HR Consulting

blogheader

When You Get Sued, Your Handbook Is Your Best Witness

I am not an attorney. This article is general information based on my experience as an HR professional, and it is not legal advice. For legal advice about your situation, consult a qualified attorney.

The short version

  • The same statute produces different outcomes in front of different judges, juries, arbitrators and agency investigators.
  • A handbook is the written record of what you committed to before the dispute existed, and it does not get cross-examined.
  • Every agency asks for your written policies first. Not having them lengthens the investigation and shifts the investigator’s starting assumption.

You do not have to work through these rules alone. Our HR subscribers email or call us whenever a question comes up, and plans start at $139 a month. Call (562) 444-8076, email service@accomplicenter.com, or come by our store at 3217 Carson St in Lakewood to sign up.

A statute on the books does not mean the same thing on Tuesday in San Diego that it means on Wednesday in Sacramento.

The law on the books is one input. The other inputs are the judge, the jury, the jurisdiction, the arbitrator, the agency investigator, the opposing lawyer, and the person who decided to file the claim. Each of them has a worldview, a bad day or a good day, an industry they’ve worked with before or haven’t, and a set of priors about employers and employees that you have no control over.

The same fact pattern in front of a 35-year-old plaintiff-side judge in San Francisco is a different case than in front of a 65-year-old judge with a small-business background in Bakersfield. Same statute. Same conduct. Different conclusion.

The rules are the rules, and the variability around them is enormous. Once you’re in the dispute, the variability is what decides whether you win or lose.

What the handbook does in this picture

You can’t pick your judge. You can’t pick your jury. You can’t pick the agency investigator who shows up at the door, and you can’t pick whether the dispute lands in a courtroom, an arbitration, or a hearing room at the Department of Labor.

What you can do is narrow the variability.

A handbook is the record of what you intended to do as an employer. It’s what you wrote down before the dispute happened. It says you committed to a complaint procedure. It says you committed to an accommodation process. It says you committed to progressive discipline. It says, most importantly, that you committed to applying these things consistently across employees.

When the dispute lands in front of a judge or a jury or an arbitrator, the handbook walks in with you. It doesn’t get rattled on cross-examination. It doesn’t forget what you said two years ago. It doesn’t change its story. It says exactly what it said the day you handed it to the employee, signed and acknowledged, in writing.

This is what I mean when I say the handbook is your best witness. Every other witness, including you, is going to be cross-examined. The handbook gets entered into evidence and stays exactly what it is.

Two reasons you need one

You need a handbook for two reasons. The first is the reason most owners think about. It guides you and your team while you’re running the business. It tells your managers how to handle a complaint. It tells your employees how to request time off. It tells everyone how at-will employment works in your shop. The day-to-day function of the handbook is real and it matters.

The second reason is the one most owners don’t think about until it’s too late. The handbook is what you show the judge, jury, jurisdiction, or agency investigator to demonstrate what you intended to do. It narrows the variability of the legal system in your favor. It moves you from “the owner says he handled it this way” to “here is the written policy the owner committed to in advance, here is the signed acknowledgment from the employee, and here is the documented record of how it was applied.”

That second reason is why a handbook with a complaint procedure beats a handbook without one. It’s why a handbook with a written accommodation process beats a handbook that punts on accommodations. It’s why a handbook that includes progressive discipline beats one that says “the company may discipline employees for any reason.” Specifics narrow variability. Vagueness widens it.

What this looks like in practice

A client of mine, a small nonprofit with fewer than a hundred employees, got a demand letter from a plaintiff’s firm claiming harassment, retaliation, and constructive discharge. The former employee had resigned without using a single one of the complaint channels the handbook published: supervisor, HR, or the hotline. Each channel was covered by a signed acknowledgment, including a standalone anti-harassment acknowledgment.

When defense counsel opened the file, the defense was already sitting in it. Signed acknowledgments proving she knew exactly how to complain and never did, and accommodation paperwork that contradicted the demand letter point by point, all of it created before anyone knew there would be a claim. Without that handbook, the same facts would have been one person’s word against a demand letter.

The reason this matters more for small employers than for large ones is the same reason small employers face higher risk overall. Big companies have the resources to build a defense even when their documentation is bad. They have lawyers, witnesses, and budget. Small employers don’t. If your handbook isn’t doing the work for you, nothing is.

What about arbitration

A lot of small employers have arbitration clauses in their offer letters, or they’re considering them. The thinking is that arbitration is cheaper and faster than court, which is mostly true, and that the variability problem goes away in arbitration, which is mostly false.

Arbitrators are people too. They have priors. They’ve handled prior cases. Some of them lean toward employees, some lean toward employers, and which arbitrator you draw depends on a process you don’t fully control. Arbitration narrows some kinds of variability and not others.

The handbook does the same thing in arbitration that it does in court. It’s the written record of what you intended to do. The arbitrator reads the handbook. The arbitrator weighs the handbook. The handbook doesn’t get rattled on cross-examination in arbitration any more than it does in front of a jury.

What about the EEOC, DLSE, or DOL

State and federal agencies handle employment claims before they ever reach a courtroom. The EEOC, your state’s equivalent, the federal Department of Labor, your state’s labor commissioner, and any number of other agencies will investigate complaints, take statements, demand records, and ultimately decide whether the claim has merit.

In every one of these processes, the agency investigator is going to ask for your written policies. If you have them, the investigation moves faster and more often in your favor. If you don’t, the investigation gets longer and the investigator’s prior shifts. Not because the investigator is biased, but because the absence of a written policy is itself a fact that informs the investigation.

The handbook isn’t just a courtroom witness. It’s the document that talks to every agency that ever asks about your business.

The cost of not having one

I’ve seen owners save the cost of a handbook for years and then spend ten times that amount in a single dispute that the handbook would have prevented or shortened. I’ve seen owners write their own from a template that didn’t reflect their state’s law and discover the gap during a deposition. I’ve seen owners decide they didn’t need one and then sit in a hearing room explaining why their managers all had different stories about how complaints were handled.

The handbook is one of the cheapest pieces of insurance you’ll ever buy for the business. It costs less than an hour with most employment lawyers. It pays for itself the first time something goes wrong, and it earns its keep every day before that by giving your team a clear understanding of how the place runs.

What we offer

Every AccompliCenter HR subscription includes a custom employee manual, because we got tired of watching small employers walk into disputes without one. We tailor the manual to your state, your headcount, and your industry. The required disclosures are in. The at-will language is done right. The complaint procedure works. The accommodation process is laid out for your managers in language they’ll actually use.

Plans start at $139 a month, and every plan also includes email consultation and our HR hotline.

To subscribe, call us at (562) 444-8076, stop by our store at 3217 Carson St in Lakewood, or email service@accomplicenter.com.

See AccompliCenter HR plans →

Store Hours

Today
  • Tue
    Nov 17

    8:30AM
    —
    6:00PM
  • Wed
    Nov 18

    8:30AM
    —
    6:00PM
  • Thu
    Nov 19

    8:30AM
    —
    6:00PM
  • Fri
    Nov 20

    8:30AM
    —
    6:00PM
  • Sat
    Nov 21

    9:00AM
    —
    4:00PM
  • Sun
    Nov 22

    10:00AM
    —
    3:00PM
  • Mon
    Nov 23

    8:30AM
    —
    6:00PM