employer:

  • Pregnancy Disability Leave (PDL). Up to 4 months for pregnancy-related disability. The 4 months can be taken before, during, or after childbirth depending on what the medical provider certifies as disabling. PDL applies at 5+ employees in California. So the employee gets up to 4 months of pregnancy disability leave.
  • Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA). Up to 12 weeks unpaid for the birth of a child and bonding. FMLA runs concurrently with PDL when the employee is using PDL leave for pregnancy-related disability. So the employee uses 12 weeks of FMLA during the PDL period (the pregnancy disability portion), exhausting FMLA before they ever get to the bonding portion.
  • California Family Rights Act (CFRA). Up to 12 weeks unpaid for bonding with a new child. CFRA does NOT run concurrently with PDL because PDL is specifically for pregnancy-related disability and CFRA is for bonding. So after the employee finishes PDL (up to 4 months for pregnancy disability), they can take CFRA bonding leave (up to 12 weeks).

Total stack: Up to 4 months PDL + up to 12 weeks CFRA bonding = approximately 4 months + 3 months = approximately 7 months of protected leave. (FMLA runs concurrently with PDL, so it doesn’t add to the total.)

Paid Family Leave (PFL). During the bonding portion (CFRA), California’s PFL program provides partial wage replacement. Doesn’t add leave time, but adds pay during the leave that’s already protected.

The combinations are where California operators most often get pregnancy leave wrong. Trace the stack before you answer an employee’s question about how long they can be out.

Other states that stack significantly

  • New York. PFL provides 12 weeks of paid bonding leave at 67% of wages (capped). Combined with disability leave (DBL) for pregnancy disability, total leave can run 26 weeks or more depending on the medical course of the pregnancy. NY DBL covers pregnancy disability separately from bonding.
  • New Jersey. Similar structure. NJFLI for bonding (12 weeks paid) plus TDI for pregnancy disability (potentially up to 26 weeks combined depending on medical certification).
  • Massachusetts. PFML provides up to 20 weeks of medical leave (which can cover pregnancy disability) plus 12 weeks of family leave for bonding, capped at 26 weeks combined in a benefit year. Family leave to care for a covered servicemember runs to 26 weeks on its own.
  • Washington. PFML provides up to 12 weeks of medical leave (pregnancy disability) plus 12 weeks of family leave (bonding), capped at 16 weeks combined per claim year, or 18 weeks where a pregnancy-related condition causes incapacity. Job protection reached employers with 25 or more employees on January 1, 2026, drops to 15 in 2027 and 8 in 2028.

Connecticut, Oregon and Colorado each have similar stacking structures with different durations and percentages. Delaware and Minnesota began paying benefits on January 1, 2026 and Maine on May 1, 2026, so an employer in those states now has a paid-leave overlay that didn’t exist a year ago.

The pattern in each of these states is that a pregnancy can implicate both pregnancy disability leave (covering the medical portion) and family leave (covering the bonding portion), and the two leaves don’t always run concurrently.

The practical math for a small employer

If you’re a 30-employee employer in California, your stack is:

PDL (up to 4 months for disability) plus CFRA (up to 12 weeks for bonding) plus PFL (partial wage replacement during the CFRA portion). FMLA doesn’t apply because you’re under 50.

The 7-month potential still applies. Your employee can be out for that long, with job restoration at the end (because PDL and CFRA both provide job-protected leave). You won’t be paying full wages during the leave (because PDL is unpaid, CFRA is unpaid, and PFL is partial), but the employee’s job is held.

If you’re a 30-employee employer in Texas, your stack is:

ADA accommodations if applicable. PWFA accommodations. PDA non-discrimination. No state pregnancy leave law. No state paid family leave program.

The picture is much narrower. The employee can request accommodations under PWFA, the medical portion of pregnancy might trigger ADA-style accommodation analysis if it rises to disability, and the employer can’t discriminate. There’s no specific entitlement to weeks-of-leave the way California provides.

