HR Consulting

blogheader

Independent Contractor or Employee? The Test the IRS, DOL, and States Use

I am not an attorney. This article is general information based on my experience as an HR professional, and it is not legal advice. For legal advice about your situation, consult a qualified attorney.

The short version

  • Three different tests apply to the same hire, and you have to pass the strictest one that reaches you.
  • The ABC test’s (B) prong fails whenever the work is in your usual course of business, no matter how independent the relationship looks.
  • The federal picture is unsettled: the 2024 rule still governs private lawsuits, the DOL stopped enforcing it in May 2025, and a replacement was proposed in February 2026.

Fixing an HR mistake after the fact costs more than preventing it. Subscriptions start at $139 a month, and every plan includes a custom employee manual. Call (562) 444-8076, email service@accomplicenter.com, or come by our store at 3217 Carson St in Lakewood to sign up.

Calling someone a “1099 contractor” because it was simpler than putting them on payroll is one of the more expensive shortcuts in employment law. Misclassification is a high-volume enforcement target at the federal and state level, and the cost of getting it wrong is substantial: back wages, back overtime, unpaid taxes, unpaid workers’ compensation premiums, unpaid unemployment insurance contributions, penalties, and potentially personal liability for the owner.

The hard part is that three different tests apply to the same hire, and they don’t agree with each other. You have to pass the strictest of the three that applies to you.

The three tests

  • The IRS common-law test. Used for federal tax purposes. Looks at the degree of control the company has over the worker, organized into three categories: behavioral control (does the company control how the work is done), financial control (does the company control the business aspects of the worker’s job), and the type of relationship (written contracts, benefits, permanency). No single factor decides; the IRS looks at the totality.
  • The DOL economic-reality test. Used for federal Fair Labor Standards Act purposes (overtime, minimum wage). Six factors: the opportunity for profit or loss depending on managerial skill, investments by the worker and the employer, the degree of permanence of the work relationship, the nature and degree of control, the integral nature of the work to the employer’s business, and the skill and initiative required. The federal picture is unsettled in a way that matters to you. The 2024 rule setting out that six-factor test is still on the books and still governs private lawsuits, but the Department told its own investigators on May 1, 2025 to stop applying it in enforcement and to use the older 2008 and 2019 framework instead, and on February 27, 2026 it proposed rescinding the rule outright in favor of a two-factor test built on control and opportunity for profit or loss. The proposal is not final. Classify to satisfy the 2024 rule anyway. The enforcement bulletin binds Department investigators and nobody else, and a private plaintiff can still sue under the rule as written.
  • The state ABC test. Used in several states for state wage and hour, unemployment insurance, and workers’ compensation purposes. Three prongs, all of which must be satisfied for independent-contractor classification: (A) the worker is free from the employer’s control and direction in performing the work, (B) the work is performed outside the usual course of the employer’s business, and (C) the worker is customarily engaged in an independently established trade, occupation, or business of the same nature.

ABC is the strictest of the three tests, particularly the (B) prong. If the work is part of the employer’s usual course of business, the (B) prong fails, regardless of how independent the relationship looks otherwise. A construction company can’t classify its construction workers as independent contractors under ABC, even if they have other clients and set their own hours, because their work is in the usual course of the construction company’s business.

Which test applies to you

Federal tax classification: IRS common-law test.

Federal wage and hour: DOL economic-reality test.

State wage and hour, unemployment, workers’ comp:

ABC test states: California (AB 5 codified Dynamex), New Jersey, Massachusetts, Connecticut, Illinois (limited application), Vermont, and a small number of others. In these states, you have to pass the ABC test for state purposes.

Common-law or modified states: Most other states use the IRS common-law test, the DOL economic-reality test, or some hybrid for state purposes.

Industry-specific carve-outs: California’s AB 5 has a long list of statutory carve-outs (certain professions, certain types of business-to-business contracts, etc.). Other states have similar carve-outs. If you’re in a covered industry with a carve-out, the analysis is different.

The practical version: if you’re in California, New Jersey, Massachusetts, Connecticut, or Illinois (within ABC application), you have to pass the ABC test for state purposes. The IRS test and DOL test still apply for federal purposes, but ABC is the most demanding.

The (B) prong problem in California

California’s AB 5 has been the most consequential independent-contractor law of the past decade. The (B) prong requires that the work be outside the usual course of the employer’s business. The carve-outs are specific and limited.

The result: most workers performing work that’s part of an employer’s usual course of business are now employees in California, even if they have other clients, even if they set their own hours, even if they have written independent-contractor agreements, even if they prefer 1099 status.

Common situations where AB 5 has changed the analysis:

A delivery driver for a delivery company is an employee, not a contractor (delivery is the company’s usual business). A graphic designer hired by a graphic design firm for a project is typically an employee for that work. A janitor hired by a janitorial services company to do janitorial work is an employee. A truck driver for a trucking company is an employee. A construction worker for a construction company is an employee.

