Hiring and At-Will Employment for Small Employers
By John Hamilton, MS, PHRca, PHR · Reviewed for legal currency August 2026
I am not an attorney. These articles are general information based on my experience as an HR professional, and they are not legal advice. For legal advice about your situation, consult a qualified attorney.
If a position requires fingerprinting, we take Live Scan fingerprints at our store, with no appointment needed.
Hiring Is the Most Important Decision You’ll Ever Make as an Employer
The short version
- Every employment-law decision that follows starts from who you hired.
- Spend the time on the job description, the interview, the reference check and the background check. The front end is cheap and the back end is not.
- A clean failure has a manual, a job description, documented expectations and a documented gap. A messy one has your memory.
These rules change every year, and California adds its own. A subscription gives you a California-certified HR professional to check your answer before you act. Call (562) 444-8076, email service@accomplicenter.com, or come by our store at 3217 Carson St in Lakewood to sign up.
If you ask me what the single most important decision a small employer makes is, I’ll tell you it’s the hire. Not because it’s the most expensive decision (it’s usually not). Not because it’s the most legally fraught (although hiring is full of traps). Because every other employment-law decision that follows starts from who you brought on.
A good hire makes the manual a friendly reminder of how things work around here. They read it on day one, they ask a few questions, they nod, and you barely have to think about it again. The manual sits in their drawer and supports a relationship that’s mostly working.
A bad hire turns the manual into the only thing standing between you and a lawsuit. Now the at-will language matters. Now the discipline policy matters. Now the complaint procedure matters. Now the documentation you wish you’d kept matters. The manual stops being a friendly reminder and starts being your file.
This is why I tell every operator to spend disproportionate time on the front end of the hire. The front end is cheap. The back end isn’t.
What the front end actually looks like
Spend more time on the job description than feels comfortable. The job description is the document that defines what “essential functions” mean if the employee ever asks for an accommodation. It’s the document that supports your FLSA exemption analysis if you ever get audited. It’s the document that frames every performance conversation that follows. Get it right.
Spend more time on the interview than feels comfortable. The interview is the only chance you get to learn who this person actually is before you’re paying them. Use the time. Ask behavioral questions. Ask follow-up questions. Listen for the things that don’t quite line up.
Run reference checks. Most operators skip this because references are inconvenient and the previous employer is going to confirm dates of employment and not much else. Do it anyway. The five-minute call to a former supervisor occasionally surfaces something that changes the decision, and the documentation that you ran the references shows up later if you’re ever asked whether you exercised reasonable care.
Run a background check, with the employee’s signed authorization, in compliance with the federal Fair Credit Reporting Act and your state’s ban-the-box rules. Most small employers don’t, and most of the time they get away with it. Some of the time they don’t.
For a senior hire, a leadership hire, or any role where a miscast costs you real money, consider an assessment. We wrote a separate post on the CPI 260, which is the validated personality instrument I use for clients who want to de-risk a high-stakes hire. The science on selection assessments is robust when the right tool is used the right way. The cost of one is a fraction of the cost of a wrong hire.
What the manual does after the hire
Most operators think of the manual as a defensive document. It is, but only partly. The bigger function is that the manual sets the standard for performance from day one. It tells the new hire how this place works. It tells them what’s expected. It tells them what behavior gets praised and what behavior gets corrected. It does this in writing, signed and acknowledged, before there’s any disagreement about it.
When the new hire performs well, the manual is just the agreement that’s working. When the new hire underperforms, the manual is the standard you can point to and say “this is what you signed up for, here’s where the gap is, here’s what we’re going to do about it.” Performance conversations get easier when the standard exists in writing. Discipline gets cleaner when the standard exists in writing. And if the performance issue eventually leads to a termination, the manual is the roadmap for doing the termination cleanly and legally.
When the hire doesn’t work out
Even with the best front-end work, some hires don’t work out. The job changes, the person changes, the chemistry doesn’t develop, the skills weren’t quite there. This is a normal part of running a business with employees. The question isn’t whether some hires fail, because some hires always do. The question is whether you’ve set yourself up to handle the failure cleanly.
- Clean failure looks like this. The new hire received the manual on day one and signed for it. The job description was specific about essential functions and was given to them. Performance expectations were communicated clearly. When performance dipped, you documented the gap against the standard. You had a conversation. You documented the conversation. The standard didn’t get hit, and you moved to next steps from a position with a clear written record.
- Messy failure looks like this. The new hire came in without a manual. The job description was a paragraph. Performance expectations were “you know, just do good work.” When performance dipped, you said something to them in the parking lot. There’s no record of any conversation. Now you want to terminate, and your defense is your own memory, which the employee may or may not share.
- The first version is uncomfortable but defensible. The second version is the one that turns into a lawsuit.
The bigger picture
Hiring isn’t separate from your manual, your policies, or your day-to-day management. It’s the front end of all of it.
When you hire well and onboard well, your manual becomes the document that supports the relationship instead of the document that defends you against it. Your discipline conversations become coaching conversations. Your accommodation requests become collaborative problem-solving. Your performance reviews become opportunities to invest in someone who’s invested in you.
A good hire is the highest-return investment you can make in your business. A bad hire is the most expensive single mistake. The work you do at the front end determines which one you got, and the manual you put in their hands on day one determines what happens next.
Every AccompliCenter HR subscription includes a custom employee manual, because the manual is the document that connects hiring to everything that follows. It is tailored to your state and written in plain English. Plans start at $139 a month. If you’re about to hire and you don’t have one, get one before they start.
This article is general information, not legal advice. For legal advice about your situation, consult a qualified attorney.
Back to the list of articles
What “At-Will Employment” Actually Means (And the 5 Words That Can Wreck It)
The short version
- At-will is the default in 49 states. Montana is the exception, and its default probationary period is now 12 months, extendable to 18.
- Five phrases turn it off: “permanent position,” “long-term employment,” “as long as you perform,” “we’ll always have a place for you,” and a “good cause” list of termination reasons.
- Progressive discipline written as “will” instead of “may” is a contract you then have to follow.
If this article raised a question about your own business, that is what our subscription is for. Plans start at $139 a month. Call (562) 444-8076, email service@accomplicenter.com, or come by our store at 3217 Carson St in Lakewood to sign up.
Most small employers will tell you their employees are at-will. Most of them are right in theory and wrong in practice, because their offer letters and their handbooks and their managers’ verbal promises have accidentally turned at-will employment off without anyone noticing.
At-will is a powerful default. It means you can terminate the employment relationship at any time, with or without notice, with or without cause, as long as the reason isn’t unlawful (no firing for protected-class reasons, no firing in retaliation for protected activity, no firing in violation of public policy). Forty-nine of fifty states recognize this default. Montana is the holdout, and its Wrongful Discharge from Employment Act was amended in 2025: the default probationary period during which an employer may discharge without good cause is now 12 months, extendable by the employer to 18.