If you’re a 30-employee employer in New York, your stack is:

PWFA federally, PDA federally, NY State PFL (12 weeks paid bonding), NY DBL (pregnancy disability), and NY State Human Rights Law accommodations. The picture is closer to California than to Texas.

What this looks like in your manual

Your handbook needs a pregnancy leave policy that reflects every law that applies at your size in your state.

For California at 50+: PDL, CFRA, FMLA, PFL, PWFA, ADA. All of them, with the stacking explained.

For California at 5-49: PDL, CFRA, PFL, PWFA, ADA.

For Texas at 30: PWFA, ADA, PDA, no state programs.

For New York at any size: NY PFL, NY DBL, PWFA, ADA, PDA.

A handbook that uses generic federal-only pregnancy language is wrong in every state with state programs. A handbook that uses generic California language is wrong in every other state. The right policy depends on your specific picture.

We tailor pregnancy leave policies to your state and employer size in the custom employee manual that comes with every AccompliCenter HR subscription. The PWFA was added to our manuals when the final regulations took effect in 2024. State programs are tracked as they roll out and expand. Plans start at $139 a month.

If you have an employee who’s pregnant or whose spouse is pregnant, this is one of the leave situations where having the right policy in writing, before the question comes up, is the difference between handling it cleanly and finding out you got it wrong.

This article is general information, not legal advice. For legal advice about your situation, consult a qualified attorney.

Back to the list of articles

The Pregnant Workers Fairness Act: What It Actually Requires (Beyond Leave)

The short version

  • The PWFA is an accommodation law, not a leave law, and it applies at 15 employees.
  • Its threshold is lower than the ADA’s. It requires only a known limitation, and an essential function can be suspended temporarily as the accommodation.
  • Four accommodations are presumed reasonable and generally require no medical documentation: water, extra restroom breaks, sitting or standing, and breaks to eat.

You do not have to work through these rules alone. Our HR subscribers email or call us whenever a question comes up, and plans start at $139 a month. Call (562) 444-8076, email service@accomplicenter.com, or come by our store at 3217 Carson St in Lakewood to sign up.

The Pregnant Workers Fairness Act took effect June 27, 2023. The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission’s final regulations took effect June 18, 2024. Most small employers think of PWFA as a pregnancy-leave law. It isn’t. PWFA is an accommodation law, and the difference matters.

Pregnancy leave (FMLA, state pregnancy disability laws, state family leave laws) governs how much time an employee can take off. PWFA governs what accommodations the employee is entitled to while continuing to work. Different question, different framework, different obligations.

The basic framework

PWFA applies to employers with 15 or more employees, the same threshold as Title VII and the ADA.

The law requires reasonable accommodation for known limitations related to pregnancy, childbirth, or related medical conditions, unless the accommodation would cause undue hardship to the business.

The covered conditions include not just pregnancy itself but a broad range of related conditions: morning sickness, gestational diabetes, postpartum depression, lactation, menstruation in some applications, miscarriage, and recovery from childbirth. Abortion was on the EEOC’s original list and is no longer; a federal court vacated that piece of the regulation nationwide in May 2025.

The law builds on existing federal law. The Pregnancy Discrimination Act (1978) prohibits discrimination based on pregnancy. PWFA adds an affirmative accommodation duty that the PDA didn’t include. Title VII still applies. The ADA still applies if a pregnancy-related condition rises to disability.

How PWFA differs from ADA

Both laws use similar concepts (reasonable accommodation, interactive process, undue hardship), but the specifics differ in ways that matter.

Threshold for coverage. ADA requires that the employee have a “physical or mental impairment that substantially limits one or more major life activities.” PWFA requires only a “known limitation” related to pregnancy, childbirth, or a related medical condition. The PWFA threshold is lower. Pregnancy-related conditions don’t need to be substantially limiting to trigger PWFA accommodation duties.