Carve-outs that allow contractor classification despite AB 5 include licensed professionals (doctors, lawyers, accountants, engineers in specific roles), certain service providers operating as legitimate business-to-business arrangements, certain creative professionals (with specific requirements), and several industry-specific categories. App-based rideshare and delivery drivers are carved out separately by Proposition 22, which the California Supreme Court upheld unanimously in July 2024.

If you’re a California employer and you have anyone classified as a 1099 who’s doing work in your usual course of business, run the analysis. The penalty for getting this wrong includes Labor Code violations under PAGA, which can reach into significant per-violation penalties on top of back wages.

What “usual course of business” actually means

The (B) prong language sounds simple and isn’t. Courts have read “usual course of business” broadly. If the work the contractor is doing is the kind of work the company’s employees do, or the kind of work the company’s customers pay for, it’s in the usual course.

A few examples that pass (B):

A landscaping company hires an accountant to do its books. Accounting isn’t the landscaping company’s business. (B) is satisfied.

A restaurant hires a marketing consultant to revamp its branding. Marketing isn’t the restaurant’s business. (B) is satisfied.

A small business hires an HR consultant to handle a specific compliance project. HR consulting isn’t the small business’s business. (B) is satisfied (subject to the rest of the analysis).

A few examples that fail (B):

A landscaping company hires a “1099 landscaper” to mow lawns. Landscaping is the company’s business. (B) fails.

A restaurant hires a “1099 server” to wait tables. Serving is the restaurant’s business. (B) fails.

A construction company hires a “1099 carpenter” to do framing. Carpentry is the company’s business (in most construction contexts). (B) fails.

If you can’t pass (B), the worker is an employee under ABC, regardless of how the rest of the relationship looks.

The cost of misclassification

  • The math on getting this wrong is bad. Three categories of exposure.
  • Back wages and overtime. If the contractor was actually an employee, they should have been paid minimum wage and overtime. Federal back-pay runs up to two years (three if willful). State back-pay runs longer in some states. Plus liquidated damages.
  • Unpaid taxes. The employer should have paid Social Security, Medicare, federal unemployment, and state unemployment on the wages. The employer should have withheld income tax. The IRS will pursue the missing employer taxes plus penalties. Section 530 relief is available in some cases but isn’t guaranteed.
  • Unpaid workers’ comp premiums. The contractor should have been covered by workers’ compensation. The state insurance fund or your private carrier will pursue the missing premiums.
  • Other state-specific penalties. PAGA in California, similar private attorney general statutes elsewhere. Misclassification penalties under wage and hour codes. Civil penalties for failure to provide wage statements, meal and rest breaks, and other employee-only protections.

For a single misclassified worker over two years, the total exposure can run from tens of thousands to over a hundred thousand dollars. Multiple misclassified workers compound the problem.

What to do if you have contractors right now

Audit the relationships. For each 1099 worker, ask the three questions:

Is the worker free from your control and direction in performing the work (A). Is the work outside your usual course of business (B). Is the worker customarily engaged in an independent trade or business of this nature (C).

If you can answer yes to all three with documentation, the worker is a contractor under ABC. If you can’t, you have a misclassification.

For workers who fail the analysis, the options are:

Convert them to W-2 employees going forward. Restructure the relationship so the (B) prong (or the relevant prong) is satisfied (this is hard if the work is in your usual course of business). Continue as is and accept the exposure.

The third option is what most operators end up doing through inertia. The exposure compounds over time.

What this looks like in your manual

Your handbook applies to W-2 employees, not to independent contractors. But your handbook should:

State that the company evaluates worker classification based on legal standards, not on preference or contract language. Establish that classification decisions are made centrally (not by individual managers). Reference that contractors are not employees and don’t receive employee benefits or protections.

If you have a separate template for contractor agreements, that should reflect the requirements of the applicable test. We don’t write contractor agreements (those are typically lawyer-drafted and project-specific), but we make sure your handbook addresses the classification question correctly. Plans start at $139 a month.

If you’re using 1099 workers in your usual course of business, especially in California or another ABC state, the audit is the most important compliance project you can do. The cost of converting a misclassified worker is much smaller than the cost of getting caught after years of back exposure.

To subscribe, call us at (562) 444-8076, stop by our store at 3217 Carson St in Lakewood, or email service@accomplicenter.com.

See AccompliCenter HR plans →

Store Hours

Today
  • Tue
    Nov 17

    8:30AM
    —
    6:00PM
  • Wed
    Nov 18

    8:30AM
    —
    6:00PM
  • Thu
    Nov 19

    8:30AM
    —
    6:00PM
  • Fri
    Nov 20

    8:30AM
    —
    6:00PM
  • Sat
    Nov 21

    9:00AM
    —
    4:00PM
  • Sun
    Nov 22

    10:00AM
    —
    3:00PM
  • Mon
    Nov 23

    8:30AM
    —
    6:00PM