HR Consulting

blogheader

Job Descriptions That Protect You: The ADA-Aware Way to Write Them

I am not an attorney. This article is general information based on my experience as an HR professional, and it is not legal advice. For legal advice about your situation, consult a qualified attorney.

The short version

  • The job description defines essential functions for ADA analysis, supports your FLSA exemption, and anchors any performance termination.
  • Separate essential functions from marginal ones. Marginal functions can be reassigned as an accommodation; essential functions cannot.
  • Pay ranges are now required in job postings in fourteen states and the District of Columbia.

A single wage claim or agency charge can cost more than several years of an HR subscription. Plans start at $139 a month. Call (562) 444-8076, email service@accomplicenter.com, or come by our store at 3217 Carson St in Lakewood to sign up.

Most small-employer job descriptions are useless. Three sentences in a job posting, copied into a Word file, never updated, never referenced. The operator wrote it once when they were hiring and hasn’t looked at it since. The employee may never have seen the version that’s in the file.

A useful job description does work. It defines what “essential functions” mean if the employee ever requests an ADA accommodation. It supports your FLSA exemption analysis. It frames every performance conversation that follows. It anchors any termination decision based on performance gaps. It also helps the manager actually manage the role, which is the day-to-day function the document is supposed to serve.

The four jobs the document does

A job description does four jobs.

  • It defines essential functions. When an employee requests an accommodation under the ADA, the analysis turns on whether they can perform the essential functions of the position with reasonable accommodation. Essential functions are determined by what the job description says they are, by what the employee actually does day to day, and by what the employer’s judgment is about which functions are essential. The written job description is the most concrete evidence in this analysis.
  • It supports FLSA exemption analysis. Whether an employee is properly classified as exempt depends on their primary duty and whether that duty fits one of the exempt categories. The job description is where the primary duty is laid out. If the document says the primary duty is “managing the production team,” that supports executive exemption. If it says “performing routine inventory tasks,” it doesn’t.
  • It frames performance evaluation. Performance is measured against what the role is supposed to be. The job description is the document that defines what the role is supposed to be. Performance reviews that reference the job description are stronger than performance reviews that don’t, because they tie evaluation to a written standard rather than to the manager’s subjective sense of the role.
  • It anchors termination decisions for performance. When an employee is terminated for performance issues, the file needs to show the gap between what was expected (the job description) and what was delivered (documented performance). A vague or missing job description makes this harder.

What a useful job description includes

A useful job description has the following sections.

Position title. The actual title used internally and externally.

Reports to. The position the role reports to, by title.

  • Position summary. Two or three sentences describing the overall purpose of the role.
  • Essential functions. A list, typically five to ten items, of the functions the role performs that are essential. Each function should be specific, action-oriented, and measurable. “Manages a team of four production employees” is specific. “Helps with team management” is not.
  • Marginal functions. Functions the role performs that are not essential. Important to distinguish because marginal functions can be reassigned as part of an ADA accommodation; essential functions can’t be reassigned (the employee has to be able to perform them).
  • Required qualifications. Education, experience, licenses, certifications, physical abilities, schedule requirements. Each qualification has to be genuinely required for the job, not aspirational.
  • Preferred qualifications. Things that would be nice to have but aren’t required. Useful for hiring but kept distinct from required qualifications because the latter sets the bar for the role.
  • Physical demands. Specific to roles where physical capability matters. Lifting requirements, standing, sitting, climbing, repetitive motion, etc. This section gets attention in ADA accommodation analysis, so be specific and accurate.
  • Work environment. Where the work is performed. Office, factory floor, customer site, vehicle, outdoor. Includes any environmental factors (noise, temperature, exposure to chemicals, etc.) that might affect accommodation analysis.
  • Schedule. Days, hours, on-call requirements, travel expectations.
  • FLSA classification. Exempt or non-exempt. State equivalent if applicable.
  • Compensation range. Required in job postings in fourteen states and the District of Columbia, with thresholds that vary: California at 15 or more employees, Colorado, Connecticut, Hawaii at 50, Illinois at 15, Maryland, Massachusetts at 25, Minnesota at 30, Nevada, New Jersey at 10, New York at 4, Rhode Island, Vermont at 5, and Washington at 15. Several Ohio cities have their own rules, and Delaware joins in 2027. Check your state before you post.

The “essential function” question

The single most important section of a job description is the essential functions list. The list determines a lot of downstream legal analysis.