Essential function analysis. Under the ADA, an employee is entitled to accommodation only if they can perform the essential functions of the job with reasonable accommodation. Under PWFA, an employer must consider, as a reasonable accommodation, temporarily suspending one or more essential functions in some circumstances, particularly when the inability to perform the essential function is temporary and the function can reasonably be performed by other employees in the meantime.

This is one of the most significant ways PWFA differs from ADA. Under ADA, if the employee can’t perform essential functions even with accommodation, the employer’s accommodation duty ends. Under PWFA, temporary suspension of essential functions can itself be the accommodation. The “temporary” framing is key. PWFA isn’t requiring permanent reassignment of essential functions. It’s requiring that for a defined period during pregnancy or recovery, an essential function can be put on hold if doing so doesn’t cause undue hardship.

The four “predictable assessments.” EEOC regulations identify four accommodations that should generally be granted without significant analysis because the burden is small and the need is common: allowing the employee to carry water and drink as needed; allowing additional restroom breaks; allowing the employee to sit (if normally standing) or stand (if normally sitting); allowing breaks to eat and drink. These four are presumed reasonable and not unduly burdensome in most workplaces. The interactive process should accommodate them quickly.

Other examples of reasonable accommodation. Modified schedules, modified workstation, light duty, temporary reassignment to a different role, time off for medical appointments, lactation accommodations beyond what state law already requires, leave of absence as the accommodation itself.

The interactive process under PWFA

Like the ADA, PWFA requires the interactive process. The five steps look largely the same as the ADA process (recognize the request, engage the interactive process, evaluate, decide and document, follow through), but a few specifics differ.

  • The request can be informal. PWFA explicitly contemplates that requests may come from the employee in informal terms (“I’m pregnant and I can’t lift the heavy boxes anymore”). The employer’s obligation triggers regardless of formality.
  • Documentation requirements are limited. EEOC regulations restrict how much medical documentation an employer can require for PWFA accommodations. For the four predictable assessments, the employer generally cannot require medical documentation. For other accommodations, documentation can be requested only when it’s reasonable, and the bar for “reasonable” is meaningful.
  • Temporary suspension of essential functions. When this is on the table, the conversation is structured around how long the suspension will last, how the function will be covered in the meantime, and whether that coverage causes undue hardship. The presumption is in favor of accommodation when the duration is bounded.
  • Lactation accommodations. The PUMP Act, signed December 29, 2022, requires reasonable break time and a private space that isn’t a bathroom, for one year after the child’s birth. It covers exempt and non-exempt employees alike at FLSA-covered employers of any size. Employers with fewer than 50 employees may assert undue hardship, but it is judged case by case with the burden on the employer; it isn’t automatic. Remedies became available April 28, 2023. PWFA adds an accommodation duty for lactation as a pregnancy-related condition on top of that.

Undue hardship under PWFA

PWFA’s undue-hardship standard is broadly the same as ADA’s. The employer can deny an accommodation if providing it would cause significant difficulty or expense considering the cost of the accommodation, the financial resources of the employer, and the nature of the operation.

For small employers, undue hardship is sometimes easier to demonstrate than for large employers because the financial resources and operational scale are smaller. But the standard isn’t “this is inconvenient.” It’s “this fundamentally disrupts how the business operates.”

A specific issue under PWFA: undue hardship is harder to demonstrate for the four predictable assessments. The accommodations are by their nature low-cost and low-disruption. Denial of any of these accommodations on undue-hardship grounds would face significant scrutiny.

State law on top of PWFA

Several states have pregnancy accommodation laws that predate PWFA or impose additional requirements.

  • California. Pregnancy Disability Leave covers leave (separate from PWFA) and the Fair Employment and Housing Act covers pregnancy accommodation at 5+ employees. California’s accommodation duty for pregnancy is broader than federal in some respects. Additional protections under SB 142 (lactation accommodations) and other state laws.
  • New York. New York State Human Rights Law and New York City Human Rights Law both require pregnancy accommodation, with broader thresholds than federal.
  • New Jersey. Pregnant Workers Fairness Act (state law, predates federal) at all employers.

