HR Consulting

blogheader

Background Check Laws for Small Employers (FCRA + State Ban-the-Box)

I am not an attorney. This article is general information based on my experience as an HR professional, and it is not legal advice. For legal advice about your situation, consult a qualified attorney.

The short version

  • The FCRA disclosure has to be a stand-alone document. Bundling it into the application is the most common violation and the basis of most class actions.
  • Pre-adverse notice with a copy of the report, a reasonable wait, then the adverse action notice. Skipping either one is a separate violation.
  • Fifteen states apply fair-chance rules to private employers. New York is not one of them at the state level, though New York City is.

You do not have to work through these rules alone. Our HR subscribers email or call us whenever a question comes up, and plans start at $139 a month. Call (562) 444-8076, email service@accomplicenter.com, or come by our store at 3217 Carson St in Lakewood to sign up.

Most small employers run background checks on new hires without thinking much about the legal framework around them. The check happens through a third-party vendor, the report comes back, the hire moves forward or doesn’t. The compliance is invisible until it isn’t.

The federal Fair Credit Reporting Act and a growing list of state ban-the-box laws regulate exactly when, how, and what you can do with the results of a background check. Skipping a step is the kind of thing that turns into a class-action FCRA claim, which has been one of the higher-volume employment-class-action categories for the past decade.

The FCRA process

Three steps, each required, in this order.

Step 1. Disclosure and authorization. Before you order the background check, you have to give the candidate a clear and conspicuous written disclosure that a background check will be obtained, and you have to get the candidate’s written authorization to obtain it. The disclosure has to be in a stand-alone document. Not buried in an application. Not bundled with other forms. A separate document

  • The most common FCRA violation is bundling. Operators put the disclosure on page 12 of the employment application. The class actions argue (often successfully) that this isn’t a stand-alone disclosure and the FCRA was violated. Damages are statutory at $100 to $1,000 per violation, plus attorney fees. Multiply by every applicant ever processed under the bundled form and the math gets ugly.
  • The fix is straightforward. A separate, stand-alone disclosure form. One page. The disclosure language. The authorization language. The candidate’s signature. That’s it.
  • Step 2: Run the check. The third-party consumer reporting agency (Checkr, Sterling, GoodHire, etc.) runs the check. The report comes back to you.

Step 3. If you’re considering an adverse decision, the pre-adverse and adverse action notices. If the report contains information you’re considering using as a basis for not hiring (or for some other adverse decision), you have to follow a two-step notice process

First, the pre-adverse action notice. You send the candidate a notice that includes a copy of the report and a copy of the FCRA “Summary of Your Rights.” You have to wait a reasonable time (typically five business days) before taking the adverse action, to give the candidate a chance to dispute or explain.

Second, the adverse action notice. After you’ve made the decision, you send the candidate a final adverse action notice that includes the consumer reporting agency’s contact information and informs the candidate of their right to obtain a free copy of the report and dispute its accuracy.

Skipping either notice is a separate FCRA violation. Skipping both is two violations per candidate. Class actions love this.

The “stand-alone document” rule in detail

The FCRA requires the disclosure to be “in a document that consists solely of the disclosure.” The Ninth Circuit and Third Circuit have read this strictly. A disclosure with a release of liability included in the same document violates the FCRA. A disclosure with state-law-specific notices included in the same document violates the FCRA.

The acceptable practice is a clean, single-purpose disclosure document. State-law notices that the FCRA specifically permits to be included can be included. Anything else has to be separate.

Vendor forms are the usual source. The vendor provides a form, the form looks reasonable, the form violates the standalone rule, and the class action follows years later when someone notices.

If you’re using a vendor for background checks, ask the vendor specifically: is your disclosure form compliant with the standalone rule under the FCRA. Get the answer in writing. If the answer is anything other than an unambiguous yes, get a different vendor or a different form.

State ban-the-box laws

Beyond the FCRA, an increasing number of states and cities prohibit asking about criminal history early in the hiring process and limit when and how a criminal record can be used in hiring decisions.

The general structure of a ban-the-box law is this. You can’t ask about criminal history on the initial application. You can ask later in the process (often after a conditional offer has been made). When you obtain criminal history information, you have to do an individualized assessment that considers the nature of the offense, the time since the offense, and the relationship between the offense and the job. You have to provide a copy of the report and an opportunity to respond before making an adverse decision.

Fifteen states have fair-chance hiring laws that reach private employers: California, Colorado, Connecticut, Hawaii, Illinois, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, Minnesota, New Jersey, New Mexico, Oregon, Rhode Island, Vermont and Washington. New York is the one people get wrong. New York State restricts how private employers may use criminal history (Correction Law Article 23-A and Human Rights Law § 296), but it has no statewide application-stage ban; the box comes off the application only in New York City, Buffalo, Rochester, Suffolk County and Westchester County. Many cities (Los Angeles, San Francisco, Seattle, Chicago, Philadelphia) have their own ordinances on top of state law.

The specifics vary substantially by state. California’s Fair Chance Act has a detailed individualized-assessment requirement and a specific notice-and-response timeline. New York City has specific notice requirements and timing. Each jurisdiction has its own rules, and a multi-state employer needs to handle each one separately.

What you can and can’t do with the results

Even after you have the report, what you can do with it is limited.

