The Termination Checklist: 12 Steps Before You Let Someone Go
By John Hamilton, MS, PHRca, PHR · Reviewed for legal currency August 2026
I am not an attorney. This article is general information based on my experience as an HR professional, and it is not legal advice. For legal advice about your situation, consult a qualified attorney.
The short version
- Before the meeting: verify the reason in writing, check the last 90 days for protected activity, check consistency across employees, confirm leave status, and calculate final pay.
- If you are in a day-of-discharge state, the check has to be in your hand when you walk in.
- Document the meeting within 24 hours, and investigate anything the employee raised during it.
If this article raised a question about your own business, that is what our subscription is for. Plans start at $139 a month. Call (562) 444-8076, email service@accomplicenter.com, or come by our store at 3217 Carson St in Lakewood to sign up.
You’ve decided to terminate someone. The decision feels right. You’ve thought about it. You’ve talked to people. You’re ready.
Stop. Before the meeting, work through this list. Each step has a reason behind it, and skipping any one of them is the kind of thing that turns a clean termination into a wrongful-termination claim.
The pre-termination questions (steps 1 through 5)
Step 1. Verify the reason holds up in writing
If you had to explain in court why this employee is being terminated, what would you say. Write it down. Read it. Does it match the documentation in the file. Is it specific. Is it tied to behavior or performance, not personality. Does it apply consistently to similarly situated employees, or are you about to fire this person for something other employees do without consequence.
If the answer to any of these is shaky, fix it before the meeting. Get the documentation in order. If the file doesn’t support the termination, the meeting isn’t ready yet.
Step 2. Check the recent timeline
Look at the last 90 days of the employee’s history. Did they recently file a complaint, request an accommodation, take protected leave, refuse to do something they thought was unlawful, or report a workplace safety concern. If yes, the timing is going to look retaliatory regardless of your actual reasons. You can still terminate, but the file needs to be much stronger to overcome the timing inference, and you should walk through this with your lawyer before the meeting.
Step 3. Check protected-class implications
Is the employee in a protected class. Are similarly situated employees outside that class being treated the same way for the same conduct. If you’ve terminated three employees this year and all three are in the same protected class while non-class employees with similar conduct have not been terminated, you have a disparate-treatment problem. Run this check before the meeting, not after.
Step 4. Confirm the leave status
Is the employee currently on FMLA, state family leave, pregnancy leave, ADA leave-as-accommodation, or workers’ compensation leave. Termination during protected leave isn’t categorically prohibited, but it requires documentation that the termination decision was made independent of the leave and would have happened regardless. Verify before the meeting.
Step 5. Calculate the final pay
What does the employee receive on the day of termination. Regular wages through the termination date. Overtime if applicable. Accrued and unused PTO if your state or your handbook requires payout. Earned commissions or bonuses. Reimbursable expenses. Add it all up. Have payroll prepare a paper check (or a same-day direct deposit if your state allows it). The check needs to be in your hand at the meeting.
If you’re in California, Colorado, Massachusetts, Missouri or Nevada, payment is due on the day of discharge. Montana requires it immediately on a for-cause discharge or layoff unless a written personnel policy extends the deadline. Utah gives you 24 hours. Hawaii allows the next working day where the circumstances genuinely prevent immediate payment. Minnesota requires payment within 24 hours of the employee’s demand. The check has to be ready before you walk into the meeting.
The meeting (steps 6 through 9)
Step 6. Set the meeting deliberately
Pick a quiet time. Pick a private place. Plan to have a second person present (typically an HR designee or another manager) as a witness. The meeting should be short, factual, and respectful. It is not a debate. The decision has been made.
The script is straightforward. State the decision. State the effective date (today, in most cases). State the reason briefly without belaboring it. Hand over the final paycheck. Hand over any separation paperwork. Answer logistical questions about benefits and unemployment. Don’t get drawn into a discussion of the merits of the decision.