Connecticut, Massachusetts, Washington, Oregon, Illinois. Each has state pregnancy accommodation requirements.

If you have employees in any state with its own pregnancy accommodation law, that law may apply at lower employer thresholds than federal PWFA and may impose additional requirements.

Where the abortion-accommodation rule stands

The EEOC’s original regulations required accommodation for abortion alongside childbirth and miscarriage. A federal court in Louisiana vacated that portion of the rule nationwide on May 21, 2025. The statute is untouched and so is the rest of the regulation, but abortion is no longer an accommodable related medical condition under the rule. Accommodations tied to a pregnancy-related medical condition are still required regardless of how the condition arose.

Two other things a 2024-vintage policy will miss. The Fifth Circuit upheld the PWFA’s enactment in August 2025, ending the argument that the law was never validly passed. And the EEOC has a proposed rule on its 2026 agenda that would narrow what counts as a related medical condition. Your handbook should track the current federal rule and stay out of the politics.

What this looks like in your manual

Your handbook should have a pregnancy accommodation section that covers:

The PWFA framework if you have 15+ employees. The state pregnancy accommodation law if your state has one (with the lower threshold if applicable). The interactive process for pregnancy accommodation requests. The four predictable assessments and how they’re handled (generally granted without medical documentation). The relationship between pregnancy accommodation and pregnancy leave (separate frameworks, often overlapping). The lactation accommodation requirements under federal PUMP Act, state law, and any local ordinance. The interaction with FMLA, state family leave, ADA, and state disability laws.

We include all of this in the custom employee manual that comes with every AccompliCenter HR subscription. The PWFA section was added when the final regulations took effect in 2024 and is updated as the law evolves. State pregnancy accommodation laws are tracked separately. Plans start at $139 a month.

If you have an employee who’s pregnant or postpartum, the accommodation conversation is the one most likely to come up in the workplace. Most of the accommodations are simple. The four predictable assessments cost almost nothing. The conversations go best when the framework is in place before the request comes in, which is what the handbook is for.

This article is general information, not legal advice. For legal advice about your situation, consult a qualified attorney.

Back to the list of articles

ADA Accommodations: A 5-Step Process for Small Employers

The short version

  • A DMV placard is not an accommodation request, and an accommodation request does not have to use the word “accommodation.”
  • Five steps: recognize the request, engage the interactive process, evaluate against essential functions, decide and document, follow through.
  • The ADA applies at 15 employees. California’s FEHA applies at 5, and failing to engage in the interactive process is its own claim there.

A single wage claim or agency charge can cost more than several years of an HR subscription. Plans start at $139 a month. Call (562) 444-8076, email service@accomplicenter.com, or come by our store at 3217 Carson St in Lakewood to sign up.

An employee comes into your office. They lay a state-issued handicap placard on your desk and ask whether they can start parking in the closest spaces to the building. Maybe they say “I have a condition.” Maybe they don’t say anything more than that.

What do you do?

Most operators handle this one of two ways. They say yes: sure, no problem, take any spot you want. Or they say no: the closest spots are reserved for customers, sorry. Both are wrong. The right answer is a third one that takes a little longer and costs you almost nothing.

A handicap placard isn’t an ADA accommodation request

  • A handicap placard from the DMV is one thing. An accommodation duty under the Americans with Disabilities Act is another. They can show up in the same conversation. They don’t mean the same thing.
  • The DMV is asking a narrow question. Does this person have a condition that interferes with their ability to drive, or to get from their car to where they need to go? Limited mobility from a back injury, lung disease, cardiovascular disease, low vision. The DMV’s analysis ends there. A placard is a parking privilege based on a driving-related impairment.
  • The ADA is asking a different question. It looks at whether the employee has a physical or mental impairment that substantially limits a major life activity, and then it looks at the employee’s job. What are the essential duties of the position? What accommodation, if any, would let the employee perform those essential duties? Would providing it cause undue hardship to the business?
  • These two questions reach different conclusions. An employee can have a DMV placard and no ADA accommodation right at work, because the placard says nothing about whether their condition affects the essential duties of their job. An employee can also have a real ADA accommodation right at work and no placard, because their disability has nothing to do with mobility or driving.