You can’t categorically exclude based on a criminal record. The EEOC’s 2012 criminal-record guidance is still posted, but the federal enforcement posture behind it has shifted: an April 2025 executive order directed agencies to deprioritize disparate-impact liability, and a June 2026 Justice Department opinion called the EEOC’s disparate-impact guidelines unlawful. Neither changes the statute or the Supreme Court precedent, private plaintiffs still bring these claims, and state law requires the individualized assessment outright. A blanket “no felonies” or “no convictions in the past 10 years” policy is still a bad policy.

You have to do the individualized assessment. Consider the nature of the offense, the time elapsed, the relationship to the job, the candidate’s explanation, evidence of rehabilitation, and any other relevant factors. Document the assessment.

You can’t use arrests as the basis for a decision. Most jurisdictions limit consideration to convictions, not arrests. Arrests without convictions generally can’t be used to deny employment.

You have to follow the FCRA notice process. Adverse action based on a criminal record still requires the pre-adverse and adverse action notices.

You can’t ask about expunged or sealed records in most jurisdictions. Expungement laws vary, but the general principle is that an expunged record doesn’t exist for employment-decision purposes.

When the screening is automated

California’s Civil Rights Department regulations, effective October 1, 2025, treat an automated decision system used in recruitment, screening, interviewing, selection or promotion as covered by FEHA. Anti-bias testing isn’t mandated, but whether you did it, how recently, and what it showed are all evidence in a discrimination defense, and the absence of testing is evidence too. Records tied to the system have to be kept four years, and you are liable for a vendor’s tool as if it were your own. Illinois amended its Human Rights Act effective January 1, 2026 to bar AI-driven discrimination and the use of ZIP codes as proxies for protected classes, and to require notice when AI is used in employment decisions; the implementing rules were withdrawn in June 2026 but the statute binds regardless. New York City requires an annual independent bias audit for automated employment decision tools, with the summary posted publicly and 10 business days’ notice to candidates. Texas prohibits developing or deploying AI with intent to discriminate, effective January 1, 2026. Colorado repealed and replaced its AI Act before it ever took effect; the replacement is a transparency law effective January 1, 2027. The EEOC pulled its own AI technical assistance documents in January 2025, so there is no federal playbook to follow. The state rules are the operative ones.

The credit report angle

If you’re using a credit report (not just a criminal background check), additional rules apply. Several states (California, Connecticut, Hawaii, Illinois, Maryland, Nevada, Oregon, Vermont, Washington, and others) restrict the use of credit reports in employment decisions to specific positions where credit history is materially related to the role. New York City has its own ordinance.

If you’re running credit reports as part of your background check process, audit which positions you’re running them for and confirm each position falls within the permitted categories under your state’s law.

The common mistakes

I see these regularly:

  • Bundled disclosure forms. The disclosure is part of the application packet, not a stand-alone document. FCRA violation.
  • No pre-adverse action notice. The operator decides not to hire based on the report, sends the rejection email, and never sent the pre-adverse notice with the report and Summary of Rights. FCRA violation.
  • Same-day adverse action. The operator sends the pre-adverse action notice and the adverse action notice on the same day, without giving the candidate time to respond. FCRA violation.
  • Categorical exclusion policies. The application or the policy says “no convictions” or “no felonies.” Disparate-impact and state-law issues.

Asking on the application in a ban-the-box jurisdiction. The application has a “have you ever been convicted of a crime” question, in a state or city that prohibits the question on the initial application.

Using arrests. The hiring decision relies on an arrest record, in a jurisdiction that prohibits arrest-based decisions.

Not doing the individualized assessment. The decision is “they have a felony, we don’t hire felons” without consideration of the specific offense, the time elapsed, the relationship to the job, or the candidate’s response.

What this looks like in your manual

Your handbook should reference your background check process, but the actual disclosure and authorization documents are typically separate. The handbook should:

State that background checks are part of the hiring process where applicable. Reference the FCRA disclosure and authorization process. Reference your individualized-assessment process for any adverse decision based on criminal history. Reference the ban-the-box compliance for your jurisdictions.

We include this in the custom employee manual that comes with every AccompliCenter HR subscription, with state-tailored language for the ban-the-box jurisdictions. We don’t draft the actual disclosure and authorization forms (those are typically provided by your background check vendor), but we make sure your handbook references the process correctly. Plans start at $139 a month.

If you’ve been running background checks without a stand-alone disclosure form, this is one of the higher-priority audits a small employer can do. Class actions in this space have hit small employers as well as large, and the fix is straightforward. Get the disclosure form right. Run the notice process. Document the individualized assessment.

To subscribe, call us at (562) 444-8076, stop by our store at 3217 Carson St in Lakewood, or email service@accomplicenter.com.

See AccompliCenter HR plans →

Store Hours

Today
  • Tue
    Nov 17

    8:30AM
    —
    6:00PM
  • Wed
    Nov 18

    8:30AM
    —
    6:00PM
  • Thu
    Nov 19

    8:30AM
    —
    6:00PM
  • Fri
    Nov 20

    8:30AM
    —
    6:00PM
  • Sat
    Nov 21

    9:00AM
    —
    4:00PM
  • Sun
    Nov 22

    10:00AM
    —
    3:00PM
  • Mon
    Nov 23

    8:30AM
    —
    6:00PM