HR Consulting

blogheader

What “At-Will Employment” Actually Means (And the 5 Words That Can Wreck It)

I am not an attorney. This article is general information based on my experience as an HR professional, and it is not legal advice. For legal advice about your situation, consult a qualified attorney.

The short version

  • At-will is the default in 49 states. Montana is the exception, and its default probationary period is now 12 months, extendable to 18.
  • Five phrases turn it off: “permanent position,” “long-term employment,” “as long as you perform,” “we’ll always have a place for you,” and a “good cause” list of termination reasons.
  • Progressive discipline written as “will” instead of “may” is a contract you then have to follow.

If this article raised a question about your own business, that is what our subscription is for. Plans start at $139 a month. Call (562) 444-8076, email service@accomplicenter.com, or come by our store at 3217 Carson St in Lakewood to sign up.

Most small employers will tell you their employees are at-will. Most of them are right in theory and wrong in practice, because their offer letters and their handbooks and their managers’ verbal promises have accidentally turned at-will employment off without anyone noticing.

At-will is a powerful default. It means you can terminate the employment relationship at any time, with or without notice, with or without cause, as long as the reason isn’t unlawful (no firing for protected-class reasons, no firing in retaliation for protected activity, no firing in violation of public policy). Forty-nine of fifty states recognize this default. Montana is the holdout, and its Wrongful Discharge from Employment Act was amended in 2025: the default probationary period during which an employer may discharge without good cause is now 12 months, extendable by the employer to 18.

Five phrases give at-will away more often than any others.

The five phrases that can wreck at-will

1. “Permanent position.” As in: “We’re pleased to offer you this permanent position.” Sounds reassuring. Means something specific in employment law. A “permanent position” is a position the employee holds permanently. The employee can argue, sometimes successfully, that you’ve contracted to keep them indefinitely as long as their performance is acceptable.

The fix is straightforward. Don’t use “permanent” anywhere in your offer letter or your handbook. Say “regular full-time position” or “ongoing position” or just “position” if you want to convey the same meaning without the implication.

2. “Long-term employment.” Same problem as “permanent.” Implies a duration commitment you don’t actually want to make. Same fix. Drop the phrase.

3. “As long as you perform.” As in: “You’ll have a job here as long as you perform.” Friendly. Reassuring. Creates an implied contract that says the employer will not terminate as long as performance is acceptable. Now if you terminate someone whose performance is debatable, you’ve broken the implied promise, and the question of whether their performance was actually acceptable becomes a question for a jury.

The fix is the same. Don’t say it. Don’t write it. Train your managers not to say it.

4. “We’ll always have a place for you.” Or any variation. “There will always be work here for you.” “We’ll take care of you.” “You’re family here.” These phrases are meant to be welcoming. They function as promises. A jury can find that the company committed to ongoing employment, and the employee can recover damages when the commitment isn’t honored.

I know operators say things like this without thinking, and I know they mean well when they do. The fix is to retrain the impulse. Welcome the new hire, express enthusiasm about working with them, do all of that. Just don’t promise them ongoing employment as part of it.

5. “Just cause” or “good cause” termination language in the handbook. Some handbooks say something like “the company may terminate employees for good cause, including…” and then list a set of categories. The intent is to communicate the kinds of behavior that lead to termination. The effect is to limit the company’s right to terminate to those categories, which means anything outside the list is not a permitted reason for termination.

This is one of the most common ways small-employer handbooks accidentally turn at-will off. The fix is to use language like “employment is at-will and may be terminated by either party at any time, with or without cause.” Then, if you want to give examples of behavior that leads to discipline, frame them as examples, not as the exclusive list. “Examples of conduct that may lead to discipline up to and including termination include, but are not limited to…”

The phrases that don’t wreck at-will but get used wrong

A few items that aren’t on the five-phrase list but cause similar problems.

Progressive discipline policies that read as commitments. A handbook that says “the company will use progressive discipline including verbal warning, written warning, final warning, and termination” creates an obligation. Now if you skip a step (say, you fire someone after a single bad incident), the employee has a claim that you violated the company’s own policy. The fix is to use “may” instead of “will.” “The company may use progressive discipline” reserves the flexibility you actually need.