What makes a function essential. The EEOC and most state regulations identify several factors:

The job exists primarily to perform that function. A limited number of employees are available to perform the function (so reassignment isn’t easy). The function is highly specialized and the employee was hired specifically because of expertise in that function. The amount of time spent on the function. The consequences of not performing the function. The terms of any collective bargaining agreement. The actual experience of past or current employees in the position.

A job description that lists every conceivable task a person might do is not a job description. It’s a list. The exercise is to identify which tasks are essential and document them as such, with specifics.

How to write the functions

Each essential function should be:

  • Specific. Not “manages people” but “supervises a team of four to six production employees, including hiring recommendations, performance evaluation, and discipline.”
  • Action-oriented. Verbs, not adjectives. Not “responsible for inventory” but “maintains inventory records, conducts monthly counts, and reorders supplies based on minimum stock levels.”
  • Measurable where possible. Not “produces good work” but “completes 15 to 20 customer orders per day to quality standards.”
  • Tied to the job, not the person. Don’t write the description around the current person in the role. Write it around what the role requires regardless of who fills it.

The ADA accommodation connection

When an employee requests an ADA accommodation, the conversation often comes down to whether they can perform essential functions with reasonable accommodation.

If the job description is clear about essential functions, the conversation is straightforward. The employee needs to be able to perform these specific functions. The accommodation question is whether some adjustment lets them do so.

If the job description is vague or non-existent, the conversation becomes a debate about what the job actually requires, which the employee can argue is more flexible than the manager believes. The lack of a written job description weakens the employer’s position.

The same logic applies to fitness-for-duty after an injury or leave. The treating physician needs to know what functions the employee has to perform. Without a clear job description with specific physical demands, the physician is guessing, and you’re not getting a useful certification.

The FLSA exemption connection

For salaried-exempt employees, the duties test requires that the employee’s primary duty fit one of the exempt categories. Primary duty depends on what the employee actually does, which the job description should reflect.

A job description that says the role’s primary duty is “managing the operations team, including supervision of staff, scheduling, performance evaluation, and resource allocation” supports executive exemption. A job description that says the role “performs all production tasks alongside the team and assists with scheduling when needed” does not, even if the title is “Operations Manager.”

When the DOL or a plaintiff’s lawyer challenges a classification, the job description is the first document they look at. If it doesn’t support the classification, the analysis usually doesn’t go in the employer’s favor.

What a stale or missing job description does

A job description that hasn’t been updated in several years is often wrong. The role has evolved. New responsibilities have been added. Old responsibilities have been dropped. The written document doesn’t match what the person actually does.

This creates problems in several scenarios.

In an ADA accommodation request, the discrepancy between the written document and the actual role gives the employee room to argue that essential functions are different from what the written document says.

In an FLSA challenge, the discrepancy creates evidence that the employer wasn’t paying close attention to whether the classification was supported by the actual duties.

In a performance termination, the discrepancy means the standard the employee was being measured against doesn’t match the standard documented in the file.

In hiring, the discrepancy means new candidates are being evaluated against the wrong description.

The fix is to review job descriptions annually, at the same time you do your handbook review, and update them when the role has materially changed.

What this looks like in your manual

Your handbook should reference job descriptions as the document supporting essential functions, FLSA classification, and performance evaluation. The handbook itself doesn’t include the job descriptions; they live separately, organized by position.

The handbook’s discipline section should reference the job description as the standard against which performance is measured. The accommodation section should reference job descriptions as the source for essential functions in the interactive process. The FLSA section should reference job descriptions as the basis for exemption analysis.

We tie all of this together in the custom employee manual that comes with every AccompliCenter HR subscription. We don’t write the individual job descriptions for you, but we structure the handbook to reference them properly and we provide a job description template that follows the framework above. Plans start at $139 a month.

If you have employees and you don’t have job descriptions, or your job descriptions haven’t been updated in three years, this is one of the higher-leverage projects a small employer can do. The document is short. The work to write it well is real, but bounded. The protection it provides is across the lifecycle of the employment relationship.

To subscribe, call us at (562) 444-8076, stop by our store at 3217 Carson St in Lakewood, or email service@accomplicenter.com.

See AccompliCenter HR plans →

Store Hours

Today
  • Tue
    Nov 17

    8:30AM
    —
    6:00PM
  • Wed
    Nov 18

    8:30AM
    —
    6:00PM
  • Thu
    Nov 19

    8:30AM
    —
    6:00PM
  • Fri
    Nov 20

    8:30AM
    —
    6:00PM
  • Sat
    Nov 21

    9:00AM
    —
    4:00PM
  • Sun
    Nov 22

    10:00AM
    —
    3:00PM
  • Mon
    Nov 23

    8:30AM
    —
    6:00PM