An employee with a placard for low vision who works a desk job may have no ADA accommodation right at all. Their condition doesn’t affect any essential function of the work. An employee with severe anxiety who has never been near a DMV may have a strong ADA accommodation right at work.

Same person can have both. Same person can have one and not the other. The way you figure out which is by having a conversation. A real one, in writing, with a doctor’s input. That conversation is the interactive process.

Why slowing down matters

Most accommodation problems I’ve seen at small businesses don’t come from bad faith. They come from quick reactions. The owner wants to be a good boss, hears the request, says yes on the spot. Then the second request comes in, and the third, and now there’s no consistency, no documentation, and no defensible reason for why one employee got something the next one didn’t.

Or the opposite. The owner gets nervous, says no immediately, and now there’s an EEOC charge or a state-agency complaint on the desk because nobody asked the doctor what the employee actually needed.

The interactive process prevents both. It is deliberate and it is slow, and the same conversation that protects you legally is the one that tells your employee you take their situation seriously.

Step 1. Recognize the request

The request doesn’t have to use the word “accommodation.” It doesn’t have to mention the ADA. An employee saying “I’m having trouble standing for my whole shift” is making a request. So is “the fluorescent lights are giving me migraines.” So is laying a placard on your desk and asking about parking.

Train your managers to spot it. Formal or informal, written or verbal, the moment the request comes in your obligation starts and your timeline starts with it.

Step 2. Engage the interactive process

Hand the employee a set of accommodation request forms. Not because the paperwork is the point, but because the forms create a written record and tell the doctor what to address. The forms ask three things. What does the employee need. What limitations create the need. What does the doctor recommend.

Give the employee a deadline to return the forms. Fifteen business days is reasonable. Tell them in writing they can keep their current arrangement (parking, schedule, whatever it is) while the forms are being completed. That’s both a courtesy and a hedge. It protects you in case the doctor confirms the need.

I recently advised a manufacturing client in California whose HR specialist handled this almost perfectly. An employee came in and asked about parking closer to the building. She gave him the forms, told him his doctor needed to fill them out, and gave him fifteen days. She also told him plainly that the request had nothing to do with the DMV placard he showed her. She was treating it as a separate accommodation question, which is exactly right.

Step 3. Evaluate

When the doctor’s response comes back, you have something to work with. Compare the recommendation against the essential functions of the job and figure out whether the recommended accommodation, or a reasonable alternative, lets the employee perform those essential functions without undue hardship to the business.

Three terms in that sentence carry weight.

Essential functions are what you put in the job description. If your job descriptions don’t say what’s essential, fix that.

Reasonable alternative means you don’t have to grant the exact accommodation requested if a different one works. The employee is entitled to an effective accommodation, not a specific one.

Undue hardship is a high bar. It isn’t “this is inconvenient.” It’s “this fundamentally disrupts how the business operates.” Cost matters, but a reasonable accommodation that costs a few hundred dollars at a 12-employee shop will rarely qualify as undue hardship on its own.

Step 4. Decide and document

Decide. Write the decision down. Send it to the employee in writing.

If you’re granting the accommodation, spell out the terms. What’s being granted, when it starts, how long it lasts, what the employee’s responsibilities are. If you’re denying it, spell out the reason. If you’re offering an alternative, spell that out too.

The documentation is the entire point. It’s how you show, six months from now or six years from now, that you engaged in good faith. Without it, you’re standing in front of a hearing officer telling a story. With it, you’re handing them a file.

Step 5. Follow through and revisit

If you granted an accommodation, monitor it. If circumstances change, revisit. The employee’s condition might have shifted. The job’s requirements might have changed. You might have grown. Accommodations aren’t lifetime contracts. They’re a snapshot of what works right now.

