Religious Accommodations: When You Have to Say Yes (And When You Don’t)
By John Hamilton, MS, PHRca, PHR · Reviewed for legal currency August 2026
I am not an attorney. This article is general information based on my experience as an HR professional, and it is not legal advice. For legal advice about your situation, consult a qualified attorney.
The short version
- Groff v. DeJoy replaced the de minimis standard in 2023. Undue hardship now means substantial increased costs in the context of your particular business.
- Coworker complaints and generalized administrative inconvenience are no longer a basis to deny a religious accommodation.
- The EEOC has not updated its own compliance manual since Groff, so a policy drafted from that document understates your obligations.
These rules change every year, and California adds its own. A subscription gives you a California-certified HR professional to check your answer before you act. Call (562) 444-8076, email service@accomplicenter.com, or come by our store at 3217 Carson St in Lakewood to sign up.
In June 2023, the Supreme Court decided Groff v. DeJoy. The decision didn’t change the words of the statute, which still says employers must provide religious accommodation unless doing so would impose “undue hardship on the conduct of the employer’s business.” What it changed was the meaning of “undue hardship.”
For forty-six years, courts had interpreted “undue hardship” using a phrase from a 1977 case (TWA v. Hardison) that said anything more than a “de minimis cost” qualified. Trivial costs were enough to deny religious accommodation. After Groff, that’s gone. The new standard is “substantial increased costs,” which is materially harder to meet.
Most small employers haven’t updated their religious accommodation analysis to reflect the change.
The framework
Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 prohibits employment discrimination based on religion. As part of that prohibition, employers are required to provide reasonable accommodation for sincerely held religious beliefs and practices, unless doing so would cause undue hardship to the business.
Title VII applies at 15 or more employees. State analogs (California’s FEHA, New York’s Human Rights Law, others) apply at lower thresholds and sometimes use different standards.
The structure of the analysis:
The employee notifies the employer of a religious belief or practice that conflicts with a workplace requirement.
The employer engages in an interactive process to identify possible accommodations.
If a reasonable accommodation exists that doesn’t cause undue hardship, the employer must provide it.
If no reasonable accommodation can be identified, or if all possible accommodations would cause undue hardship, the employer can decline.
What “religious belief or practice” means
The definition is broad. A religious belief or practice includes:
Traditional religious observance (sabbath, holy days, religious dress, dietary restrictions, prayer requirements).
Beliefs that aren’t part of an organized religion but are sincerely held and function in the employee’s life as religious beliefs.
Beliefs that other adherents of the same religion don’t share. Sincerity is the standard, not orthodoxy.
The employer is generally not allowed to question the religious nature of a belief or to require the employee to prove the belief is sincere. There are exceptions when the employer has a reasonable basis to question sincerity (the employee’s prior conduct contradicts the claimed belief, the request appears to be tactical rather than religious), but these are narrow.
What’s not religious: political beliefs (even strongly held), personal preferences framed as religious, generic moral views without religious foundation. The line gets blurry, but the basic distinction is between belief in something transcendent and personal opinions on secular matters.
The Groff change
Before Groff, employers could deny religious accommodation if providing it would cause anything more than “de minimis cost.” This was a very low bar. A small administrative inconvenience was enough.
After Groff, the standard is “substantial increased costs in relation to the conduct of the employer’s particular business.” This is materially harder to meet. The cost has to be substantial, not minor. The cost has to be in relation to the employer’s business, which means the analysis is contextual.
What hasn’t changed:
Employers don’t have to violate other employees’ rights or impose unequal burdens on coworkers in order to accommodate.
Employers don’t have to violate seniority systems established under collective bargaining or otherwise.
Employers don’t have to grant accommodations that would prevent the employee from performing essential functions, or that would create safety risks that can’t be reasonably mitigated.
What has changed:
A small administrative cost is no longer sufficient to deny accommodation.
The “we’d have to pay overtime to cover the shift” argument is no longer automatic. The cost has to be substantial.
Coworker preferences and complaints about an accommodation no longer count as undue hardship. Animosity from coworkers isn’t a basis to deny.
Common religious accommodation situations
- Sabbath and holy day observance. Schedule swaps, voluntary substitutes, schedule adjustments, partial day arrangements. Most cases can be accommodated through scheduling. The employer’s obligation is to make reasonable efforts to find a solution.