Five phrases give at-will away more often than any others.
The five phrases that can wreck at-will
1. “Permanent position.” As in: “We’re pleased to offer you this permanent position.” Sounds reassuring. Means something specific in employment law. A “permanent position” is a position the employee holds permanently. The employee can argue, sometimes successfully, that you’ve contracted to keep them indefinitely as long as their performance is acceptable.
The fix is straightforward. Don’t use “permanent” anywhere in your offer letter or your handbook. Say “regular full-time position” or “ongoing position” or just “position” if you want to convey the same meaning without the implication.
2. “Long-term employment.” Same problem as “permanent.” Implies a duration commitment you don’t actually want to make. Same fix. Drop the phrase.
3. “As long as you perform.” As in: “You’ll have a job here as long as you perform.” Friendly. Reassuring. Creates an implied contract that says the employer will not terminate as long as performance is acceptable. Now if you terminate someone whose performance is debatable, you’ve broken the implied promise, and the question of whether their performance was actually acceptable becomes a question for a jury.
The fix is the same. Don’t say it. Don’t write it. Train your managers not to say it.
4. “We’ll always have a place for you.” Or any variation. “There will always be work here for you.” “We’ll take care of you.” “You’re family here.” These phrases are meant to be welcoming. They function as promises. A jury can find that the company committed to ongoing employment, and the employee can recover damages when the commitment isn’t honored.
I know operators say things like this without thinking, and I know they mean well when they do. The fix is to retrain the impulse. Welcome the new hire, express enthusiasm about working with them, do all of that. Just don’t promise them ongoing employment as part of it.
5. “Just cause” or “good cause” termination language in the handbook. Some handbooks say something like “the company may terminate employees for good cause, including…” and then list a set of categories. The intent is to communicate the kinds of behavior that lead to termination. The effect is to limit the company’s right to terminate to those categories, which means anything outside the list is not a permitted reason for termination.
This is one of the most common ways small-employer handbooks accidentally turn at-will off. The fix is to use language like “employment is at-will and may be terminated by either party at any time, with or without cause.” Then, if you want to give examples of behavior that leads to discipline, frame them as examples, not as the exclusive list. “Examples of conduct that may lead to discipline up to and including termination include, but are not limited to…”
The phrases that don’t wreck at-will but get used wrong
A few items that aren’t on the five-phrase list but cause similar problems.
Progressive discipline policies that read as commitments. A handbook that says “the company will use progressive discipline including verbal warning, written warning, final warning, and termination” creates an obligation. Now if you skip a step (say, you fire someone after a single bad incident), the employee has a claim that you violated the company’s own policy. The fix is to use “may” instead of “will.” “The company may use progressive discipline” reserves the flexibility you actually need.
Probationary periods. Some handbooks have a 90-day probationary period after which the employee is no longer probationary. The implication is that after probation, the employment relationship has changed. Some employees, and some lawyers, will argue this means at-will ended at the 90-day mark and the employee is now in a more protected status. The fix is either to drop the probationary concept entirely or to call it an “introductory period” and explicitly state that at-will applies during the introductory period and continues after it.
Annual reviews promised in writing. “The company will conduct annual performance reviews.” Now if you skip a year, the employee has a basis to argue you didn’t follow your own policy. Use “may” or restructure the policy as a description of practice rather than a commitment.
What to put in the offer letter
A good offer letter explicitly states at-will. Two places. First, in the offer itself: “This is an offer of at-will employment, which means that either you or the company may terminate the employment relationship at any time, with or without notice, with or without cause.” Second, in the acknowledgment the employee signs: “I understand and agree that my employment is at-will and that nothing in this letter or in any communication with the company creates a contract or a guarantee of continued employment.”
What to leave out: anything resembling “permanent,” “long-term,” “as long as you perform,” “there will always be a place for you,” or “we expect you to be here for years.” Even when these phrases are sincere expressions of welcome, they create legal exposure that didn’t have to be there.
The state exceptions to at-will
Even with strong at-will language in your offer letter and your handbook, every state recognizes some exceptions to at-will employment. The exceptions vary by state. The most common ones:
- Public-policy exceptions. You can’t terminate someone for a reason that violates public policy. Filing a workers’ compensation claim, refusing to commit a crime at the employer’s direction, exercising a statutory right (like jury duty or whistleblowing). Most states recognize this exception.
- Implied-contract exceptions. This is the exception the five phrases above can create. Some states recognize implied contracts based on offer letters, handbooks, or oral promises. California is among the broader of these.
- Implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing. A small number of states recognize a duty of good faith in employment, which limits at-will somewhat. California, again, is among them.
- Statutory exceptions. Federal and state anti-discrimination laws, anti-retaliation laws, FMLA, ADA, and others all carve out reasons you can’t terminate. These aren’t really exceptions to at-will. They’re the floor that at-will operates above.
The takeaway is that at-will isn’t absolute even where you’ve kept the language clean. It’s a strong default with specific carve-outs. Understanding the carve-outs is part of running a business with employees. Avoiding the five phrases above is the part you have direct control over.
What this means for your manual
A handbook that does its job will:
State at-will employment in the front of the document, in plain language. Repeat at-will employment in the acknowledgment the employee signs. Use “may” instead of “will” for any disciplinary, review, or process commitment that isn’t actually mandatory. Avoid “permanent,” “long-term,” “as long as you perform,” and similar phrases. Frame examples of disciplinable conduct as examples, not as an exhaustive list. Be reviewed periodically against your offer letters and your verbal practices to make sure they all line up.
We do this work as part of the custom employee manual that comes with every AccompliCenter HR subscription. State-specific, with at-will language built in correctly across the document and the acknowledgment, and aligned with your offer letter language. Plans start at $139 a month.
If you’re an at-will employer and you want to stay that way, the cheapest insurance is a handbook that does the language right. The most expensive accident is finding out at deposition that an offhand phrase in an offer letter has cost you the at-will protection you assumed you had.
This article is general information, not legal advice. For legal advice about your situation, consult a qualified attorney.
Back to the list of articles
Offer Letters That Don’t Accidentally Become Contracts
The short version
- An offer letter is evidence of what you committed to. Most small-employer offer letters commit to more than the operator realized.
- State at-will twice: in the body of the letter and again in the acknowledgment the employee signs.
- State the annual salary with its per-pay-period equivalent, and tie any bonus to conditions and to active employment on the payment date.
Fixing an HR mistake after the fact costs more than preventing it. Subscriptions start at $139 a month, and every plan includes a custom employee manual. Call (562) 444-8076, email service@accomplicenter.com, or come by our store at 3217 Carson St in Lakewood to sign up.