What if the employee doesn’t hold up their end

Back to the manufacturing client. The employee took the forms in November. He didn’t return them. The HR specialist followed up in December. He said he was busy with school and would get to the doctor’s appointment soon. She said please keep us updated. He still didn’t return the forms.

By March, four months after the original meeting, he was still parking in handicap spaces without an authorized accommodation. He got a written warning for the unauthorized parking. He refused to sign. He said other employees parked there too. He said singling him out wasn’t fair.

The advice I gave the company was that the warning was perfectly valid. His refusal to sign didn’t change anything. The November interactive-process meeting had superseded any informal parking arrangement he claimed had existed. And the company’s documented good-faith engagement was the reason the discipline would hold up if it ever got challenged. Handing him forms, giving him a deadline, following up in December, waiting four months. All of it was the file.

I also told them to verify that the same standard was being applied to anyone else parking in handicap spaces without authorization. His “others do it too” argument was legally weak, but inconsistent enforcement would have undermined the company in front of an investigator. Equal application of the rule was the missing piece.

This is what the interactive process actually does. It protects you from the small number of employees who try to use accommodation requests as cover. It also preserves your relationship with the much larger number of employees who do hold up their end, because the standard is consistent, the process is fair, and the documentation says so.

Following the law here isn’t just defensive. It’s how you treat your good people the way they deserve to be treated.

State-by-state quick notes

Federal ADA: applies at 15 or more employees. Definition of disability under the 2008 amendments is broad and covers a wide range of physical and mental impairments. Interactive process is required by EEOC regulation.

California (FEHA): applies at 5 or more employees. The state’s definition of disability is broader than federal. There’s no “substantial limitation” requirement. The interactive process is explicit in California regulation, and the failure to engage in it is itself an independent claim an employee can bring.

New York and New Jersey: state disability law reaches every employer, down to one employee. Washington: eight or more. All three define disability more broadly than the ADA does.

Other states: many go lower than 15. Minnesota, Michigan, Colorado, Alaska and Hawaii cover all employers. Connecticut starts at three. New Mexico, Ohio, Pennsylvania and Rhode Island at four. Oregon at six for disability. Check your state before you assume the federal 15 applies.

What this looks like in your manual

Five steps. Recognize the request. Engage the interactive process. Evaluate. Decide and document. Follow through.

Your manual should have a written accommodation policy that lays this process out for your managers in language they’ll actually use when a request comes in. The custom employee manual that comes with every AccompliCenter HR subscription includes exactly that: a state-tailored accommodation policy plus the forms your managers need to start the conversation. Plans start at $139 a month, and the manual is built for someone who runs a business, not for someone who reads regulations for fun.

This article is general information, not legal advice. For legal advice about your situation, consult a qualified attorney.

Back to the list of articles

Religious Accommodations: When You Have to Say Yes (And When You Don’t)

The short version

  • Groff v. DeJoy replaced the de minimis standard in 2023. Undue hardship now means substantial increased costs in the context of your particular business.
  • Coworker complaints and generalized administrative inconvenience are no longer a basis to deny a religious accommodation.
  • The EEOC has not updated its own compliance manual since Groff, so a policy drafted from that document understates your obligations.

These rules change every year, and California adds its own. A subscription gives you a California-certified HR professional to check your answer before you act. Call (562) 444-8076, email service@accomplicenter.com, or come by our store at 3217 Carson St in Lakewood to sign up.

In June 2023, the Supreme Court decided Groff v. DeJoy. The decision didn’t change the words of the statute, which still says employers must provide religious accommodation unless doing so would impose “undue hardship on the conduct of the employer’s business.” What it changed was the meaning of “undue hardship.”

For forty-six years, courts had interpreted “undue hardship” using a phrase from a 1977 case (TWA v. Hardison) that said anything more than a “de minimis cost” qualified. Trivial costs were enough to deny religious accommodation. After Groff, that’s gone. The new standard is “substantial increased costs,” which is materially harder to meet.