Probationary periods. Some handbooks have a 90-day probationary period after which the employee is no longer probationary. The implication is that after probation, the employment relationship has changed. Some employees, and some lawyers, will argue this means at-will ended at the 90-day mark and the employee is now in a more protected status. The fix is either to drop the probationary concept entirely or to call it an “introductory period” and explicitly state that at-will applies during the introductory period and continues after it.

Annual reviews promised in writing. “The company will conduct annual performance reviews.” Now if you skip a year, the employee has a basis to argue you didn’t follow your own policy. Use “may” or restructure the policy as a description of practice rather than a commitment.

What to put in the offer letter

A good offer letter explicitly states at-will. Two places. First, in the offer itself: “This is an offer of at-will employment, which means that either you or the company may terminate the employment relationship at any time, with or without notice, with or without cause.” Second, in the acknowledgment the employee signs: “I understand and agree that my employment is at-will and that nothing in this letter or in any communication with the company creates a contract or a guarantee of continued employment.”

What to leave out: anything resembling “permanent,” “long-term,” “as long as you perform,” “there will always be a place for you,” or “we expect you to be here for years.” Even when these phrases are sincere expressions of welcome, they create legal exposure that didn’t have to be there.

The state exceptions to at-will

Even with strong at-will language in your offer letter and your handbook, every state recognizes some exceptions to at-will employment. The exceptions vary by state. The most common ones:

  • Public-policy exceptions. You can’t terminate someone for a reason that violates public policy. Filing a workers’ compensation claim, refusing to commit a crime at the employer’s direction, exercising a statutory right (like jury duty or whistleblowing). Most states recognize this exception.
  • Implied-contract exceptions. This is the exception the five phrases above can create. Some states recognize implied contracts based on offer letters, handbooks, or oral promises. California is among the broader of these.
  • Implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing. A small number of states recognize a duty of good faith in employment, which limits at-will somewhat. California, again, is among them.
  • Statutory exceptions. Federal and state anti-discrimination laws, anti-retaliation laws, FMLA, ADA, and others all carve out reasons you can’t terminate. These aren’t really exceptions to at-will. They’re the floor that at-will operates above.

The takeaway is that at-will isn’t absolute even where you’ve kept the language clean. It’s a strong default with specific carve-outs. Understanding the carve-outs is part of running a business with employees. Avoiding the five phrases above is the part you have direct control over.

What this means for your manual

A handbook that does its job will:

State at-will employment in the front of the document, in plain language. Repeat at-will employment in the acknowledgment the employee signs. Use “may” instead of “will” for any disciplinary, review, or process commitment that isn’t actually mandatory. Avoid “permanent,” “long-term,” “as long as you perform,” and similar phrases. Frame examples of disciplinable conduct as examples, not as an exhaustive list. Be reviewed periodically against your offer letters and your verbal practices to make sure they all line up.

We do this work as part of the custom employee manual that comes with every AccompliCenter HR subscription. State-specific, with at-will language built in correctly across the document and the acknowledgment, and aligned with your offer letter language. Plans start at $139 a month.

If you’re an at-will employer and you want to stay that way, the cheapest insurance is a handbook that does the language right. The most expensive accident is finding out at deposition that an offhand phrase in an offer letter has cost you the at-will protection you assumed you had.

To subscribe, call us at (562) 444-8076, stop by our store at 3217 Carson St in Lakewood, or email service@accomplicenter.com.

See AccompliCenter HR plans →

Store Hours

Today
  • Tue
    Nov 17

    8:30AM
    —
    6:00PM
  • Wed
    Nov 18

    8:30AM
    —
    6:00PM
  • Thu
    Nov 19

    8:30AM
    —
    6:00PM
  • Fri
    Nov 20

    8:30AM
    —
    6:00PM
  • Sat
    Nov 21

    9:00AM
    —
    4:00PM
  • Sun
    Nov 22

    10:00AM
    —
    3:00PM
  • Mon
    Nov 23

    8:30AM
    —
    6:00PM