HR Consulting

blogheader

Unemployment Claims: When to Contest and When to Let It Go

I am not an attorney. This article is general information based on my experience as an HR professional, and it is not legal advice. For legal advice about your situation, consult a qualified attorney.

The short version

  • Contest a claim only when the facts meet your state’s misconduct standard and you have the documentation. Both, or neither.
  • Most performance terminations do not rise to misconduct, so contesting them wastes time and can produce findings used against you later.
  • California employers also lost 1.2 percent of the FUTA credit for tax year 2025, an extra $84 per employee.

Employment law is complicated, and one mistake can cost far more than a year of help. An AccompliCenter HR subscription starts at $139 a month. Call (562) 444-8076, email service@accomplicenter.com, or come by our store at 3217 Carson St in Lakewood to sign up.

You just terminated an employee. A few weeks later, you receive a notice from the state unemployment agency. The employee has filed for benefits. You have a deadline (typically 10 to 14 days) to respond. The form asks whether you want to contest the claim.

What you do here matters. Contest the wrong claims and you waste time, lose anyway, and possibly invite scrutiny of your termination practices. Concede the wrong claims and your unemployment insurance rate goes up over time, which compounds into real money.

How unemployment works for employers

Unemployment insurance is a state-by-state program funded by employer payroll taxes. The federal floor is set by FUTA (Federal Unemployment Tax Act); states administer their own programs with their own rules.

Your unemployment insurance rate is “experience-rated.” This means your rate is set partly based on the unemployment claims paid out to your former employees. More claims, higher rate. Fewer claims, lower rate. The exact rate calculation varies by state, but the principle is universal: claims affect your rate.

Within the rate calculation, the state distinguishes between charges that are “non-charged” (the state pays the benefit but doesn’t charge it against your account) and “charged” (the benefit is charged to your account). The distinction depends on why the employee separated and whether you contested the claim successfully.

In general:

A successful contest of misconduct or voluntary quit results in the claim being non-charged.

A claim that’s paid because the separation was a layoff, a termination without cause, or a quit with good cause is charged.

The math is real but moves slowly. A single claim might shift your rate by a fraction of a percent, which over time compounds. For a small employer with a small claim history, individual claims matter more than for a large employer where any single claim is a small fraction of total claim volume.

One number makes this concrete for California employers. California has owed the federal government money for unemployment benefits since 2020, and the penalty comes out of the FUTA credit. For tax year 2025, paid with the Form 940 due January 31, 2026, California employers lost 1.2 percent of the credit: a net federal rate of 1.8 percent instead of 0.6 percent, or an extra $84 per employee. The Department of Labor sets the 2026 figure in November 2026, and it rises if the loan is still outstanding. That sits on top of whatever your state experience rating does.

When to contest

Contest a claim when both of the following are true:

The facts support a successful contest. The standard varies by state, but the general categories that lead to successful contests are misconduct (a serious violation of company policy or rule), voluntary resignation without good cause attributable to the employer, or refusal of suitable work.

You have documentation supporting your position. Memory and verbal accounts don’t carry weight in unemployment hearings. Written warnings, signed acknowledgments, performance documentation, witness statements, time records. The contemporaneous file is what carries the day.

The intersection of these two is where contesting makes sense. If both are present, contest. If either is missing, let it go.

When to let it go

Let the claim go when any of the following is true:

The separation was a layoff or position elimination. Not the employee’s fault. The unemployment program exists for exactly this situation. Contesting is a waste of time.

The performance issues were real but not at the level of misconduct. Most performance terminations don’t rise to misconduct under unemployment standards. The employee was underperforming, you let them go, but they weren’t engaged in willful misconduct or gross neglect. The benefit will likely be paid regardless of whether you contest.

The documentation isn’t there. Even if the facts support a contest, you can’t win without documentation. Trying invites a hearing where you’ll lose, and the loss can produce findings that get used against you in any subsequent litigation by the same employee.

The employee resigned with what they’ll claim was good cause. Constructive discharge cases (where the employee resigns because conditions made staying intolerable) are usually losers from the employer’s perspective. The employee will argue the conditions were intolerable. The hearing officer will likely give them benefit of the doubt unless your documentation is unusually strong.

The amount at stake is small relative to the cost of contesting. A short-tenure employee with a low wage may produce a claim that’s small enough that contesting (with management time, document assembly, hearing preparation, possibly attorney involvement) costs more than the rate impact of conceding.

