How to Fire an Employee Without Getting Sued
By John Hamilton, MS, PHRca, PHR · Reviewed for legal currency August 2026
I am not an attorney. This article is general information based on my experience as an HR professional, and it is not legal advice. For legal advice about your situation, consult a qualified attorney.
The short version
- Run the proximity test. Any complaint, accommodation request, protected leave or safety report in the last 90 days makes the timing look retaliatory.
- Ames v. Ohio Department of Youth Services removed the extra hurdle for majority-group plaintiffs in 2025, so the consistency check now runs in every direction.
- Pair any severance with a properly drafted release, and keep confidentiality and non-disparagement clauses narrow.
You do not have to work through these rules alone. Our HR subscribers email or call us whenever a question comes up, and plans start at $139 a month. Call (562) 444-8076, email service@accomplicenter.com, or come by our store at 3217 Carson St in Lakewood to sign up.
You can fire any employee, at any time, for any lawful reason, in 49 of 50 states. That’s the theory of at-will employment. In practice, whether the reason was lawful is exactly the question that ends up in front of a jury, an arbitrator, or an agency investigator after the firing.
The Termination Checklist (post #24) covers the procedural steps. The legal traps underneath them are what turn an otherwise ordinary termination into a wrongful-termination claim.
The categories of unlawful termination
Most wrongful-termination claims fall into one of these categories. Knowing them helps you spot when a planned termination might trigger one.
- Discrimination based on protected class. You can’t fire someone because of their race, color, religion, sex (including pregnancy, sexual orientation, and gender identity), national origin, age (40+ federally; some states protect younger), disability, genetic information, or any other category your state protects. The discrimination doesn’t have to be intentional or stated. A firing that has a disparate impact on a protected class can be challenged even when the stated reason is neutral.
- Retaliation for protected activity. You can’t fire someone because they filed a complaint, supported someone else’s complaint, requested an accommodation, took protected leave, refused to do something they reasonably believed was unlawful, raised a safety concern, or exercised any other statutorily protected right. Retaliation claims are the fastest-growing category of employment claims at the federal and state agencies, and they’re often easier to win for the employee than discrimination claims because the timing of the firing tells the story.
- Public-policy violation. You can’t fire someone for a reason that violates public policy. The categories vary by state, but typically include filing a workers’ compensation claim, refusing to commit a crime, exercising civic duties (jury duty, voting, military service), and reporting illegal activity to authorities.
- FMLA interference or retaliation. If FMLA applies to you and your employee was using it or was eligible to use it, you can’t fire them in connection with the leave.
- ADA or state-disability-law issues. Termination of an employee with a disability, an employee who recently requested accommodation, or an employee on disability leave can implicate the ADA and state-disability-law analogs.
- Implied contract. If your offer letter, your handbook, or your manager’s verbal promises created an implied contract (we covered the five phrases that do this in post #8 on at-will employment), termination outside the implied terms is breach of contract.
- Wage and hour violations connected to termination. If the termination is preceded or followed by improper handling of final pay, accrued PTO, or commissions owed, the wage claim attaches to the termination as a separate cause of action.
The proximity test
The single most important pre-termination question is the proximity test. Look at the employee’s history in the past 90 days, with extra weight on the past 30 days. Did any of the following happen:
The employee filed a complaint (about anything: harassment, discrimination, safety, wages, working conditions, anything). The employee supported someone else’s complaint, was named as a witness, or participated in an investigation. The employee requested an accommodation under the ADA, the PWFA, or a religious accommodation. The employee took protected leave (FMLA, state family leave, pregnancy leave, military, jury, etc.). The employee filed a workers’ compensation claim. The employee raised a workplace safety concern. The employee refused to do something on grounds that they thought it was unlawful.
If any of these happened in the past 90 days, the timing of a termination is going to look retaliatory. You can still terminate, but the file needs to be much stronger. Specifically:
The reason for termination must be documented and clear. The reason must be tied to behavior or performance that pre-dates the protected activity, or to behavior that’s so serious it stands on its own (a clear policy violation, a safety incident, a customer complaint, etc.). The decision-maker should be able to show, in writing, that the decision was made independent of the protected activity. Other employees with similar issues should have been treated similarly.
If you can’t satisfy these on a proximity-test termination, talk to a lawyer before pulling the trigger. The cost of a 30-minute call with employment counsel is small. The cost of a retaliation claim is large.
The disparate-treatment check
Pull a list of every employee terminated in the past 18 to 24 months, along with the reason. Compare the protected-class status of the terminated employees to the protected-class status of the remaining workforce. If terminations are disproportionately concentrated in one or more protected classes, you have an exposure that exists independent of the specific termination you’re considering.
The same exercise can be done at the discipline level (formal warnings, performance improvement plans, suspensions). If discipline is being administered disproportionately to a protected class, the termination at the end of that discipline path inherits the same exposure.
The fix isn’t to never terminate employees in protected classes. The fix is to make sure the discipline and termination decisions are being made consistently across employees, regardless of class. That means the same conduct gets the same response, the same performance gets the same review, the same standards apply to everyone.