An offer letter is one page. Most operators treat it as a formality. The candidate accepts, you both sign, the letter goes in a drawer.
The drawer is where it stays until something goes wrong. At that point, the offer letter becomes evidence. Specifically, it becomes evidence of what you committed to when you brought the employee on. Most small-employer offer letters commit to more than the operator realized.
Seven phrases show up in offer letters and turn at-will employment off. Some come from vendor templates. Some are language operators write themselves to sound welcoming.
Phrase 1: “Permanent position”
“We’re pleased to offer you this permanent position as Senior Operations Manager.” Sounds appropriate. Means something specific. A “permanent” position is a position the employee holds permanently. Some courts have read this as creating an implied contract for ongoing employment.
Fix: drop “permanent” entirely. Use “regular full-time position” or just “position.”
Phrase 2: “Long-term employment”
Same problem. Implies duration. “We see this as a long-term role for you.” Read in the employee’s favor at trial: the company committed to a long-term arrangement.
Fix: don’t write it. Train hiring managers not to say it during interviews.
Phrase 3: “As long as you perform”
“You’ll have a job here as long as you perform.” Friendly during the offer call. Reassuring on day one. Creates an implied contract that says the company won’t terminate as long as performance is acceptable. Now whether performance was acceptable becomes the question for a jury.
Fix: don’t say it, don’t write it.
Phrase 4: “We expect you to be here for years”
Variations: “We’re investing in you for the long term.” “This is a position we expect you to grow in for a decade.” “We’re betting on you for the next several years.” Each one sounds like enthusiasm and ends up sounding like a commitment in front of an arbitrator.
Fix: express enthusiasm in non-durational language. “We’re excited to have you join the team.” “We think you’re a great fit for what we’re building.” Keep the warmth, drop the calendar.
Phrase 5: “Subject to satisfactory performance”
This one sounds like it preserves at-will. It doesn’t. “Your continued employment is subject to satisfactory performance” implies that satisfactory performance is the standard for continued employment, which means unsatisfactory performance is the standard for termination, which means the only legitimate reason to terminate is unsatisfactory performance, which is no longer at-will.
Fix: just say at-will. “Your employment is at-will, meaning either party may terminate the relationship at any time, with or without cause, with or without notice.” That’s the language. Don’t dress it up.
Phrase 6: A salary stated as an annual figure without a per-pay-period equivalent
“Your annual salary will be $75,000.” Standard. Also problematic. Some courts have read annual-salary language as a commitment to one year of employment, with the salary representing the agreed-upon compensation for that period.
Fix: state the annual figure for clarity, then state the per-pay-period equivalent. “Your salary will be $75,000 per year, paid as $2,884.62 biweekly. This is your rate of pay, not a contract for any specific term of employment.”
Phrase 7: Specific bonus language without conditions
“You’ll receive a $10,000 annual bonus.” Sounds clear. Now the bonus is owed regardless of performance, regardless of whether the employee is still employed at the time the bonus would normally be paid, regardless of company financial performance.
Fix: tie bonuses to specific conditions. “You’ll be eligible for an annual discretionary bonus of up to $10,000, based on individual and company performance, in the company’s sole discretion. Bonus eligibility requires active employment on the payment date.”
What an offer letter should actually contain
A clean offer letter for an exempt employee in an at-will state includes:
A statement of the position offered (title and brief job description or reference to attached job description). The pay (annual salary plus per-pay-period equivalent, or hourly rate). The pay schedule (biweekly, semimonthly, etc.). The classification (exempt or non-exempt under FLSA and any state law). The start date. A clear at-will statement, in the body of the letter and again in the acknowledgment block. Reference to the employee handbook, with acknowledgment that the handbook is not a contract. Any contingencies (background check, drug screen, I-9 verification, signed handbook acknowledgment) and the consequence if a contingency fails. A statement that the offer letter is the entire agreement and supersedes any prior verbal or written representations. Signature lines.
What it should not contain: any of the seven phrases above, any specific durational commitment, any “always” or “never” language, any guarantees about future role changes or promotions. Non-compete language deserves its own decision. The FTC’s national ban was vacated in August 2024 and the agency abandoned its appeal in September 2025, so non-competes are now purely a state-law question, and the states are moving. California, Minnesota, North Dakota and Oklahoma ban them outright for employees; Washington’s broad ban takes effect June 30, 2027; more than a hundred bills were pending across 34 states as of March 2026. Don’t drop boilerplate non-compete language into an offer letter without checking the state.
The handbook acknowledgment connection
The offer letter and the handbook acknowledgment work together. The offer letter establishes at-will at hire. The handbook acknowledgment reinforces at-will and confirms the employee understands the handbook isn’t a contract. If either document is weak, the other has to do double duty.
A handbook with strong at-will language won’t fully protect you if the offer letter created an implied contract before the handbook was ever signed. An offer letter with strong at-will language won’t fully protect you if the handbook later promised “progressive discipline including written warnings before termination” and the company skipped a step.
The two documents have to align.
What a good offer letter looks like
A model offer letter, with the components above, runs about one page. It’s not legalese. It’s clear, friendly, and businesslike. It says what’s being offered, on what terms, with what understandings. It doesn’t promise anything that wasn’t actually negotiated. It establishes at-will twice. It references the handbook and the acknowledgment.
We provide template offer letters as part of the custom employee manual that comes with every AccompliCenter HR subscription. State-tailored, integrated with the handbook acknowledgment, drafted to avoid the seven phrases above. Plans start at $139 a month.
If your current offer letter has any of these phrases, fix it before the next hire. The fix is a 20-minute edit. The cost of leaving it alone is whatever the next implied-contract claim costs.
This article is general information, not legal advice. For legal advice about your situation, consult a qualified attorney.
Back to the list of articles
I-9 for Small Businesses: A Plain-English Walkthrough (Plus the Self-Audit)
The short version
- Use the Form I-9 edition expiring 05/31/2027. The prior edition stopped being acceptable on August 1, 2026.
- Section 2 is due within three business days of the employee’s first day of work for pay.
- ICE reclassified more than ten error types as substantive on March 16, 2026. The 10-day cure window is gone and each form carries $288 to $2,861.
Employment law is complicated, and one mistake can cost far more than a year of help. An AccompliCenter HR subscription starts at $139 a month. Call (562) 444-8076, email service@accomplicenter.com, or come by our store at 3217 Carson St in Lakewood to sign up.
The I-9 form is one of those documents that most small employers fill out wrong, file wrong, and then forget about. ICE changed its enforcement policy on March 16, 2026 in a way that materially raises the cost of those errors. Run the self-audit below in the next 30 to 60 days.