How to contest effectively when you do contest

Three steps.

Respond to the initial notice on time, with the relevant facts. The state agency sends an initial determination questionnaire. Answer it completely. Provide the dates, the specifics, the reasons. Attach the relevant documentation (final warning, signed acknowledgment of policy, etc.). The initial response often determines the outcome without a hearing.

Prepare for the hearing if one is scheduled. Many states schedule a hearing if either party requests one, or if the initial determination is appealed. Hearings are typically conducted by phone, last 30 to 60 minutes, and follow rules of evidence loosely. Prepare your witness list, organize your documents, brief the witnesses on what they’ll be asked.

Present the case clearly. Hearing officers handle dozens of these cases a week. They’re not going to dig through a chaotic file. Present a clean, organized account: here’s what the policy was, here’s the employee’s signed acknowledgment, here’s the documented violation, here’s the employee’s response, here’s the termination decision and why.

If you’re uncomfortable representing yourself at the hearing, an HR consultant or attorney can represent the company. The cost varies. For a small claim, it’s often not worth it. For a large claim or one with patterns that affect future cases, it can be.

The misconduct standard

The standard for misconduct varies by state but generally requires more than ordinary unsatisfactory performance. The employee has to have engaged in willful or wanton disregard of the employer’s interests, or gross negligence, or deliberate violation of a known policy or rule. California is representative and strict: the employer has to show a material duty owed to the employer, a substantial breach of that duty, willful or wanton disregard, and a breach that tends to injure the employer’s interests. All four. A discharge that was entirely justified is not automatically misconduct.

Examples that typically meet the standard:

Theft, fraud, or other criminal conduct related to the job. Insubordination (refusal of a direct lawful order). Repeated violations of safety rules. Repeated tardiness or absenteeism after multiple warnings, where the employee was clearly aware of the standard and the consequences. Workplace violence or threats. Significant policy violations (drug use, harassment, etc.) where the policy was known.

Examples that typically don’t meet the standard:

Poor performance over time without specific willful conduct. Single incidents of judgment errors, even when consequential. Personality conflicts with management. Inability to learn the job or keep up with the workload. Failure to meet sales targets or production goals due to factors not entirely within the employee’s control.

The line is fuzzy and varies by state. The general principle: misconduct requires fault on the employee’s part beyond ordinary failure to perform.

The voluntary-quit-with-good-cause issue

When an employee resigns, the question becomes whether they had good cause. Good cause attributable to the employer (intolerable working conditions, unsafe workplace, harassment that the employer didn’t address, material change in compensation or duties) typically results in benefits being paid. Good cause not attributable to the employer (personal reasons, transportation, family situation) typically doesn’t.

This is the area where employers most often get tripped up by what the employee said in their last conversation. If the employee said they were quitting because of “stress” or “I just can’t take it anymore” or “the way [manager] treats me,” the employee will likely frame this as good cause attributable to the employer. The employer’s documentation needs to show otherwise.

What this looks like in your manual

The handbook itself doesn’t directly contest unemployment claims, but several handbook elements support successful contests:

A clear discipline policy that establishes expectations. A documented complaint procedure (so resignation-citing-conditions claims can be checked against whether the employee actually used the procedure). A clear policy against the kinds of conduct that constitute misconduct. Acknowledgment forms that establish employees were aware of policies.

We include all of this in the custom employee manual that comes with every AccompliCenter HR subscription. The handbook gives you the foundation; the day-to-day documentation builds on it. Plans start at $139 a month.

If you’re getting unemployment claims and you’re not sure whether to contest each one, the framework above is the starting point. The math is sometimes counterintuitive: contesting fewer claims, but contesting them well, often produces a better long-term rate outcome than contesting everything reflexively.

To subscribe, call us at (562) 444-8076, stop by our store at 3217 Carson St in Lakewood, or email service@accomplicenter.com.

See AccompliCenter HR plans →

Store Hours

Today
  • Tue
    Nov 17

    8:30AM
    —
    6:00PM
  • Wed
    Nov 18

    8:30AM
    —
    6:00PM
  • Thu
    Nov 19

    8:30AM
    —
    6:00PM
  • Fri
    Nov 20

    8:30AM
    —
    6:00PM
  • Sat
    Nov 21

    9:00AM
    —
    4:00PM
  • Sun
    Nov 22

    10:00AM
    —
    3:00PM
  • Mon
    Nov 23

    8:30AM
    —
    6:00PM