Most small employers haven’t updated their religious accommodation analysis to reflect the change.

The framework

Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 prohibits employment discrimination based on religion. As part of that prohibition, employers are required to provide reasonable accommodation for sincerely held religious beliefs and practices, unless doing so would cause undue hardship to the business.

Title VII applies at 15 or more employees. State analogs (California’s FEHA, New York’s Human Rights Law, others) apply at lower thresholds and sometimes use different standards.

The structure of the analysis:

The employee notifies the employer of a religious belief or practice that conflicts with a workplace requirement.

The employer engages in an interactive process to identify possible accommodations.

If a reasonable accommodation exists that doesn’t cause undue hardship, the employer must provide it.

If no reasonable accommodation can be identified, or if all possible accommodations would cause undue hardship, the employer can decline.

What “religious belief or practice” means

The definition is broad. A religious belief or practice includes:

Traditional religious observance (sabbath, holy days, religious dress, dietary restrictions, prayer requirements).

Beliefs that aren’t part of an organized religion but are sincerely held and function in the employee’s life as religious beliefs.

Beliefs that other adherents of the same religion don’t share. Sincerity is the standard, not orthodoxy.

The employer is generally not allowed to question the religious nature of a belief or to require the employee to prove the belief is sincere. There are exceptions when the employer has a reasonable basis to question sincerity (the employee’s prior conduct contradicts the claimed belief, the request appears to be tactical rather than religious), but these are narrow.

What’s not religious: political beliefs (even strongly held), personal preferences framed as religious, generic moral views without religious foundation. The line gets blurry, but the basic distinction is between belief in something transcendent and personal opinions on secular matters.

The Groff change

Before Groff, employers could deny religious accommodation if providing it would cause anything more than “de minimis cost.” This was a very low bar. A small administrative inconvenience was enough.

After Groff, the standard is “substantial increased costs in relation to the conduct of the employer’s particular business.” This is materially harder to meet. The cost has to be substantial, not minor. The cost has to be in relation to the employer’s business, which means the analysis is contextual.

What hasn’t changed:

Employers don’t have to violate other employees’ rights or impose unequal burdens on coworkers in order to accommodate.

Employers don’t have to violate seniority systems established under collective bargaining or otherwise.

Employers don’t have to grant accommodations that would prevent the employee from performing essential functions, or that would create safety risks that can’t be reasonably mitigated.

What has changed:

A small administrative cost is no longer sufficient to deny accommodation.

The “we’d have to pay overtime to cover the shift” argument is no longer automatic. The cost has to be substantial.

Coworker preferences and complaints about an accommodation no longer count as undue hardship. Animosity from coworkers isn’t a basis to deny.

Common religious accommodation situations

  • Sabbath and holy day observance. Schedule swaps, voluntary substitutes, schedule adjustments, partial day arrangements. Most cases can be accommodated through scheduling. The employer’s obligation is to make reasonable efforts to find a solution.
  • Religious attire and grooming. Head coverings, beards, religious jewelry, modest dress. Workplace dress codes have to be flexible enough to accommodate religious observance unless a specific dress code element is essential (for example, OSHA-required protective gear, where the religious item can’t be safely worn).
  • Prayer requirements. Brief breaks for prayer. Most can be accommodated through normal break time and minor schedule flexibility.
  • Religious holidays. Time off for religious holidays beyond the employer’s standard holiday calendar. Often accommodated through PTO use, schedule swaps, or unpaid time off.
  • Dietary restrictions. Generally low-burden in most workplaces. Accommodation might involve adjusting cafeteria offerings or allowing personal food storage.
  • Refusal of certain duties. A pharmacy employee who declines to dispense certain medications, a hospitality employee who declines to serve alcohol, a clerk who declines to issue certain licenses. These cases are harder because the duty being declined may be central to the job. Reassignment to a different role or shift may be possible; other times the duty is genuinely essential and accommodation isn’t feasible.