What the I-9 is and why it exists
The Form I-9 verifies that the people working for you are eligible to work in the United States. It’s required by federal law for every new hire, regardless of citizenship, regardless of how long they’ll be working, regardless of whether they’re full-time, part-time, or seasonal. It’s a paperwork check, not an immigration enforcement function. You’re not investigating anyone. You’re confirming that the documents the employee presents look reasonably authentic and establish identity and work authorization.
The form has three parts. Section 1 is completed by the employee. Section 2 is completed by you, the employer, after looking at the employee’s documents. Supplement B is completed by you in limited situations (reverification, rehires within three years); on the current edition it replaces what used to be Section 3. Supplement A holds the preparer or translator certification.
The current edition of the form is the 01/20/25 edition with an expiration of 05/31/2027. Use the current edition for every new hire going forward. Download from uscis.gov/i-9.
The 3-day rule
The timing on Section 2 is the rule most small employers miss. Section 2 must be completed within three business days of the employee’s first day of work for pay. Not three calendar days. Three business days.
If the employee starts on a Monday, Section 2 must be completed by Thursday. If they start on a Friday, Section 2 must be completed by Wednesday of the following week. If they start work for less than three days (a one-day temp job, for example), Section 2 must be completed by the end of the first day.
The 3-day rule is a fineable item. Late completion is a paperwork violation, and ICE counts each one separately.
What documents to accept
Section 2 requires the employee to present documents that establish both identity and work authorization. The form has three lists.
List A documents establish both identity and work authorization in a single document. A US passport. A Permanent Resident Card. A foreign passport with an I-551 stamp. An employment authorization document.
List B documents establish identity only. A driver’s license. A state-issued ID card. A school ID with photo for those under 18.
List C documents establish work authorization only. A Social Security card. A birth certificate. An employment authorization document issued by DHS.
The employee chooses what to present. You don’t get to specify which documents they bring. They can bring one List A document, or one List B document plus one List C document. That’s it. You inspect the documents in their physical presence (or via the procedures for remote verification if eligible), record the document information on the form, and return the originals.
You can ask for additional documents only if what was presented isn’t reasonably acceptable on its face. You cannot ask for specific documents from a specific list. Specifying documents is a documentary practice violation, which is itself a fineable item separate from any actual paperwork error.
What the new enforcement landscape looks like
ICE changed its I-9 enforcement policy on March 16, 2026. The change matters.
Common paperwork errors that previously carried a 10-day cure window (where the employer could fix the error and avoid a fine) now trigger immediate fines of $288 to $2,861 per form. The cure window is gone for most paperwork violations. Worksite audits are up. The window to fix errors closes the moment a Notice of Inspection is served.
What this means in practice: the math on doing nothing has gotten worse. A small employer with 30 active employees and a few retained terminated-employee forms might have 35 to 40 forms on file. If each form has even one paperwork error, the exposure on a single inspection runs from $10,000 to $100,000 or more. The audit you do yourself, today, costs you only time. The audit ICE does later costs you money.
The self-audit
I’m telling every client to run an internal I-9 self-audit in the next 30 to 60 days. Tedious work. Worth doing.
Step 1. Pull every I-9 on file. Active employees and retained terminated-employee forms. Don’t skip the retained ones. Many of them are still subject to inspection, and many of them have errors
Step 2. Go through each form field by field. Section 1 must be completed and signed by the employee on or before the first day of work. Section 2 must be completed by the employer within three business days. Names, dates, document numbers, and signature lines all need to match what’s required
Step 3. Fix errors the right way. Draw a single line through the wrong entry, write the correction, initial, and date. No white-out. No backdating. No replacement forms
Section 1 corrections must be made by the employee, not by you. If the original Section 1 is missing information or has an error in the employee’s portion, the employee has to fix it. For former employees who can’t be reached, USCIS has an approved memo procedure that lets you document the error and the attempted correction. Use it. Document everything.
Step 4. If you use an electronic I-9 system, confirm the version. The prior edition, the one showing an expiration of 07/31/2026, stopped being acceptable on August 1, 2026. Only the edition showing 05/31/2027 may be used for new hires and reverifications. Get written confirmation from your vendor that their system generates the current edition. If it doesn’t, every form it produces is defective
Step 5. Dispose of forms past their retention window. I-9 forms must be retained for the later of three years from the hire date or one year from the termination date. Forms past that window are no longer required, and keeping them only adds to your audit exposure. Dispose of them per your records-retention policy
Section 1 vs Section 2 corrections
This is the part of self-audits that trips people up. Section 1 is the employee’s section. Section 2 is yours. They get fixed differently.
If you find an error in Section 1 (missing date, missing signature, missing field), the employee has to fix it. You can’t fix it for them, and you can’t have someone else sign for them. If the employee is still working for you, get them to make the correction in your physical presence (or via the remote procedures), with their initials and date.
If the employee no longer works for you and you can’t reach them, document the error and the unsuccessful attempt to correct. Use the USCIS memo procedure: a brief memo attached to the form explaining what the error is, when it was discovered, what efforts you made to reach the former employee, and that the correction couldn’t be made. This isn’t a fix. It’s a documented good-faith record that you tried.
If you find an error in Section 2 (your section), correct it yourself. Single line through the wrong entry, write the correction, initial, and date.
E-Verify by state
E-Verify is the federal program that runs employee information through DHS and SSA databases to verify work authorization. It’s voluntary at the federal level for most employers, but several states have made it mandatory.
E-Verify is mandatory for at least some private employers in roughly ten states, and the thresholds vary widely: Alabama, Arizona, Mississippi and South Carolina reach all or nearly all private employers; Florida at 25 or more; Georgia at 10 or more; North Carolina at 25 or more; plus Tennessee, Utah and Louisiana with their own thresholds. Ohio added a construction-sector mandate effective March 19, 2026 covering every nonresidential construction contractor, subcontractor and labor broker, with penalties of $250 to $25,000 per employee. Confirm your state’s threshold with the state agency before you rely on a number; the secondary sources disagree with each other.
California prohibits employers from requiring E-Verify as a condition of employment unless required by federal law or as a condition of receiving federal funds. If you’re a multi-state employer, this is one of the places where state law materially affects your I-9 program.
What an audit actually looks like
A formal ICE Notice of Inspection arrives in writing. The Notice gives you three business days to produce the I-9 forms for current and recent employees. The exact list of forms requested varies, but it’s typically all active and recent (last few years) employee files.
You assemble the forms. ICE reviews them. ICE issues findings, which can include substantive violations (employees not authorized to work) and paperwork violations (errors in form completion). Substantive violations carry separate, larger fines. Paperwork violations carry the $288 to $2,861 per-form range.