- Religious attire and grooming. Head coverings, beards, religious jewelry, modest dress. Workplace dress codes have to be flexible enough to accommodate religious observance unless a specific dress code element is essential (for example, OSHA-required protective gear, where the religious item can’t be safely worn).
- Prayer requirements. Brief breaks for prayer. Most can be accommodated through normal break time and minor schedule flexibility.
- Religious holidays. Time off for religious holidays beyond the employer’s standard holiday calendar. Often accommodated through PTO use, schedule swaps, or unpaid time off.
- Dietary restrictions. Generally low-burden in most workplaces. Accommodation might involve adjusting cafeteria offerings or allowing personal food storage.
- Refusal of certain duties. A pharmacy employee who declines to dispense certain medications, a hospitality employee who declines to serve alcohol, a clerk who declines to issue certain licenses. These cases are harder because the duty being declined may be central to the job. Reassignment to a different role or shift may be possible; other times the duty is genuinely essential and accommodation isn’t feasible.
The interactive process
Like the ADA, religious accommodation requires an interactive process. The structure looks similar.
Step 1. Recognize the request. The employee notifies the employer of a religious belief or practice that conflicts with a work requirement. The notification doesn’t have to be formal
Step 2. Engage in conversation. Explore the specific need, the proposed accommodation, possible alternatives
Step 3. Evaluate. Whether the requested accommodation is feasible. Whether alternatives might work. Whether providing the accommodation would cause substantial increased costs
Step 4. Decide and communicate. In writing. With reasoning that documents the interactive process
Step 5. Implement and revisit. If granted, the accommodation goes into effect. If circumstances change, the conversation can reopen
What the post-Groff analysis actually looks like
After Groff, an undue-hardship denial requires more documentation than before. The employer needs to show:
The cost of accommodation is substantial. Specific dollars, not generalities.
The cost is in relation to the employer’s particular business. A $5,000 accommodation cost might be substantial for a 10-employee landscaping company and not substantial for a 200-employee manufacturer. Context matters.
Alternatives have been considered and either don’t work or have similar costs.
The denial isn’t based on coworker complaints, customer preferences, or generalized administrative inconvenience.
Most denials that worked under the de minimis standard don’t work under the new standard. Schedule swaps, shift coverage costs, dress code modifications, brief accommodations during a workday: most of these are below “substantial” costs in most workplaces.
Substantial doesn’t mean monetary only. The Ninth Circuit held in May 2026 that patient-safety risk, operational disruption and staffing consequences can satisfy Groff in a healthcare setting. The EEOC has also made religious accommodation an enforcement priority, with six public settlements since August 2025, including one over a million dollars. What it has not done is update its own compliance manual, which still describes the pre-Groff standard.
State variations
Some states have stricter religious accommodation standards than federal even before Groff:
- California. Workplace Religious Freedom Act and FEHA require accommodation. CA’s standard has been broader than federal in some respects and may not have been substantially affected by Groff (because federal was previously narrower than CA, and Groff brought federal closer to CA).
- New York. State Human Rights Law and NYC Human Rights Law require accommodation with similar broad reach.
- Other states. Several have specific religious accommodation provisions, often with different specifics.
For multi-state employers, the higher standard governs in each state. A federal employer is now operating under a Groff-influenced standard everywhere; CA and NY employers may have to provide more.
What this looks like in your manual
Your handbook should have a religious accommodation section that:
States the company’s commitment to religious accommodation under federal and applicable state law. Describes the request process. References the interactive process. States that requests will be evaluated based on the post-Groff standard (substantial increased costs). Confirms that decisions will be documented in writing.
We include this in the custom employee manual that comes with every AccompliCenter HR subscription. The section was rewritten when Groff came down and reflects the substantial-increased-costs standard the courts are actually applying. Worth knowing: the EEOC has not updated its own compliance manual section on religion since Groff, so a policy drafted off that document will understate your obligations. Plans start at $139 a month.
If your handbook still describes religious accommodation using the pre-Groff “de minimis” framework, it’s out of date and may understate your obligations. Updating it is straightforward and worth doing before the next request comes in.
To subscribe, call us at (562) 444-8076, stop by our store at 3217 Carson St in Lakewood, or email service@accomplicenter.com.
See AccompliCenter HR plans →