I-9 for Small Businesses: A Plain-English Walkthrough (Plus the Self-Audit)
By John Hamilton, MS, PHRca, PHR · Reviewed for legal currency August 2026
I am not an attorney. This article is general information based on my experience as an HR professional, and it is not legal advice. For legal advice about your situation, consult a qualified attorney.
The short version
- Use the Form I-9 edition expiring 05/31/2027. The prior edition stopped being acceptable on August 1, 2026.
- Section 2 is due within three business days of the employee’s first day of work for pay.
- ICE reclassified more than ten error types as substantive on March 16, 2026. The 10-day cure window is gone and each form carries $288 to $2,861.
Employment law is complicated, and one mistake can cost far more than a year of help. An AccompliCenter HR subscription starts at $139 a month. Call (562) 444-8076, email service@accomplicenter.com, or come by our store at 3217 Carson St in Lakewood to sign up.
The I-9 form is one of those documents that most small employers fill out wrong, file wrong, and then forget about. ICE changed its enforcement policy on March 16, 2026 in a way that materially raises the cost of those errors. Run the self-audit below in the next 30 to 60 days.
What the I-9 is and why it exists
The Form I-9 verifies that the people working for you are eligible to work in the United States. It’s required by federal law for every new hire, regardless of citizenship, regardless of how long they’ll be working, regardless of whether they’re full-time, part-time, or seasonal. It’s a paperwork check, not an immigration enforcement function. You’re not investigating anyone. You’re confirming that the documents the employee presents look reasonably authentic and establish identity and work authorization.
The form has three parts. Section 1 is completed by the employee. Section 2 is completed by you, the employer, after looking at the employee’s documents. Supplement B is completed by you in limited situations (reverification, rehires within three years); on the current edition it replaces what used to be Section 3. Supplement A holds the preparer or translator certification.
The current edition of the form is the 01/20/25 edition with an expiration of 05/31/2027. Use the current edition for every new hire going forward. Download from uscis.gov/i-9.
The 3-day rule
The timing on Section 2 is the rule most small employers miss. Section 2 must be completed within three business days of the employee’s first day of work for pay. Not three calendar days. Three business days.
If the employee starts on a Monday, Section 2 must be completed by Thursday. If they start on a Friday, Section 2 must be completed by Wednesday of the following week. If they start work for less than three days (a one-day temp job, for example), Section 2 must be completed by the end of the first day.
The 3-day rule is a fineable item. Late completion is a paperwork violation, and ICE counts each one separately.
What documents to accept
Section 2 requires the employee to present documents that establish both identity and work authorization. The form has three lists.
List A documents establish both identity and work authorization in a single document. A US passport. A Permanent Resident Card. A foreign passport with an I-551 stamp. An employment authorization document.
List B documents establish identity only. A driver’s license. A state-issued ID card. A school ID with photo for those under 18.
List C documents establish work authorization only. A Social Security card. A birth certificate. An employment authorization document issued by DHS.
The employee chooses what to present. You don’t get to specify which documents they bring. They can bring one List A document, or one List B document plus one List C document. That’s it. You inspect the documents in their physical presence (or via the procedures for remote verification if eligible), record the document information on the form, and return the originals.
You can ask for additional documents only if what was presented isn’t reasonably acceptable on its face. You cannot ask for specific documents from a specific list. Specifying documents is a documentary practice violation, which is itself a fineable item separate from any actual paperwork error.
What the new enforcement landscape looks like
ICE changed its I-9 enforcement policy on March 16, 2026. The change matters.
Common paperwork errors that previously carried a 10-day cure window (where the employer could fix the error and avoid a fine) now trigger immediate fines of $288 to $2,861 per form. The cure window is gone for most paperwork violations. Worksite audits are up. The window to fix errors closes the moment a Notice of Inspection is served.
What this means in practice: the math on doing nothing has gotten worse. A small employer with 30 active employees and a few retained terminated-employee forms might have 35 to 40 forms on file. If each form has even one paperwork error, the exposure on a single inspection runs from $10,000 to $100,000 or more. The audit you do yourself, today, costs you only time. The audit ICE does later costs you money.
The self-audit
I’m telling every client to run an internal I-9 self-audit in the next 30 to 60 days. Tedious work. Worth doing.