You may have an opportunity to negotiate down the paperwork findings if the errors are minor and the company has a documented compliance program. The self-audit you run before the inspection is part of that compliance documentation.
What this looks like in your manual
Your handbook should have a written I-9 retention and audit policy. It should reference your designated representative who handles I-9 completion and storage. It should reference the retention period (later of three years from hire or one year from termination). It should reference the self-audit cadence (annual is reasonable; biennial is the floor).
We include this in the custom employee manual that comes with every AccompliCenter HR subscription. State-tailored, including the E-Verify language for your state, with the I-9 procedures laid out for your designated representative. Plans start at $139 a month.
If you don’t have an I-9 procedure in writing and you haven’t audited your forms recently, the next 30 to 60 days are the right time to fix both. The window to fix paperwork errors closes the moment ICE shows up. Don’t wait.
This article is general information, not legal advice. For legal advice about your situation, consult a qualified attorney.
Back to the list of articles
Background Check Laws for Small Employers (FCRA + State Ban-the-Box)
The short version
- The FCRA disclosure has to be a stand-alone document. Bundling it into the application is the most common violation and the basis of most class actions.
- Pre-adverse notice with a copy of the report, a reasonable wait, then the adverse action notice. Skipping either one is a separate violation.
- Fifteen states apply fair-chance rules to private employers. New York is not one of them at the state level, though New York City is.
You do not have to work through these rules alone. Our HR subscribers email or call us whenever a question comes up, and plans start at $139 a month. Call (562) 444-8076, email service@accomplicenter.com, or come by our store at 3217 Carson St in Lakewood to sign up.
Most small employers run background checks on new hires without thinking much about the legal framework around them. The check happens through a third-party vendor, the report comes back, the hire moves forward or doesn’t. The compliance is invisible until it isn’t.
The federal Fair Credit Reporting Act and a growing list of state ban-the-box laws regulate exactly when, how, and what you can do with the results of a background check. Skipping a step is the kind of thing that turns into a class-action FCRA claim, which has been one of the higher-volume employment-class-action categories for the past decade.
The FCRA process
Three steps, each required, in this order.
Step 1. Disclosure and authorization. Before you order the background check, you have to give the candidate a clear and conspicuous written disclosure that a background check will be obtained, and you have to get the candidate’s written authorization to obtain it. The disclosure has to be in a stand-alone document. Not buried in an application. Not bundled with other forms. A separate document
- The most common FCRA violation is bundling. Operators put the disclosure on page 12 of the employment application. The class actions argue (often successfully) that this isn’t a stand-alone disclosure and the FCRA was violated. Damages are statutory at $100 to $1,000 per violation, plus attorney fees. Multiply by every applicant ever processed under the bundled form and the math gets ugly.
- The fix is straightforward. A separate, stand-alone disclosure form. One page. The disclosure language. The authorization language. The candidate’s signature. That’s it.
- Step 2: Run the check. The third-party consumer reporting agency (Checkr, Sterling, GoodHire, etc.) runs the check. The report comes back to you.
Step 3. If you’re considering an adverse decision, the pre-adverse and adverse action notices. If the report contains information you’re considering using as a basis for not hiring (or for some other adverse decision), you have to follow a two-step notice process
First, the pre-adverse action notice. You send the candidate a notice that includes a copy of the report and a copy of the FCRA “Summary of Your Rights.” You have to wait a reasonable time (typically five business days) before taking the adverse action, to give the candidate a chance to dispute or explain.
Second, the adverse action notice. After you’ve made the decision, you send the candidate a final adverse action notice that includes the consumer reporting agency’s contact information and informs the candidate of their right to obtain a free copy of the report and dispute its accuracy.
Skipping either notice is a separate FCRA violation. Skipping both is two violations per candidate. Class actions love this.
The “stand-alone document” rule in detail
The FCRA requires the disclosure to be “in a document that consists solely of the disclosure.” The Ninth Circuit and Third Circuit have read this strictly. A disclosure with a release of liability included in the same document violates the FCRA. A disclosure with state-law-specific notices included in the same document violates the FCRA.
The acceptable practice is a clean, single-purpose disclosure document. State-law notices that the FCRA specifically permits to be included can be included. Anything else has to be separate.
Vendor forms are the usual source. The vendor provides a form, the form looks reasonable, the form violates the standalone rule, and the class action follows years later when someone notices.
If you’re using a vendor for background checks, ask the vendor specifically: is your disclosure form compliant with the standalone rule under the FCRA. Get the answer in writing. If the answer is anything other than an unambiguous yes, get a different vendor or a different form.
State ban-the-box laws
Beyond the FCRA, an increasing number of states and cities prohibit asking about criminal history early in the hiring process and limit when and how a criminal record can be used in hiring decisions.
The general structure of a ban-the-box law is this. You can’t ask about criminal history on the initial application. You can ask later in the process (often after a conditional offer has been made). When you obtain criminal history information, you have to do an individualized assessment that considers the nature of the offense, the time since the offense, and the relationship between the offense and the job. You have to provide a copy of the report and an opportunity to respond before making an adverse decision.
Fifteen states have fair-chance hiring laws that reach private employers: California, Colorado, Connecticut, Hawaii, Illinois, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, Minnesota, New Jersey, New Mexico, Oregon, Rhode Island, Vermont and Washington. New York is the one people get wrong. New York State restricts how private employers may use criminal history (Correction Law Article 23-A and Human Rights Law § 296), but it has no statewide application-stage ban; the box comes off the application only in New York City, Buffalo, Rochester, Suffolk County and Westchester County. Many cities (Los Angeles, San Francisco, Seattle, Chicago, Philadelphia) have their own ordinances on top of state law.
The specifics vary substantially by state. California’s Fair Chance Act has a detailed individualized-assessment requirement and a specific notice-and-response timeline. New York City has specific notice requirements and timing. Each jurisdiction has its own rules, and a multi-state employer needs to handle each one separately.
What you can and can’t do with the results
Even after you have the report, what you can do with it is limited.
You can’t categorically exclude based on a criminal record. The EEOC’s 2012 criminal-record guidance is still posted, but the federal enforcement posture behind it has shifted: an April 2025 executive order directed agencies to deprioritize disparate-impact liability, and a June 2026 Justice Department opinion called the EEOC’s disparate-impact guidelines unlawful. Neither changes the statute or the Supreme Court precedent, private plaintiffs still bring these claims, and state law requires the individualized assessment outright. A blanket “no felonies” or “no convictions in the past 10 years” policy is still a bad policy.
You have to do the individualized assessment. Consider the nature of the offense, the time elapsed, the relationship to the job, the candidate’s explanation, evidence of rehabilitation, and any other relevant factors. Document the assessment.