Step 7. Provide separation paperwork
State law and federal law require certain paperwork at termination. The list varies by state, but typically includes:
The final paycheck itself. A COBRA notice if you have group health coverage and 20 or more employees, or a state mini-COBRA notice if you have fewer (about forty states have one; California’s is Cal-COBRA, covering employers with 2 to 19 employees). The state unemployment notice (required in many states). A termination letter or notice of separation if your state or your handbook requires one. A return-of-property checklist (laptop, keys, badge, uniforms, vehicle, etc.). Any state-specific forms (California has the Notice to Employee as to Change in Relationship; New York has separation notices; others vary).
Have all of this assembled in a folder before the meeting. Hand it over at the meeting.
Step 8. Recover company property
Keys, badges, laptops, phones, vehicles, uniforms, samples, customer lists, anything else that belongs to the company. Recover it at the meeting if possible. If not possible (a remote employee, equipment at the employee’s home), set a clear plan for return with a written deadline and follow up.
Step 9. Address access immediately
Email access, computer system access, building access, customer-facing accounts. All of it should be terminated by the end of the meeting (preferably before the meeting starts, so the employee can’t access systems after they know they’re being terminated). Coordinate with IT in advance. Same for physical access (badges, keys).
The post-termination follow-up (steps 10 through 12)
Step 10. Document the meeting
Within 24 hours, write a contemporaneous note about what was said in the meeting. Who attended. What you said. What the employee said. Any objections or claims raised. Any commitments made (return of property by a specific date, etc.). This goes in the file.
If the employee said something that should be investigated (a discrimination complaint, a safety concern, a wage claim), the meeting note triggers that investigation. Don’t ignore complaints raised during termination meetings. They’re sometimes genuine, and ignoring them creates additional liability separate from the termination itself.
Step 11. Handle the unemployment claim
The employee will likely file for unemployment. Your decision on whether to contest depends on the facts. If the termination was for misconduct meeting the state’s standard, you can contest and may prevail. If the termination was for performance issues that don’t rise to misconduct, contesting is usually a waste of time. (We wrote a separate post on the contest decision.)
Either way, when the unemployment notice arrives, respond on time. Late responses can default in favor of the employee and sometimes create additional issues.
Step 12. Communicate to the team appropriately
Tell the team the employee is no longer with the company. Don’t elaborate on why. “Effective today, [name] is no longer with the company. We thank them for their service. [New person or coverage plan].” That’s it.
If team members ask why, the answer is “I’m not going to discuss the specifics.” Repeat as needed.
This is also where you address any operational gaps the termination creates. Who covers the work. Who responds to the customers. What happens to in-progress projects. The departure shouldn’t disrupt the business if the planning was done in advance.
What to do if the meeting goes sideways
Most termination meetings go cleanly. Some don’t. The employee gets emotional. The employee starts to argue. The employee threatens to sue. The employee refuses to leave the building.
Stay calm. Don’t argue back. Don’t escalate. Repeat what was said: “The decision has been made. We’re going to need you to gather your things and exit the building.” If the employee won’t leave, you can call building security or, in extreme cases, local police for a peaceful escort. Have a plan in advance.
Don’t change the decision under emotional pressure. Don’t promise anything you don’t intend to deliver. Don’t get drawn into a debate. The decision was made before the meeting started, and the meeting is for communicating it, not deciding it.
If the employee threatens to sue, acknowledge it briefly (“I understand. We’ve made this decision in good faith.”) and continue. Don’t apologize, don’t admit anything, don’t make new statements about the merits. Move forward with the steps.
What this looks like in your manual
Your handbook should include a termination procedure that lays out the company’s approach. The procedure doesn’t have to be a script, but it should reference:
The final-pay timing and content. The separation paperwork required by your state. The return-of-property expectation. The access-termination protocol. The protocol for communicating to the team.
We include a state-tailored termination procedure in the custom employee manual that comes with every AccompliCenter HR subscription. The procedure is what your managers reach for when they need to do this and don’t do it often. Plans start at $139 a month.
Termination is one of the parts of the job that nobody enjoys. Done with the checklist, it’s clean. Done without, it’s the most expensive mistake a small employer can make.
To subscribe, call us at (562) 444-8076, stop by our store at 3217 Carson St in Lakewood, or email service@accomplicenter.com.
See AccompliCenter HR plans →