Step 1. Pull every I-9 on file. Active employees and retained terminated-employee forms. Don’t skip the retained ones. Many of them are still subject to inspection, and many of them have errors
Step 2. Go through each form field by field. Section 1 must be completed and signed by the employee on or before the first day of work. Section 2 must be completed by the employer within three business days. Names, dates, document numbers, and signature lines all need to match what’s required
Step 3. Fix errors the right way. Draw a single line through the wrong entry, write the correction, initial, and date. No white-out. No backdating. No replacement forms
Section 1 corrections must be made by the employee, not by you. If the original Section 1 is missing information or has an error in the employee’s portion, the employee has to fix it. For former employees who can’t be reached, USCIS has an approved memo procedure that lets you document the error and the attempted correction. Use it. Document everything.
Step 4. If you use an electronic I-9 system, confirm the version. The prior edition, the one showing an expiration of 07/31/2026, stopped being acceptable on August 1, 2026. Only the edition showing 05/31/2027 may be used for new hires and reverifications. Get written confirmation from your vendor that their system generates the current edition. If it doesn’t, every form it produces is defective
Step 5. Dispose of forms past their retention window. I-9 forms must be retained for the later of three years from the hire date or one year from the termination date. Forms past that window are no longer required, and keeping them only adds to your audit exposure. Dispose of them per your records-retention policy
Section 1 vs Section 2 corrections
This is the part of self-audits that trips people up. Section 1 is the employee’s section. Section 2 is yours. They get fixed differently.
If you find an error in Section 1 (missing date, missing signature, missing field), the employee has to fix it. You can’t fix it for them, and you can’t have someone else sign for them. If the employee is still working for you, get them to make the correction in your physical presence (or via the remote procedures), with their initials and date.
If the employee no longer works for you and you can’t reach them, document the error and the unsuccessful attempt to correct. Use the USCIS memo procedure: a brief memo attached to the form explaining what the error is, when it was discovered, what efforts you made to reach the former employee, and that the correction couldn’t be made. This isn’t a fix. It’s a documented good-faith record that you tried.
If you find an error in Section 2 (your section), correct it yourself. Single line through the wrong entry, write the correction, initial, and date.
E-Verify by state
E-Verify is the federal program that runs employee information through DHS and SSA databases to verify work authorization. It’s voluntary at the federal level for most employers, but several states have made it mandatory.
E-Verify is mandatory for at least some private employers in roughly ten states, and the thresholds vary widely: Alabama, Arizona, Mississippi and South Carolina reach all or nearly all private employers; Florida at 25 or more; Georgia at 10 or more; North Carolina at 25 or more; plus Tennessee, Utah and Louisiana with their own thresholds. Ohio added a construction-sector mandate effective March 19, 2026 covering every nonresidential construction contractor, subcontractor and labor broker, with penalties of $250 to $25,000 per employee. Confirm your state’s threshold with the state agency before you rely on a number; the secondary sources disagree with each other.
California prohibits employers from requiring E-Verify as a condition of employment unless required by federal law or as a condition of receiving federal funds. If you’re a multi-state employer, this is one of the places where state law materially affects your I-9 program.
What an audit actually looks like
A formal ICE Notice of Inspection arrives in writing. The Notice gives you three business days to produce the I-9 forms for current and recent employees. The exact list of forms requested varies, but it’s typically all active and recent (last few years) employee files.
You assemble the forms. ICE reviews them. ICE issues findings, which can include substantive violations (employees not authorized to work) and paperwork violations (errors in form completion). Substantive violations carry separate, larger fines. Paperwork violations carry the $288 to $2,861 per-form range.
You may have an opportunity to negotiate down the paperwork findings if the errors are minor and the company has a documented compliance program. The self-audit you run before the inspection is part of that compliance documentation.
What this looks like in your manual
Your handbook should have a written I-9 retention and audit policy. It should reference your designated representative who handles I-9 completion and storage. It should reference the retention period (later of three years from hire or one year from termination). It should reference the self-audit cadence (annual is reasonable; biennial is the floor).
We include this in the custom employee manual that comes with every AccompliCenter HR subscription. State-tailored, including the E-Verify language for your state, with the I-9 procedures laid out for your designated representative. Plans start at $139 a month.
If you don’t have an I-9 procedure in writing and you haven’t audited your forms recently, the next 30 to 60 days are the right time to fix both. The window to fix paperwork errors closes the moment ICE shows up. Don’t wait.
To subscribe, call us at (562) 444-8076, stop by our store at 3217 Carson St in Lakewood, or email service@accomplicenter.com.
See AccompliCenter HR plans →