You can’t use arrests as the basis for a decision. Most jurisdictions limit consideration to convictions, not arrests. Arrests without convictions generally can’t be used to deny employment.
You have to follow the FCRA notice process. Adverse action based on a criminal record still requires the pre-adverse and adverse action notices.
You can’t ask about expunged or sealed records in most jurisdictions. Expungement laws vary, but the general principle is that an expunged record doesn’t exist for employment-decision purposes.
When the screening is automated
California’s Civil Rights Department regulations, effective October 1, 2025, treat an automated decision system used in recruitment, screening, interviewing, selection or promotion as covered by FEHA. Anti-bias testing isn’t mandated, but whether you did it, how recently, and what it showed are all evidence in a discrimination defense, and the absence of testing is evidence too. Records tied to the system have to be kept four years, and you are liable for a vendor’s tool as if it were your own. Illinois amended its Human Rights Act effective January 1, 2026 to bar AI-driven discrimination and the use of ZIP codes as proxies for protected classes, and to require notice when AI is used in employment decisions; the implementing rules were withdrawn in June 2026 but the statute binds regardless. New York City requires an annual independent bias audit for automated employment decision tools, with the summary posted publicly and 10 business days’ notice to candidates. Texas prohibits developing or deploying AI with intent to discriminate, effective January 1, 2026. Colorado repealed and replaced its AI Act before it ever took effect; the replacement is a transparency law effective January 1, 2027. The EEOC pulled its own AI technical assistance documents in January 2025, so there is no federal playbook to follow. The state rules are the operative ones.
The credit report angle
If you’re using a credit report (not just a criminal background check), additional rules apply. Several states (California, Connecticut, Hawaii, Illinois, Maryland, Nevada, Oregon, Vermont, Washington, and others) restrict the use of credit reports in employment decisions to specific positions where credit history is materially related to the role. New York City has its own ordinance.
If you’re running credit reports as part of your background check process, audit which positions you’re running them for and confirm each position falls within the permitted categories under your state’s law.
The common mistakes
I see these regularly:
- Bundled disclosure forms. The disclosure is part of the application packet, not a stand-alone document. FCRA violation.
- No pre-adverse action notice. The operator decides not to hire based on the report, sends the rejection email, and never sent the pre-adverse notice with the report and Summary of Rights. FCRA violation.
- Same-day adverse action. The operator sends the pre-adverse action notice and the adverse action notice on the same day, without giving the candidate time to respond. FCRA violation.
- Categorical exclusion policies. The application or the policy says “no convictions” or “no felonies.” Disparate-impact and state-law issues.
Asking on the application in a ban-the-box jurisdiction. The application has a “have you ever been convicted of a crime” question, in a state or city that prohibits the question on the initial application.
Using arrests. The hiring decision relies on an arrest record, in a jurisdiction that prohibits arrest-based decisions.
Not doing the individualized assessment. The decision is “they have a felony, we don’t hire felons” without consideration of the specific offense, the time elapsed, the relationship to the job, or the candidate’s response.
What this looks like in your manual
Your handbook should reference your background check process, but the actual disclosure and authorization documents are typically separate. The handbook should:
State that background checks are part of the hiring process where applicable. Reference the FCRA disclosure and authorization process. Reference your individualized-assessment process for any adverse decision based on criminal history. Reference the ban-the-box compliance for your jurisdictions.
We include this in the custom employee manual that comes with every AccompliCenter HR subscription, with state-tailored language for the ban-the-box jurisdictions. We don’t draft the actual disclosure and authorization forms (those are typically provided by your background check vendor), but we make sure your handbook references the process correctly. Plans start at $139 a month.
If you’ve been running background checks without a stand-alone disclosure form, this is one of the higher-priority audits a small employer can do. Class actions in this space have hit small employers as well as large, and the fix is straightforward. Get the disclosure form right. Run the notice process. Document the individualized assessment.
This article is general information, not legal advice. For legal advice about your situation, consult a qualified attorney.
Back to the list of articles
Job Descriptions That Protect You: The ADA-Aware Way to Write Them
The short version
- The job description defines essential functions for ADA analysis, supports your FLSA exemption, and anchors any performance termination.
- Separate essential functions from marginal ones. Marginal functions can be reassigned as an accommodation; essential functions cannot.
- Pay ranges are now required in job postings in fourteen states and the District of Columbia.
A single wage claim or agency charge can cost more than several years of an HR subscription. Plans start at $139 a month. Call (562) 444-8076, email service@accomplicenter.com, or come by our store at 3217 Carson St in Lakewood to sign up.
Most small-employer job descriptions are useless. Three sentences in a job posting, copied into a Word file, never updated, never referenced. The operator wrote it once when they were hiring and hasn’t looked at it since. The employee may never have seen the version that’s in the file.
A useful job description does work. It defines what “essential functions” mean if the employee ever requests an ADA accommodation. It supports your FLSA exemption analysis. It frames every performance conversation that follows. It anchors any termination decision based on performance gaps. It also helps the manager actually manage the role, which is the day-to-day function the document is supposed to serve.
The four jobs the document does
A job description does four jobs.
- It defines essential functions. When an employee requests an accommodation under the ADA, the analysis turns on whether they can perform the essential functions of the position with reasonable accommodation. Essential functions are determined by what the job description says they are, by what the employee actually does day to day, and by what the employer’s judgment is about which functions are essential. The written job description is the most concrete evidence in this analysis.
- It supports FLSA exemption analysis. Whether an employee is properly classified as exempt depends on their primary duty and whether that duty fits one of the exempt categories. The job description is where the primary duty is laid out. If the document says the primary duty is “managing the production team,” that supports executive exemption. If it says “performing routine inventory tasks,” it doesn’t.
- It frames performance evaluation. Performance is measured against what the role is supposed to be. The job description is the document that defines what the role is supposed to be. Performance reviews that reference the job description are stronger than performance reviews that don’t, because they tie evaluation to a written standard rather than to the manager’s subjective sense of the role.
- It anchors termination decisions for performance. When an employee is terminated for performance issues, the file needs to show the gap between what was expected (the job description) and what was delivered (documented performance). A vague or missing job description makes this harder.
What a useful job description includes
A useful job description has the following sections.
Position title. The actual title used internally and externally.
Reports to. The position the role reports to, by title.
- Position summary. Two or three sentences describing the overall purpose of the role.
- Essential functions. A list, typically five to ten items, of the functions the role performs that are essential. Each function should be specific, action-oriented, and measurable. “Manages a team of four production employees” is specific. “Helps with team management” is not.
- Marginal functions. Functions the role performs that are not essential. Important to distinguish because marginal functions can be reassigned as part of an ADA accommodation; essential functions can’t be reassigned (the employee has to be able to perform them).