Two Supreme Court decisions changed the arithmetic here since 2024. In Ames v. Ohio Department of Youth Services, decided June 5, 2025, the Court held unanimously that a majority-group plaintiff no longer has to show “background circumstances” to get a discrimination claim past the starting line. Five circuits had required it. A white employee, a male employee, a non-disabled employee now clears the same bar as anyone else, which means the consistency check runs in every direction and not just the one you were watching. And in Muldrow v. City of St. Louis, decided in April 2024, the Court held that a discriminatory transfer needs only “some harm” to a term or condition of employment, not significant harm. Lateral moves, shift changes and performance improvement plans carry more exposure than they used to. Retaliation claims keep the older, higher standard.
The performance-issue trap
Performance-issue terminations are the largest single category of small-employer terminations and the most common source of wrongful-termination claims. The trap is that the operator usually has a real performance issue, but the documentation doesn’t support it, and the absence of documentation makes the termination look like pretext for something else.
The pattern I see most often is this. The employee has been a problem for months. The owner has talked to them about it informally. There’s no written record of the conversations. Eventually the owner decides enough is enough and terminates. The employee files a claim. The owner’s defense is “their performance was bad.” The employee’s response is “no it wasn’t, my reviews were fine, no one ever told me there was a problem.” The case goes to a jury, and the jury has to choose between the owner’s word and the employee’s word, with no contemporaneous documentation supporting either.
The owner often wins on the merits, but the cost of getting there can be tens of thousands of dollars. And sometimes the jury chooses the employee.
The fix is documentation, contemporaneous, in writing, throughout the employment. Performance reviews on a regular cadence, with specific examples and specific expectations going forward. Documented conversations when problems arise. A performance improvement plan with measurable goals when issues persist. A paper trail that supports the eventual termination if it comes to that.
We wrote a separate post on documenting performance problems (#25). The short version: write things down, in real time, with specifics, against the standards in the job description.
The “for cause” trap
Some operators want to fire employees “for cause” because they think it sounds stronger or it justifies denying severance or unemployment benefits.
Two problems. First, in an at-will state with at-will language, you don’t need cause. The cause framing is a holdover from contract employment that doesn’t serve the at-will posture. Second, claiming cause invites the employee to challenge whether the cause was met, which turns the case into a debate about the merits of your reason rather than a debate about whether you had a legal right to terminate.
Better approach: terminate at-will, document the reasons in the file, don’t make claims about “cause” you don’t need to make. The unemployment determination is separate (and is decided by the state agency based on whether the conduct meets the state’s misconduct standard, regardless of what you call it).
What about severance
Severance is a tool that’s underused by small employers. A few weeks of pay in exchange for a written release of claims is often the cheapest way to close out a termination cleanly. The math works whenever the cost of severance is less than the cost of defending a claim, even a meritless one.
A severance offer should always be paired with a written release. The release should cover all federal, state, and local employment claims (including ADA, ADEA, Title VII, FMLA, FLSA, state equivalents). Some special rules apply:
For employees age 40 and over, the federal Older Workers Benefit Protection Act requires specific language giving the employee 21 days to consider the release (45 days in a group termination) and 7 days to revoke after signing.
State-specific releases sometimes require additional language. California’s release should include a Civil Code section 1542 waiver. Other states have similar specifics.
A release without the right language doesn’t release. Get the document right.
One more drafting trap. Broad confidentiality and non-disparagement clauses in severance agreements can violate the National Labor Relations Act, and under the Board’s McLaren Macomb decision merely offering them is a violation. The rule reaches non-supervisory employees whether or not there is a union. The General Counsel memo explaining how to write narrow clauses was rescinded in February 2025, but the decision itself is still binding Board law. Keep the clauses narrow and carve out protected activity.
The severance amount is negotiable. Common range is one to two weeks of pay per year of service, with a minimum of two to four weeks. The amount that closes the matter depends on the facts of the specific case. For a clean termination of a recent hire, severance may not be necessary. For a termination of a long-tenured employee with potential exposure, severance is often the smart play.
What this looks like in your manual
Your handbook should include:
A clear at-will statement (front and acknowledgment). A discipline policy that uses “may” rather than “will” for any non-mandatory step. A reference to the termination checklist procedure. A complaint procedure that gives employees a path to raise concerns before they become claims.
The handbook is the document that makes a termination defensible when it happens. The complaint procedure is the document that sometimes prevents the termination from being necessary in the first place, by surfacing issues early.
We include all of this in the custom employee manual that comes with every AccompliCenter HR subscription. State-specific, integrated with the discipline framework, and aligned with the proximity-test and disparate-treatment checks above. Plans start at $139 a month.
Firing someone is the highest-stakes employment decision a small employer makes. Done well, it’s clean, defensible, and behind you in a week. Done poorly, it’s the lawsuit that takes two years to resolve and costs more than the employee ever cost you while they were on the payroll.
The decision is yours. The work to make it clean starts before the meeting and continues after.
To subscribe, call us at (562) 444-8076, stop by our store at 3217 Carson St in Lakewood, or email service@accomplicenter.com.
See AccompliCenter HR plans →