The interactive process

Like the ADA, religious accommodation requires an interactive process. The structure looks similar.

Step 1. Recognize the request. The employee notifies the employer of a religious belief or practice that conflicts with a work requirement. The notification doesn’t have to be formal

Step 2. Engage in conversation. Explore the specific need, the proposed accommodation, possible alternatives

Step 3. Evaluate. Whether the requested accommodation is feasible. Whether alternatives might work. Whether providing the accommodation would cause substantial increased costs

Step 4. Decide and communicate. In writing. With reasoning that documents the interactive process

Step 5. Implement and revisit. If granted, the accommodation goes into effect. If circumstances change, the conversation can reopen

What the post-Groff analysis actually looks like

After Groff, an undue-hardship denial requires more documentation than before. The employer needs to show:

The cost of accommodation is substantial. Specific dollars, not generalities.

The cost is in relation to the employer’s particular business. A $5,000 accommodation cost might be substantial for a 10-employee landscaping company and not substantial for a 200-employee manufacturer. Context matters.

Alternatives have been considered and either don’t work or have similar costs.

The denial isn’t based on coworker complaints, customer preferences, or generalized administrative inconvenience.

Most denials that worked under the de minimis standard don’t work under the new standard. Schedule swaps, shift coverage costs, dress code modifications, brief accommodations during a workday: most of these are below “substantial” costs in most workplaces.

Substantial doesn’t mean monetary only. The Ninth Circuit held in May 2026 that patient-safety risk, operational disruption and staffing consequences can satisfy Groff in a healthcare setting. The EEOC has also made religious accommodation an enforcement priority, with six public settlements since August 2025, including one over a million dollars. What it has not done is update its own compliance manual, which still describes the pre-Groff standard.

State variations

Some states have stricter religious accommodation standards than federal even before Groff:

  • California. Workplace Religious Freedom Act and FEHA require accommodation. CA’s standard has been broader than federal in some respects and may not have been substantially affected by Groff (because federal was previously narrower than CA, and Groff brought federal closer to CA).
  • New York. State Human Rights Law and NYC Human Rights Law require accommodation with similar broad reach.
  • Other states. Several have specific religious accommodation provisions, often with different specifics.

For multi-state employers, the higher standard governs in each state. A federal employer is now operating under a Groff-influenced standard everywhere; CA and NY employers may have to provide more.

What this looks like in your manual

Your handbook should have a religious accommodation section that:

States the company’s commitment to religious accommodation under federal and applicable state law. Describes the request process. References the interactive process. States that requests will be evaluated based on the post-Groff standard (substantial increased costs). Confirms that decisions will be documented in writing.

We include this in the custom employee manual that comes with every AccompliCenter HR subscription. The section was rewritten when Groff came down and reflects the substantial-increased-costs standard the courts are actually applying. Worth knowing: the EEOC has not updated its own compliance manual section on religion since Groff, so a policy drafted off that document will understate your obligations. Plans start at $139 a month.

If your handbook still describes religious accommodation using the pre-Groff “de minimis” framework, it’s out of date and may understate your obligations. Updating it is straightforward and worth doing before the next request comes in.

This article is general information, not legal advice. For legal advice about your situation, consult a qualified attorney.

Back to the list of articles

To subscribe, call us at (562) 444-8076, stop by our store at 3217 Carson St in Lakewood, or email service@accomplicenter.com.

See AccompliCenter HR plans →

Store Hours

Today
  • Mon
    Nov 16

    8:30AM
    —
    6:00PM
  • Tue
    Nov 17

    8:30AM
    —
    6:00PM
  • Wed
    Nov 18

    8:30AM
    —
    6:00PM
  • Thu
    Nov 19

    8:30AM
    —
    6:00PM
  • Fri
    Nov 20

    8:30AM
    —
    6:00PM
  • Sat
    Nov 21

    9:00AM
    —
    4:00PM
  • Sun
    Nov 22

    10:00AM
    —
    3:00PM