- Required qualifications. Education, experience, licenses, certifications, physical abilities, schedule requirements. Each qualification has to be genuinely required for the job, not aspirational.
- Preferred qualifications. Things that would be nice to have but aren’t required. Useful for hiring but kept distinct from required qualifications because the latter sets the bar for the role.
- Physical demands. Specific to roles where physical capability matters. Lifting requirements, standing, sitting, climbing, repetitive motion, etc. This section gets attention in ADA accommodation analysis, so be specific and accurate.
- Work environment. Where the work is performed. Office, factory floor, customer site, vehicle, outdoor. Includes any environmental factors (noise, temperature, exposure to chemicals, etc.) that might affect accommodation analysis.
- Schedule. Days, hours, on-call requirements, travel expectations.
- FLSA classification. Exempt or non-exempt. State equivalent if applicable.
- Compensation range. Required in job postings in fourteen states and the District of Columbia, with thresholds that vary: California at 15 or more employees, Colorado, Connecticut, Hawaii at 50, Illinois at 15, Maryland, Massachusetts at 25, Minnesota at 30, Nevada, New Jersey at 10, New York at 4, Rhode Island, Vermont at 5, and Washington at 15. Several Ohio cities have their own rules, and Delaware joins in 2027. Check your state before you post.
The “essential function” question
The single most important section of a job description is the essential functions list. The list determines a lot of downstream legal analysis.
What makes a function essential. The EEOC and most state regulations identify several factors:
The job exists primarily to perform that function. A limited number of employees are available to perform the function (so reassignment isn’t easy). The function is highly specialized and the employee was hired specifically because of expertise in that function. The amount of time spent on the function. The consequences of not performing the function. The terms of any collective bargaining agreement. The actual experience of past or current employees in the position.
A job description that lists every conceivable task a person might do is not a job description. It’s a list. The exercise is to identify which tasks are essential and document them as such, with specifics.
How to write the functions
Each essential function should be:
- Specific. Not “manages people” but “supervises a team of four to six production employees, including hiring recommendations, performance evaluation, and discipline.”
- Action-oriented. Verbs, not adjectives. Not “responsible for inventory” but “maintains inventory records, conducts monthly counts, and reorders supplies based on minimum stock levels.”
- Measurable where possible. Not “produces good work” but “completes 15 to 20 customer orders per day to quality standards.”
- Tied to the job, not the person. Don’t write the description around the current person in the role. Write it around what the role requires regardless of who fills it.
The ADA accommodation connection
When an employee requests an ADA accommodation, the conversation often comes down to whether they can perform essential functions with reasonable accommodation.
If the job description is clear about essential functions, the conversation is straightforward. The employee needs to be able to perform these specific functions. The accommodation question is whether some adjustment lets them do so.
If the job description is vague or non-existent, the conversation becomes a debate about what the job actually requires, which the employee can argue is more flexible than the manager believes. The lack of a written job description weakens the employer’s position.
The same logic applies to fitness-for-duty after an injury or leave. The treating physician needs to know what functions the employee has to perform. Without a clear job description with specific physical demands, the physician is guessing, and you’re not getting a useful certification.
The FLSA exemption connection
For salaried-exempt employees, the duties test requires that the employee’s primary duty fit one of the exempt categories. Primary duty depends on what the employee actually does, which the job description should reflect.
A job description that says the role’s primary duty is “managing the operations team, including supervision of staff, scheduling, performance evaluation, and resource allocation” supports executive exemption. A job description that says the role “performs all production tasks alongside the team and assists with scheduling when needed” does not, even if the title is “Operations Manager.”
When the DOL or a plaintiff’s lawyer challenges a classification, the job description is the first document they look at. If it doesn’t support the classification, the analysis usually doesn’t go in the employer’s favor.
What a stale or missing job description does
A job description that hasn’t been updated in several years is often wrong. The role has evolved. New responsibilities have been added. Old responsibilities have been dropped. The written document doesn’t match what the person actually does.
This creates problems in several scenarios.
In an ADA accommodation request, the discrepancy between the written document and the actual role gives the employee room to argue that essential functions are different from what the written document says.
In an FLSA challenge, the discrepancy creates evidence that the employer wasn’t paying close attention to whether the classification was supported by the actual duties.
In a performance termination, the discrepancy means the standard the employee was being measured against doesn’t match the standard documented in the file.
In hiring, the discrepancy means new candidates are being evaluated against the wrong description.
The fix is to review job descriptions annually, at the same time you do your handbook review, and update them when the role has materially changed.
What this looks like in your manual
Your handbook should reference job descriptions as the document supporting essential functions, FLSA classification, and performance evaluation. The handbook itself doesn’t include the job descriptions; they live separately, organized by position.
The handbook’s discipline section should reference the job description as the standard against which performance is measured. The accommodation section should reference job descriptions as the source for essential functions in the interactive process. The FLSA section should reference job descriptions as the basis for exemption analysis.
We tie all of this together in the custom employee manual that comes with every AccompliCenter HR subscription. We don’t write the individual job descriptions for you, but we structure the handbook to reference them properly and we provide a job description template that follows the framework above. Plans start at $139 a month.
If you have employees and you don’t have job descriptions, or your job descriptions haven’t been updated in three years, this is one of the higher-leverage projects a small employer can do. The document is short. The work to write it well is real, but bounded. The protection it provides is across the lifecycle of the employment relationship.
This article is general information, not legal advice. For legal advice about your situation, consult a qualified attorney.
Back to the list of articles
Personality Assessments for Hiring: When They Earn Their Keep (and When They’re Snake Oil)
The short version
- A selection assessment has to be job-related and backed by validation evidence. Most marketed personality tests are neither.
- A test designed to reveal a mental impairment is a medical examination under the ADA and cannot be given before an offer.
- California’s automated-decision regulations, effective October 1, 2025, reach personality tests, games and reaction-time challenges.
These rules change every year, and California adds its own. A subscription gives you a California-certified HR professional to check your answer before you act. Call (562) 444-8076, email service@accomplicenter.com, or come by our store at 3217 Carson St in Lakewood to sign up.
A bad hire costs a small business between 30 and 50 percent of the employee’s annual salary, by most credible estimates. For a $60,000 hire, that’s $18,000 to $30,000 lost. For a $100,000 manager, it’s a number that hurts.
The assessment industry knows this and has built itself around the promise of de-risking the decision. Personality tests, cultural fit assessments, “behavioral profiles,” and similar products are sold to employers as ways to predict who will perform and who won’t. Most of these products are junk. A few are validated science. The difference matters, and most operators don’t know how to tell.
What makes an assessment defensible
The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission and federal regulations under the Uniform Guidelines on Employee Selection Procedures don’t prohibit personality assessments in hiring. They require that any selection procedure used for employment decisions be job-related and consistent with business necessity, and that it not have an unjustified disparate impact on protected groups.
Translated for an operator: if you’re going to use an assessment to make a hiring decision, the assessment has to actually predict performance on the job, the prediction has to be backed by validation evidence, and the assessment has to be administered and interpreted by someone qualified to do so.
Most hiring personality tests fail the first part of that test. They were never built to predict job performance. They were built to be entertaining, or to generate a marketing report for the candidate, or to fit a vendor’s pricing model. They produce results, but the results don’t correlate with how the person will actually perform.
The minority of assessments that do predict job performance share a few characteristics:
- They were built specifically for occupational use. Not adapted from a clinical instrument, not based on a personality theory designed for therapy, not built for self-help. Built from the ground up for hiring decisions or workplace performance prediction.
- They have published validation studies. The vendor can show you peer-reviewed research demonstrating that the instrument correlates with relevant job-performance criteria. The studies should be in mainstream industrial-organizational psychology journals, not vendor-published white papers.
- They have published reliability data. Reliability is a measure of how consistent the test is. Bad tests give different results to the same person on different days. Good tests are stable.
They have demonstrated low adverse impact across protected groups, or the validation evidence justifies any impact that exists. The Uniform Guidelines requirements aren’t optional, and the better instruments have built their validation around demonstrating defensibility.
The assessments that meet these criteria are a small set. The CPI 260 is one of them. The Hogan suite is another. The 16PF is another. There are a few others. Most of what gets marketed as “personality assessment for hiring” doesn’t make this list.
When to use one
Assessments aren’t appropriate for every hire. The cost of administration and interpretation, the time it adds to the process, and the candidate experience implications all matter. The math works for some hires and not others.
The hires where assessments earn their keep:
- Leadership roles. A manager who sets the tone for a team has outsized impact. The CPI 260 in particular was developed and validated against managerial performance, and the data on selection assessments at this level is robust. A miscast manager costs you the team they’re managing, not just their own seat.
- Key technical hires. A senior engineer, a head of operations, a finance lead at a small company. Roles where the wrong person sets you back twelve months and the right person sets you ahead twelve months.
- Partner-level decisions. If you’re hiring someone who will own equity, who will speak for the company externally, who will represent the brand, the cost of a wrong hire goes well beyond their salary. An assessment is appropriate.
- Difficult-to-evaluate roles. Some roles are hard to interview for because the work itself is hard to simulate or describe. Sales is a common example. Customer-facing roles in regulated industries. Specialized professional roles. When the interview alone isn’t giving you a reliable read, an assessment can fill the gap.
The hires where assessments aren’t worth it:
- Hourly entry-level roles. A dishwasher hire, a cashier hire, a receiving clerk hire. The cost of the assessment exceeds the cost of a wrong hire at this level, and the validation data is thinner for these roles.
- Short-tenure roles. Seasonal hires, temporary roles, project-specific hires. The assessment cost is amortized over too short a tenure to make sense.
- Roles where the existing process works. If you have a hiring process that’s giving you reliable results, don’t add steps for the sake of adding steps. Save the assessment for the hires where you’re not getting reliable signal.
How to use one well
If you decide an assessment is appropriate for a hire, a few things matter.
- The job description has to be done first. Assessments are interpreted against the requirements of the position. Without a clear definition of essential functions and the competencies the role requires, the assessment results don’t connect to anything actionable. The job description grounds the interpretation.
- The assessment can’t be the whole decision. EEOC guidance is clear that selection decisions should rest on multiple sources of evidence. The assessment is one input. The interview is another. The reference checks are another. The candidate’s track record is another. Treating the assessment as the deciding factor is both legally risky and bad practice.
- The administration has to be qualified. This is where most operators get into trouble. They buy the assessment, give it to the candidate, get the results, and try to interpret them. The interpretation requires training. The patterns in the data, the relationships between the scales, the boundary cases, the way the results inform interview questions, all of it requires someone who has been trained on the specific instrument and has experience reading the output.
- The decision has to be consistent. If you use an assessment for the leadership role, you should use it for every leadership role at that level. Inconsistent application is one of the surest ways to invite a disparate-impact challenge. Set a clear policy for which roles get assessed and apply it.
The two legal lines
Two legal lines matter here. The first is the ADA’s bar on pre-offer medical examinations. A personality instrument crosses that line when it was designed to reveal a mental impairment, regardless of how you score it or what you use it for: the Seventh Circuit held exactly that about the MMPI in Karraker v. Rent-A-Center. The CPI 260 sits on the safe side because it is a normal-range occupational instrument rather than a clinical one, but the safe practice is the same for any tool. Use normal-range, job-related instruments, avoid items that probe mental health symptoms, and keep anything clinically derived until after the offer. The second line is new. California’s Civil Rights Department regulations, effective October 1, 2025, treat an automated tool that analyzes physical or mental traits, including personality tests, games, puzzles and reaction-time challenges, as a potential unlawful pre-offer inquiry under FEHA, and require four years of records on the system and its results. Illinois barred AI-driven employment discrimination effective January 1, 2026. The EEOC withdrew its own AI technical assistance in January 2025, so there is no federal guidance to point to. If your assessment is scored or interpreted by an algorithm rather than a trained human, the state rules are what you answer to.
Where I come in
The CPI 260 is the assessment I administer most often for clients. It was developed at the University of California Berkeley, has more than fifty years of validation research behind it, and was built specifically for occupational and managerial assessment. It’s not a quick screen. It’s a 260-item instrument that takes the candidate about 30 minutes and produces an interpretation report covering 26 personality dimensions, organized around four broader themes that map directly to managerial performance.
I’m John Hamilton. I have an MS in HR Management. My undergraduate degree is in psychology with a concentration in neurobiology, from California Polytechnic State University. I hold the PHRca and PHR certifications from HR Certification Institute. I administer the CPI 260 for clients who are about to make a hire that matters more than the average hire, and I write the interpretation in language that’s actionable for the hiring decision rather than clinical.
If you’re hiring someone whose miscast costs you real money, call us at (562) 444-8076 or email service@accomplicenter.com. A manager, a key technical hire, a partner, a leadership-track employee. We’ll talk about the role, the candidate pool, and whether the CPI 260 is the right call. Most of the time it is. When it isn’t, I’ll tell you that and we’ll talk about a different approach.
The cost of the assessment, including administration and interpretation, is a fraction of the cost of a wrong hire. The math has favored doing this for decades.
This article is general information, not legal advice. For legal advice about your situation, consult a qualified attorney.
Back to the list of articles
To subscribe, call us at (562) 444-8076, stop by our store at 3217 Carson St in Lakewood, or email service@accomplicenter.com.
See AccompliCenter HR plans →